Po Kuan - Malaysia needs you to create history to deny BN 2/3 parliamentary majority
It’s 2.45 am. Endless series of meetings, internal and external, in the past 72 hours, putting me on the road from Petaling Jaya to Perak, Penang and down to Kuala Lumpur and Petaling Jaya, including two ceramahs with Po Kuan in Batu Gajah parliamentary constituency on Friday night and the launching of two election operation centres (Tebing Tinggi and Menglembu in Perak) as well as visit to traditional DAP stronghold in Kuala Lumpur, the Bukit Bintang parliamentary constituency, but which has now become a “danger” seat because of electoral manipulation in the influx of over 6,000 postal voters.
Have been up for 22 hours – including a five-hour marathon meeting of DAP and Parti Keadilan Rakyat leaders which ended with primary agreement for one-to-one contest between DAP or PKR with the Barisan Nasional in Peninsular Malaysia states - with the last meeting just ended an hour ago.
Very tired but no thought of sleep until I blog about Fong Po Kuan. Not just because I have been made the villain causing Po Kuan’s announcement that she would not contest in the 12th general election but also because of her qualities.
At about 2.30 p.m., I received calls asking why I had forced Po Kuan to retire from politics, as AIFM (Chinese) received by motorists had carried news flash that Po Kuan had announced her resignation from the DAP because of her unhappiness with me in forcing her to contest in another constituency.
I never did such a thing and Po Kuan never resigned from the party – but the damage was done, as first impressions (however false) are most lasting, that I had forced Po Kuan to resign from the DAP because I was forcing her to contest in another constituency apart from Batu Gajah. Talking about “eating dead cat”!
The party never asked Po Kuan to change constituencies, as all party leaders had expected and fully supported her to contest for the third time in the Batu Gajah parliamentary seat.
I will not be speaking the truth if I say that Po Kuan’s announcement yesterday had come as a complete surprise to me, although it was a shock to the overwhelming majority of DAP leaders, members and supporters.
I had tried to head off Po Kuan from making such a decision because she is a great asset to the party, Malaysian Parliament and the cause for justice, freedom and democracy but I failed. For this I take full responsibility.
I had skimmed through both the avalanche of comments on her blog and my blog. Po Kuan should know that she is looked up as a beacon of hope for Malaysians in the hard and grueling battle for justice, democracy and a Bangsa Malaysia.
I fully associate with the outpouring of public appeals to Po Kuan to reconsider and rejoin the DAP frontline in the great electoral battle looming before the nation by again standing for the parliamentary seat of Batu Gajah – as DAP, the people and nation need her to create history to deny the Barisan Nasional its unbroken two-thirds parliamentary majority on March 8, 2008 to usher in a new democracy and a new Malaysian politics.
Before I conclude, let me confess that in the past 72 hours, I had departed from my practice since the start of my blog to read every comment published on my blog whether before or after publication – but with the dissolution of Parliament, time simply does not permit it.
As a result, I have not been able to respond to the many legitimate questions raised particularly over donations to the DAP Election Fund. I thank you for your support and let me assure you that every sen of the on-line donation would be fully accounted, audited and made public after the general election.
We need far more financial support from you as what the DAP Election Fund needs to prepare for the “Battle of the Century” in the 12th general election is many many times more than the amounts which have come through online.
Thanks are in order for volunteers led by GKT for taking over management of this blog since the past 72 hours till the end of the election campaign. Let us give GKT and team the time to go through the queries of the past 72 hours and to respond to them.
February 18th, 2008 at 04: 20.58
Uncle Kit,
Take a good night rest. You must be very tired by now. It’s good to hear that DAP and PKR have reached a one to one agreement in penisular malaysia.
Malaysians still need po kuan. I truly hope that she will reconsider her decision.
February 18th, 2008 at 04: 34.05
YB Po Kuan,
As I read this post by Uncle Lim, tears just welled up in my eyes.
Its never easy to be in politics & to find yourself as opposition in Malaysia is a million times harder. Yet against all odds (especially against Ong Ka Chuan, he thought he could easily turn you into meat balls) you have victoriously sailed through.
You have become a symbol for democracy & Justice emerging from the much needed 2nd wave of younger generation to take the baton from Uncle Lim. Constant pressure not just from BN but from within will come at times to deal you with a killer blow. It is at times like this that one rises above the occasion, like pure gold being refined 7 times ferocious heat in the furnace.
Of all the many opposition leaders coming from the younger generation, YB Po Kuan, you are one of that rare pure gold!
So, I urge you & encourage you to take the bigger picture, it is noy just DAP that needs you at this crictical moment in history with every tell tale sign that the nation is facing grave danger of turning into a dictatorship regime, Malaysians need you!
May God grants you the wisdon & understanding & overwhelms you with love & affection & May He protects you with a shield for your coming in & going out. Amen!
February 18th, 2008 at 04: 49.05
Uncle Lim please take care! Lots of vitamin B & C help fight stress.
May God bless you & your whole team.
February 18th, 2008 at 05: 20.50
Which sets me wondering! If the DAP cannot sort out its internal issues, how is the party doing in its negotiations with its electoral partners like PKR and PAS over constituencies??
February 18th, 2008 at 05: 39.44
If Po Kuan is not standing in BG for the Parliamentary seat, who is? If she is a loyal DAP member, she should abide by whatever decision the DAP leadership has taken after weighing the overall interest of the party, a party she has dedicated her life to working for. Sending her off to Johor is in the best interest of her party and she should put that interest before her personal interest.
Is she saying that her loyalty comes with a price?
February 18th, 2008 at 06: 10.25
Uncle Lim
Generally, the entire fiasco is now under the BM’s media circus. Let alone the intention of making the announcement at such hours. If needed so, she needs to reconsider. It’s never too late and not that the country is going to be empty without her. It’s important all party members reach out to her. But if she herself wants it that way, we need all have to accept it, gracefully and concentrate on a bigger picture
February 18th, 2008 at 07: 06.51
She should know very well she had to suffer when she offered herself to DAP. DAP is not like BN or any of its component parties where one can enjoy life and merriment each day. Being in DAP means sacrificing wealth, riches, prestige, time, dedication and lots more for the rakyat. She should have known this right from day one, not after 2 terms as MP! How come it took her so long to realize it???? Or is it another LLT in the making???
February 18th, 2008 at 07: 17.28
Respect her decision and wishes.
Po Kuan knows when it is time to let go…..with her support, the new candidate could do better.
The first flower was found in China…about 130 millions years ago.
February 18th, 2008 at 07: 28.25
YB Fong,
You are looked up to in BG. Do keep up your good work and retain the seat. If it is help you need in the constituency, call for volunteers and we will come out to help. You will need this help as you have now started a new chapter in your personal life. We all wish you well in this, but we still wish for you to lead BG.
God bless!
February 18th, 2008 at 07: 46.17
This shows her immaturity and selfishness. She should not have done it at this last hour. Putting self first ahead of the interest of the people. Lives goes on, people who vote DAP will continue to support despite her resignation. This is a temporary setback nia. But if she comes to the realization that it is the party that makes her what she is today than I do hope that she will reconsider.
February 18th, 2008 at 07: 55.38
Dear YB,
Looking through YB Fong’s blog, we can see how popular she is among us. None of the 90 comments I read so far wants her to quit. She is really an asset to the country and any other party will want her to be theirs. So, I really do wish she can be persuaded to contest in this coming election. May God bless this country.
February 18th, 2008 at 08: 26.05
I don’t think you forced Fong Po Kuan to resign. But the question remains, what is the problem between Fong Po Kuan and DAP? She is turning down her own seat as I understand it. No matter how you look at it, a failure of leadership is part of it.
February 18th, 2008 at 08: 33.25
“The party never asked Po Kuan to change constituencies, as all party leaders had expected and fully supported her to contest for the third time in the Batu Gajah parliamentary seat.”
Poh Kuan acted on rumors that the party had betrayed her? If so, it was certainly unwise on Poh Kuan’s part to go public to express her grievances, moreover, the impression I got when I saw the announcement in TV was that of a vengeance. Only time will tell the real story now.
February 18th, 2008 at 08: 37.45
YB Po Kuan,
Whatever your feelings and those swirling thoughts, I understand. There will always be moments in our lives when we get a little overwhelmed by the exigencies of the occasion.
However, (and I believe this is where most Malaysians and DAP supporters would agreee), there are times and critical moments in the course of our lives when we extend beyond the furthest reach of our arms and exert our fullest with little thought for ourselves but for the ‘task’ at hand (such as when a boy plunges into a mining pool to save a kid, thinking nothing of the dangers or when a mother buries her child beneath her frail frame to protect her child in a head-on collision).
This is one such moment in Malaysian History, Po Kuan…when all those fiery speeches you have made are now heaved onto the burner to test its mettle. Long after the dust has settled, we will have time to reflect…we pray the nation will remember the sacrifices made by those indefatigable souls that plodded on whilst other wearied colleagues fell behind. Wasn’t it the Scouts Movement that has its motto: ‘Service before Self’? Why should polticians who answer the call in the hour of battle for the soul of the nation have a lesser clarion call?
Po Kuan, some day I hope to shake your hands and thank you personally for your steadfastness and sacrifices at the expense of your personal safety and comfort.
Meanwhile, whatever you decide, please be assured that the nation and we, your friends and supporters, owe you enough.
February 18th, 2008 at 08: 39.24
What so great about YB Fong Po Kuan? Let her go…. noone is indispensable. One flower gone ….another millions come.
February 18th, 2008 at 08: 51.39
Po Kuan should know that she is looked up as a beacon of hope…….says Lim Kit Siang.
Fong Po Kuan, get back to work and stop being so childish. This is an order!
Says who?
RAKYAT MALAYSIA!
February 18th, 2008 at 08: 54.18
Do you think that Po Kuan is having personal problem instead of party problem and it leads to her decision for not taking part in this GE?
DAP central should take the prompt action to persuade again if it is for the benefit of DAP and the people of Msia for CHANGE.
February 18th, 2008 at 08: 58.02
I take LKS words in good faith. Being the pillar of DAP you should know what is best and what will work for DAP. Nevertheless what it is more important at this point of time is to ensure crisis does not crop up within DAP or opposition parties simply for seat allocation and favorite candidates did not get to choose.
We the supporters do not want to see bickering (if there is please resolve quickly) in Oppositions as in our mind they are our Alternative for BN. Should someone smart and upcoming politician like Po Kuan were to come out openly accusing unfairness and cronysm polluting DAP and other opposition especially at time like this it will a credibility issue and for fence sitters, it may as well be end of story for DAP.
THE BATTLE IS OUT THERE AND NOT AMONGST YOU.
February 18th, 2008 at 09: 14.21
Guys, The battle is out there and NOT among yourselves! Lets get it right, if you cannot get it right among your selves, how you going to fight all the Aligators of BN? Lets work towards denying BN 2/3 majority……..DAP Boleh!
February 18th, 2008 at 09: 14.32
Malaysia Politic are never a gentlemen ground and corruption level are always the highest stake in town. When we talk about power and wealth, no one will want to let go that opportunity to rule.
We have been reading far too many issue over the current government and far too many more to be digest by us.
YB Fong, it’s never easy to understand what’s really going on as being where you are today and given the duties that you have rendered. At end of everything, we are still human that made mistakes, selfish and greed. It could have been that others in your camp are ‘chewing’ you up with pressures and speculations, yet, coming from that kind of grounds, you must not quit.
Kindly look beyond the horizon of doubts and depairs, tell yourself that you can do it and moreso, you will benefit more by learning from it.
February 18th, 2008 at 09: 17.11
Looking at it on the bright side, the ever over zealous BN owned media has latched on to this with intent to a negative `song and dance`.
Now all it needs is a reversal just as Badawi`s hindu war of roses. Then they fall on their faces and get jeered.
February 18th, 2008 at 09: 27.51
Po Kuan,
I feel like watching my favourite Liverpool losing to 2nd Div. Barnsley; hate it but there’s nothing I could do. You are still young, so all the best to you and your young family.
February 18th, 2008 at 09: 30.28
///I never did such a thing and Po Kuan never resigned from the party/// – but “never resigned from the party” does not mean Po Kuan is contesting in Batu Gajah or any other constituency.
Out of respect for YB LKS, I will acept his words but still why is Po Kuan not contesting in Batu Gajah or any other constituency and what are the circumstances that led her to withdraw from the frontline in first place?
Very sad that the mainstream papers are now having a field day exploiting the propaganda value of this deveopment. Read : The Star 18th Feb page - “Fong drops a bomb†with prominent byline - “I’ve had enough. The development of internal party events in Perak DAP over the last few years and currently has made it impossible for me to continue serving effectively….â€
How could DAP national leadership have no control or not aware of “internal party events in Perak DAP over the last few years and currently”?
You’re not supposed to be “somnambulant” leadership that you accused Badawi’s of! Or it is suggested here that Po Kuan is not telling truth? I don’t believe this.
On page N3, another opposition member MDP’s head Wee Choo Keong gave his take under “Beware the daggers in DAP†and spoke of how DAP’s “potential leaders are marginalised, if not killed off politically†due to nepotism in DAP where “selfish and personal ambitions†were placed above principles and ideals for the people….[Ref Pg N3 of The Star Monday 18th ].
On the very eve of general election, the DAP is now attacked not just by BN but by a fellow Oppositionist - MDP’s Wee - the very man that was parachuted in 1990s to contest the Bukit Bintang Constitutency over the head of loyalist, KC Cheah.
You have a big problem. Please solve it.
February 18th, 2008 at 09: 38.43
I believe both DAP and Po Kuan’s reputation is on the line here. Coming so close to the elections, it demonstrates a certain chink in the leadership of DAP, and at the same time shows a certain lack of moral responsibility on Po Kuan’s part. For what it is that Perak DAP can do to really make it difficult for her to carry out her work? Has she been backstabbed? If so, it is not circulated in the national rumour mill.
It raises the question of whether Po Kuan is aware of her importance in Perak electoral politics. If she is, and she took it to the press stinging comments about Perak leadership, then it would seem like she is playing politics, and worse, the possibility that she has been “bought over”. I pray that this is not the case, and that fences can be mended. For a start, Perak leadership should give a full and frank account to national leadership of what is going on, and everyone have a sit down session with Po Kuan.
We have to bear in mind that whatever it is, damage is done. Should Po Kuan now return to Batu Gajah, she may be accused of creating this drama. If she does not come back, Perak DAP may be punished by her supporters.
Why on earth must this happen at this very critical time? Such is the rough and tumble of politics.
February 18th, 2008 at 09: 40.13
Dear Po Kuan, pls continue to serve the people especially those from Johor. We in Johor also need a strong representative like you. Come to Bakri/Muar/Segamat/Sekijang/Labis to create another history. What r u afraid of after beating Ong Ka Chuan? For sure ur husband must encourage you to serve Johoreans. If you can’t even handle internal pressure, how can you handle external attacks that are more dangerous! This is the experience that every great leader must go through! Stand up! Po Kuan!!
February 18th, 2008 at 09: 42.36
Dear YB, much as I hate to say it, you are right:
You have failed and rightfully, should be accountable. If one cannot keep one’s house in order, I shudder to think how one may manage a country.
What could possibly the best chance for the Opposition to wrest away seats from the ‘Bedebah Nasional’ now seems another exercise in futility. And you expect us, the rakyat to just vote blindly??
I will still vote the opposition, not because you are better, but because BN is worse! And that, my dear YB, is a damning verdict of what I think of politicians these days!
February 18th, 2008 at 09: 50.43
YB Lim,
Please do more to retain YB Poh Kuan. We need more people like her and YB Lim to stand up for the people in Parliament. To quote YB Lim, it’s Time To Walk The Talk, not time for internal crisis. Thank you for reading.
Lorkh
February 18th, 2008 at 09: 53.47
It was indeed a shocking news for news this Monday morning. YB Fong, regardless of any internal party bickering which I am sure that it has taken a toll on you, please be mindful that the entire BN machinery will capitalise on this episode to broadcast to the entire nation that DAP is a disunited party and should be rejected. This will cause DAP the precious votes it needs to get considering the timing of the announcement. The damage has been done but we should not give up to convince the rakyat that still the corrupt BN regime should be rejected at all cost.
Enough is enough
Time for change
Deny BN 2/3 majority
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 10.24
LKS, it’s sad to hear about FPK’s decision not to contest in the upcoming 12th GE.
two things need to be done,
1. there’s been too much of political in-fighting over the years. if party is serious about the rakyat’s welfare, plse stopped this immediately, irrespective of who’s who! I strongly urge you and your son to convince FPK to stay on in BG for the good of the locals whom she has grown to be part of them. also to be fair to the local rakyat who have grown to like her and supported her.
2. FPK, plse, i urge you to reconsider your decision. there have been outpouring of public appeals for you to stay on. come what may be, stay on to fight whatever internal squabbles there may be. since the DAP leadership had informed that you’ll still be the candidate for BG, give it another try. you are needed by the rakyat to deny the BN its 2/3 majority
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 22.28
Bakri/Muar/Segamat/Sekijang/Labis or Batu Gajah doesn’t matter.
What matter mosts is Fong PK shouldn’t doubt Lim KS’s sincerity. He gave you a chance last election, again he is appealing you to re-consider. Should you stay, that’s more than enough to send a message to the Perak DAP leadership that you’re RELEVANT!
Good luck!
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 24.01
YB Fong, live up to your title of cili padi and don’t disappoint us. You owe it to us to perform, not to please anyone in the DAP by resigning. If the going gets tough, toughened up more! No pain no gain. If you give up now, you will see yourself ridicule by your very adversaries not only within DAP, but the laughing stocks which is the BN and the component parties alike. If you feel committed to the democratic righteous cause, rethink…………..you should look at the bigger pictures, beyond just Batu Gajah, but the plights of others in Malaysia as we are suffering now in PJ because of BN policies.
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 27.05
Po Kuan is perceived as ‘fresh blood’ and ‘hopeful young female leader’ in politics. She should keep on fighting in politics. Malaysians will surely appreciate her contributions and efforts. Don’t give us impression that DAP cannot keep its house in order. Don’t give us impression that Po Kuan is not having a fighting spirit. Give us hope just like Barack Obama offers Americans a dream of hope. One of my most admired politicians is Lee Kuan Yew who fought in 1965 against powerful UMNO and MCA till Singapore was forced seperated from Malaysia. Look at his speechs in 1965, it is full of fighting spirit.
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 27.06
YB Fong Po Kuan,
Please do not resign. Malaysia needs your leadership.
Please.
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 27.53
i feel so disappointed to Po Kuan…
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 28.30
I would like add to what I said earlier. I have just read Po Kuan’s blog that is being flooded with request to change her mind. Differences in opinions and choices are something you can never get rid of in any parties be it Opposition or BN. I believe YB LKS is still within reach to get Po Kuan change her mind despite her claim. It is very important, anything from now no matter how tiny it could be, BN and their media will play big on them to portray a bad picture. Star gave such a big coverage to Po Kuan statement, it did not end there, they have stories on insiders who came up with reasons to substantiate their claim. Do you think they will do if it involves BN? ALL THESE ARE VERY BAD AND WILL WORK AGAINST OPPOSITION IF NOT RECTIFIED AND WEE CHOO KEONG MADE IT WORST.
In my comment I have requested Po Kuan to change her mind and I am going to ask all my friends to do the same. I request all who read this to do the same if you haven’t until we see 1000 or more. Truth is we have joined the battle to destroy the evil and we can’t afford to lose anyone on our side before the battle is over.
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 33.13
It is an open secret that Chinese education background DAP leaders are always sidelined by those banana men who cannot speak and write their own mother tongue.
Anyway, as a professional politician, Po Kuan shall not abuse general election to express her unhappness against Perak state DAP top leadership. There are better ways to resolve DAP internal strife and please don’t give opportunity to BN to tarnish the image of DAP and opposition parties.
I appeal Po Kuan to withdraw her decision for the sake of country and party.
??????????????
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 33.19
i decided …to starve myself………..until you change your mind….so poh kuan remember….my death will be on your mind…forever n forever…! do you want that…??
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 41.18
She maybe put her new familiy life to first place afterall she already reach 35-year old. Time is running out for any girl at that age to have baby.
She may not wanted to be first pregnant MP in Malaysia.
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 41.29
I say let her go. Personally I won’t ask her back. If she can’t handle DAP Perak, how can she handle UMNO? It’s just silly, at the stage she pulls this type of stunts. Let her go, even if she got reelected, I can see the next Lee Lam Thye in the making. Shame on her!
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 42.39
I read from newspaper today about the Feng Shui master told that the BN will still win the 2/3 majority.
I really hope that it is not true.BUT after YB Fong’s case, it looks like the possibility of what the Feng Shui master said. Very sad!
Another case is the Sg Puyu & Bagan case, it will definately affect the vote.I really do not understand if DAP can place Karpal to contest in Bagan.
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 45.19
“I read from newspaper today about the Feng Shui master told that the BN will still win the 2/3 majority.”
Unfortunately it is true. I consulted an internationally acclaimed psychic who came out with the same view. Coincidence?? I don’t think so.
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 46.22
Anyone runs a business know this is normal thing to happen, yes it happened at the most crucial moment.
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 49.15
Dear Mr Lim Sr & Mr Lim Jr,
Please appreciate talent and thier voice in the party as what you request on bn. successive internal fighting would ruin party and would be destructive if it was start from the top leadership level.
Cannon should only point out!
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 49.19
Let this be a lesson to all opposition leaders, as their decision can be a joke on fellow Malaysians.
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 49.40
Nobody should be made to feel she is indispensable. The King is dead. Long live the King! Remember that??
February 18th, 2008 at 10: 55.05
DAP is not a military junta, everyone is free to make their choice to come and go. Come and serves the rakyat, go quietly if you had have enough, everyone know DAP is a tough place to survive. Join BN if you want to get rich!
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 02.25
Let her go, she might have plans.
A politician’s job, how to describe it? It is thankless. Get scolding for nothing. I was at Po Kuan’s age when offered to stand under BN. NO, I didn’t jump excited, instead I looked at what I wanted in life. I hated sleepless nights, hated long meetings, away from family. I hated (and still is) greeting people ‘datuk-datuk, tan sri, datuk sri..’ I didn’t have dreams of richness, big fat contracts etc.
On the other hand, I had a job, not great but good job, and young family. I could say what I think fit and enjoyed the freedom of being an unknown. When I weighed one against the other, the choice was obvious.
Now Po Kuan made her choice. Sad and disappointed you might be, respect it.
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 06.09
Firstly, Po Kuan should not opt out even being marginalised by the main stream DAP leaders. The reason being : 1. U are a capable politician with ideals and principles. 2. U can retain the BG seats with your personal charisma which took 8 long years to cultivate. 3. U need not run away from the bunch of selfish leaders who look for personal glory. Instead u should continue 2 build up your grassroot foundation and network with other similar personalities within the party like Teng Chang Khim, Boo Cheng Hau etc to bot out the present leadership which deemed “soon to become irrelevant”. U should learn a lesson from Wee Choo Keong as he is struggling now without a party base.
Dear LKS, as rakyat who have always supported opposition since attaining the eligible age of voting, i must say that i am very disappointed and frustrated with one man show policy adopted since the 70’s era till now even though i admire your conviction and contribution to the Malaysian at large. I know this comment will attract a lot of criticism from your loyal supporters. But i must say its time to change. Guan Eng should also realise younger generation is not as tolerant as the older generation. They are more result oriented and could not wait if the outcome is negative.
May be i m wrong, but i m still believe a lot of good leaders being marginalsed within DAP for the obvious reason not being told. Take the case of Teng Chang Khim & Wong Swee Lim, the only 2 SA of Selangor are being sidelined for almost all state party function and even state committee. They are left to campaign and strive on their own efforts. On the other hand, Au Yong Ean Wah and Ronnie Liu, even totally lack of leadership charisma still being groomed to be state or even national leaders. Most frustrated being Fong Kui Lun, an MP being considered not relevant anymore by general public still retained as a candidate in BB. Please go to ground and hear if there is murmur that this chap is not up to the mark. These are examples of why the public are accusing DAP is practising cronism.
Last but not least. may i extent my best wishes to DAP in the upcoming GE. Get the problems fixed without fear and favour, practice meritocracy and the outcome may be beyond your imagination. Thank you for long years of struggle for Malaysian.
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 06.22
DAP may lose many Chinese educationists’ votes if Po Kuan incident is blown out and manipulated by MCA.
Po Kuan already sent a strong signal to banana men in Perak and elsewhere, without the grassroot support of chinese educated ah pek and ah soh, banana men are irrelevant in Malaysian politics.
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 10.21
keep good quality leaders in the country…both DAP & BN
kick out low quality leaders.
Po Kuan is a good leader - from her track record in Parlimen
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 16.57
http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=YY8APrYU2Gs
“Don’t Give Up On Us……………Baby!”
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 18.20
Dear Po Kuan,
I hope you read this. Did YB Lim Kit Siang really ‘direct’ to contest in another constituency or is this the work of enemies. Please search your heart. DAP and Malaysians need you in Parliament, need you as a MP. Please do not abandon ship now. Your conscience will haunt you for the rest of your life if you insist on stepping down.
Even if YB LKS wants you to go elsewhere, You must be feel honoured. You have done enough for Batu Gajah, kindly take your ability and ’service’ to another deprived area- to serve the voters there. Complete faith in you could probably been the reason, if there was any directive in the first place!
YB Poh Kuan- please reconsider, don’t let your principles be aborted, for the enemies to exploit. Don’t let DAP down, Don’t let DAP members down, Don’t let Malaysian down. Please reconsider and it will the right decision you would ever make.
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 18.32
YB Fong,
I hope you can withdraw your announcement not to contest in the coming GE or quit DAP. Let bury the hatch and whatever past is past and consolidate for the sake of DAP and the people to deny the 2/3 majority. BN is taking chances now to publicise your non-seeking of nomination. We can’t let the idiot BN machinery to harp on this issue. Please reconsider and contest again.
I am sure you are mature enough to forgive whoever have hurt you as GOD knows what you are doing. Everyone has been supporting you including the DAP leaders when you were condemned by the ‘madman’ from BN UMNO in the Parliament. Do withdraw your resignation and contest as YB Kit and SB Guan Eng had already sincerely offered you to contest in the same place.
Wee Choo Keong - please stay away form condemning DAP, you mind your own business if you still want to contest in Bukit Bintang. Are you trying o be hero??
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 19.43
Brother Kit,
We need you to pull this together but only if you are well & healthy. Remember we can help to pull you up and lift your weight.
YB Po Kuan, its a BIG dissapointment to see you leave (so much inspirations) after comparing you with my state DAP comrades won big in 2006 State. But its respected and may good fortune be with you
Hidup DAP!
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 22.19
It may sound unprofessional, but to leave a company or a party during the crucial time is a best weapon to teach them a hard lesson.
I did tender my resignation when the company’s new project in a half-way. Why? Top management favoured a faction and all promotion opportunies went to this faction regardless other hardworking people. Besides, I was offered opportunity to return to company at anytime by MD.
I had never change my quit decision from that company although that dominant faction head was appealing me to stay on and wanted to put me under his faction.
It’s different with my personal case, Po Kuan shall change her mind for the public interest.
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 22.50
Dissappointed with her for quiting esp at this time. This is the first time that I am feeling the opposition are going to do well in the coming election.We dont get much chances all this while. Let her go.A person who cant resolve their problems within shouldnt be pity or whatsoever.As far as I am concern she is not a good leader. A good leader doesnt quit. Really disappointed!!!!
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 23.22
Po Kuan, the people of Batu Gajah wants you, DAP has no objections to you standing another term there as clearly stated here.
Put aside any personal matters and do it for the Rakyat.
That is the oath you took, to SERVE THE RAKYAT. Your job is not done yet …..
However, if you choose to step down and make way for others, The Rakyat wishes you the best.
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 23.57
Please please please not at this crucial moment. We need you.
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 30.33
Dear YB Lim,
This morning I’m both happy and sad….happy because DAP and PKR have reached agreement to face BN one-to-one in all states in the Peninsula, hopefully same can be agreed upon for Sabah and Sarawak. Sad because of all the negativity surrounding YB Fong Po Kuan’s decision not to contest at all in the coming elections. The BN-controlled media is, as expected, blowing this issue out of proportion for its own advantage. I sincerely ask all parties concerned, especially YB Fong, to reconsider and make a decision based on the best interests of the Batu Gajah constituents, the party and party supporters. Let’s give BN a run for their money and retain Batu Gajah. As rightly pointed out, Ms. Fong has become a beacon of hope and the voice of the oppressed, both men and women, in parliament. Let’s not walk into BN’s traps so easily.
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 31.25
I was with PKR public rally in Taman Bukit Anggerik yesterday. I was quite impressed with PKR manisfesto and the quality of their leaders. One of the speakers is DAP ex-adun in Pahang.
Those Chinese cannot “tahan” some banana men in DAP shall consider to jump ship to PKR.
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 34.21
Newspaper and tv reports are using Po Kuan’s announcement, Phee Boon Poh’s threat to withdraw and other ex-DAP MPs eg. Hu Sepang’s article & Wee Choo Kiong’s press statements to paint a the DAP as a house in turmoil. The negative vibes have shaken my resolve to vote DAP/opposition in GE12. Many of my friends feel the same way.
Something is wrong with the DAP! Pls put your house in order before nominations get underway!
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 40.13
Dear daniel,
Just because of a little ‘tremble’ in DAP house your resolve to vote DAP/Opposition have been shaken??
Do you really want a better Msia? Do you want to deny BN that 2/3 majority?
If yes to the above two questions, may I suggest you see beyond this little ‘tremble’? Life are bound to have challenges. At the end of the day, lets vote for the Opposition symbol.
The other alternative is to vote BN and go back to the status quo.
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 41.35
NO need to praise FPK too much. She is responsible too for the present problem. She thinks she is bigger than party now, being popular with the people in general. Tell me who is she if she was not given the opportunity to stand in a DAP stronghold during the last two general elections. Tell me why FPK put in her letter of resignation: “my decision is final”. It is so bloody arrogant because it does not provide avenue for compromise, negotiation and work out. PK, I think your decision is not yours alone if you know what I mean. You are a sitting MP. You have a greater responsibility than those that affect you, your friends and family. You may be a two term MP, but I think there are still many things you need to learn, my friend.
Of course many others too within Perak DAP have also harboured unrealistic ambition to stand in the coming election. They think it is a sure bet given that the government is less popular now. The selfish intent is so apparent.
As I said earlier in this blog (I can’t remember where I put it), the quality and integrity of potential candidates are so important. Otherwise, no matter how hard we work, there is nothing to prevent some of them from crossing over to BN after the election. Please DAP. Please don’t just put up any donkey; chose a thorough breed, not a “dark-horse” even.
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 41.37
It is not a question of Po Kuan’s indispensability or interest being more important than DAP’s interest. She has cultivated goodwill of Batu Gajah constituency. They want her. It is a safe DAP’s seat.
So why, in these circumstances, parachute someone else into that constituency when that effectively means Po Guan sowed the seeds of goodwill and somebody else harvests the fruits – is that fair? The DAP rides itself that it proceeds on principles so how can this be the case? One can’t argue that it is DAP’s national strategy plan – how can this be compromised with popular Po Kuan remaining in Batu Gajah, a sure win for the DAP ?
Its all politics, wanting to accommodate the DAP Perak chiefs (the Ngehs and Ngas).
But politics and bickering for positions should not override principles of fair play for Po Kuan : why should she sow for others to harvest, tell me? And there’s nothing at national level or her performance in parliament to take away any credit from her. So why push her to this position?
Whatever happened in Park the DAP top leadership cannot absolve itself from complicity or responsibility unless it wants to admit that it is “somnambulant†leadership like that of Badawi’s that is mocked at!
It is important DAP’s leadership acts principled because otherwise we voters will ask what’s the difference if you kick the BN’s fellas out – its all the same, politics and jostling for positions without regard to fairness and equity. Isn’t this the issue?
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 44.41
Typo error in 2nd para from top - “The DAP PRIDES itself…” and last 2 para from botom - “Whatever happened in PERAK”..Sorry
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 46.25
i couldnt believe it when i read one of the tough generals of the DAP is quiting. I’m not a DAP member but reading that is as shocking as it is. The theme of Check and Balance to the ruling government is well received by the rakyat and YB Fong along with other fearless stalwarts held such qualities. Retain her by all means Mr.Lim because she is not only an asset to your party..but also the asset to the rakyat also. Wish you blessings and luck…
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 58.36
YB LKS, I am just a normal citizen with no political involvement, no parties. The poeple just want YB Foong Po Kuan to continue to serve us, we need her. I believe you have what it takes to resolve the differences internally. Please make her stay one way or another. I am from Batu Gajah, I am extremely sad and angry with the development. Please reolve it ASAP else DAP will most likely lose many Batu Gajah voters as emotions overrules their heads. The ball is now in your hand…..
February 18th, 2008 at 11: 59.09
if anyone saw an opportunist lately he is probably wee choo keong of mdp, whose personal traits can be quite significant when it comes to adding salt to injury, who has he help if not only himself? at least lle lam thye was accepted to join bn, but wee is a cast away in malaysia politics who tries to reincarnate with a party called mdp, must be quite a place to be if yiu like back stabbing people.
February 18th, 2008 at 12: 07.21
I hope all of you would agree that any bananaman or Chinese educated Ah Beng is better than the clowns from UMNO. Our country is going down the drain as we speak. Certainty FPK should understand that. Her “annoucement” had made the Perak MB laughing all the way going into the election. I hope that she would someday “grow up” and learn that how ridiculously silly about what she just did.
February 18th, 2008 at 12: 09.59
Some readers here seem to be rattled by Poh’s resignation and wondering if they should vote for DAP?
Please look at the larger picture, the larger interests. We are going for war and if you withdraw because another soldier stepped on your foot, how are you going to win the war. You too will lose the war.
Anyone who rattles now is a weak fighter. Remember, our bigger enemy is BN. Puts aside small differences.
As for Poh Kuan, I am not surprised as I have participated in seven general elections and such withdrawals have happened at every single general election. Despite all these I have sruck with the DAP and voted for it seven times.
If DAP crumbles because of one Poh Kuan, then it is a weak party.
Come on friends, look beyond Poh Kuan.
I like her but I don’t like the way she went about her resigning in this manner on the eve of a great war.
She says DAP is her family then why publicise your family problem to the world? Will you tell the press about your problem with your husband?
February 18th, 2008 at 12: 13.55
Dear Uncle Kit,
I am quite dissapointed with DAP’s inability to put its own hourse in order at these crucial moments. I can’t see the rational of transfering Fong to other constituencies as she has been such a vocal and well supported leader at Batu Gajah. DAP representatives for the up and coming general should put the people’s interest above their personal interest if they were to fight for a more democratic Malaysia. Should internal party bickering continue to rear its ugly head, DAP will pay a hefty price for it.
I sincerely hope that Po Kuan will reconsider her decision. It was a long night yesterday. I recalled and kept thinking of what she said during the press conference. She must have undergone mind-boggling and self conflicting moments to make such a decision. It is a blow to not only to DAP but the entire nation. In particular, those who have been giving her the fullest support find it hard to accept the decision. They are let down in the run-up to the election day amidst hopes of yearning for fairness and democracy.
Po Kuan, you are well supported and respected. I believe that you will be able to overcome the obstacles lying ahead with your determination to serve the people. Po Kuan, Parliament need you. Please reconsider your decision.
I would like to appeal to all fellow Malaysians to give DAP their fullest support in the coming general election despite the hiccups. It’s the love for our nation that drives me to support DAP all this while.
February 18th, 2008 at 12: 15.04
Libra2 - well said. I did the same with the party for the 5th time now. We shall overcome and we will make a difference. Looking at the bigger picture….it’s beyond the Poh Kuans, the Lam Thyes,…it’s about freedom and bringing about change. I am sticking on with the party, like I have always done
February 18th, 2008 at 12: 18.13
A family will always have problems; but we do not quit from a family.
Second, politics is service to the people, and being in a political party gives one the strength and courage to serve the rakyat.
So forget about quitting, stand in Batu Gajah, and do not worry about the announcement (which BN carried so happily). Blood is always thicker then water.
This election is very important to all Malaysians.
February 18th, 2008 at 12: 18.14
Funny how we clamour for change and yet with the same stroke we seem to want to maintain the status quo.
I’m referring to the ‘banana’ statement. So what if they are banana’s?? As long as they can represent the constituency, I care a damn if its a monkey with 5 tails!!..
Geez..we are all so entrenched in the ‘Chinese can only take care of Chinese, Malays for Malays etc etc’ line of thinking. Seriously, forget a Malaysia for all if at the end of the day you still insist on practising race-based politics!
February 18th, 2008 at 12: 18.33
you all ppl really believe MSM writings arr ??? if i’m MP for DAP, i oso quit lar, not because i hate DAP, in-fighting, bla bla, coz really cannot tahan being bullied in parliament. imagine being elected have to travel to kl to be jested, mocked and villified - can take it or not? and how confident that oppos can take > 33% parliament seats ?! as MP to serve rakyat, oppos has to play “hollier than thou” like saint, has to be hardworking to do study, collect statistic, ask question that instead of answered it gets being mocked! she oledi serve 2 terms, and she has been THERE oledi, so maybe it’s time to pass baton to others who has the stamina and energy to travel, be jested, mocked, scolded, vilified, and play saint!
February 18th, 2008 at 12: 19.50
Libra2 - right. Let her go with our best wishes. DAP has no quarel with her and she has no quarel with DAP. If we don’t get too emotional over this, we get over it faster and our focus is on the election. She is a good MP, and it’s time to say goodbye. Don’t blame her for her action.
February 18th, 2008 at 12: 21.47
Sir,
and disappoint to see this scenario happened again and again in DAP during every elections.
It is sad
But what I do believe is admit mistake, take action and make necessary changes will be the ultimate way to success.
February 18th, 2008 at 12: 22.27
Poh Kuan is one of the great fighters for justice and equality.
Her decision will not affect the growing dissatisfaction with BN…leave her alone to sort out this matter with her family, leaders and party.
The Mother of all flowers was found in China…going back 130 millions years.
February 18th, 2008 at 12: 24.20
really feel disappointed when knew yb fong want to quit,
but could it be possible UMNO play trick on her?
i dun think DAP is worst till she want to left.
if DAP vs BN, BN is worst than a shit.
February 18th, 2008 at 12: 31.23
I believe that all of us wish her to stay fight for us… No matter how much reasons being given… still we will feel disappointed, unless we have her back in participation… She is really great for the pass few years and all of us saw it before…
Although she already mentioned that her decision is final… but I still hope that we can create miracle…
PS: Please come back at least for all of us… please consider to fight for all of us again… some internal conflicts might cos you feel sad… but still general public will sure touch your heart always, if you decided to come back for all of us…
February 18th, 2008 at 12: 37.06
YB Poh Kuan think of the Party and PEOPLE. Reconsider ur decision.
February 18th, 2008 at 12: 53.50
And what was BN Perak MB immediate reaction?
“For me I cross the bridge when I come to the bridge. How do you know that she is not standing? Last minute, she might be standing there. So our preparation must be geared to the situation that she will be defending her seatâ€
But from her announcement (see Video Clip) she was a determined angry woman out to settle some old score troubling her for years. Personally she cannot accept the fact that as the elected MP she has to take orders from State leaders – or for that matter anybody. Seen her in any demos or protest gatherings? Even if asked to contest elsewhere, she could have taken up the challenge and used her experience and reputation to win another DAP seat. She is too egoistic, larger than life and place her self above the party without realizing it is the DAP party that has given her a life as an MP and now to enjoy her pension. More details T
http://powerpresent.blogspot.com/2008/02/video-fong-po-kuan-batu-gajah-mp-quits.html
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 04.39
Po Kuan;
you are giving a Big ang pau to the Barisan Natiomal.
Enough is Enough!
DAP supports know your situation
please reconsider your decision.
Sdr LIM KIT SIANG and supporters of DAP will be very sad .
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 28.00
Let’s be rational. Let the heat cool off. Everybody will then return to their good sense. It is no point of us pinpointing who is right and who is wrong as by nature everybody thinks they are right and the other is wrong. What is important is let’s consolidate and do not let the corrupted vultures a chance to take advantage of this scenario. Look at how they front page the story when all these while they have left DAP out of any news in their media.
I am sure YB Poh Kuan will find its right balance again within the next few days as I remembered that she at one time also wanted to withdraw from politics because she couldn’t stand the barrage of attacks from BN and which also resulted in her from being suspended from Parliament for 6 months. As humans after every fall, we find our steps firmer and Poh Kuan is definitely getting firmer on her steps and since she has a long way to go, we must let her know that we need her firm steps to make Malaysia a better place for every Malaysians and not let the vultures roam fearlessly so much so even the corpses are not spared.
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 28.07
I totally agree with you, ftem! History repeats itself and it is no surprise this can happen to DAP! Perhaps there is something wrong with the Feng Shui at DAP HQ? Just like what happened umpteen years ago to MCA where they engaged a Feng Shui Master and then put up two unicorns at the entrance of the HQ!
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 28.41
If FPK still insists on quiting,nobody can do anything except to wish her well in her future especially now she is just married.But to choose this critical time to make the decision is really treacherous and unpardonable.A lot of people out there are speculating whether she is another LLT or another Datuk or Tan Sri holder soon.If she still loves the party,she should change her mind now.She must think of the bigger and more important picture:to topple BN 2/3 majority,to stop the incessant bullying on the minorities by the UMO gangs for the past 50 years,to end marginalisation of the non Malays etc.Do not be affected by this ‘tremor’ if nothing can be done to the FPK issue.Let it be.All voters be united behind the ‘BA’ and YB LKS to deny the 2/3 BN majority.
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 36.01
YB
I think the YB Fong case is BN propaganda machinery working overtime, thanks to our main stream media.
As in any political party, jostling for position is normal. I.E. Obama vs Clinton (that’s call “party election”), our 2 BN Ministers in Perlis fighting the CM (that’s labelled as “in the hands of the PM”), MIC leaders not offering themselves as candidate (that’s written as “reinventing”), PPP fighting everyone else (that’s said as “negotiation”). But when it is from the opposition, FRONT PAGE = BOMB SHELL=PARTY IN DISARRAY etcs etcs.
YB Fong certainly had won the trust + heart of many. If she can be persuaded to run again fine. If not we should respect her decision. Mind you, it is not EAZY BEING AN OPPOSITION MP IN MALAYSIA.
MPs from DAP had crossed over many times, some capable, some opportunist. But for all this while, the party had stood by those who were sideline + bullied. The party’s history is more solid than any personality. I’ll back the party at this crucial moment, and hopefully any dispute will be overcome in the interest of the party + country.
I had make my trip to DAP HQ in PJ to make my contribution. Had also volunteered my self to Damansara Utama, Kajang, Kepong + HQ to be an election worker……have you?
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 37.35
As I have said earlier, PK should have known the consequences the very first day she joined DAP and “realizing” it now only makes everyone think she will be another LLT, soon to be conferred a Dato’ or Tan Sri! She should withdraw her “decision” and stand in BG in the coming election to prove her “innocence”. We have seen enough of dirty tactics - LLT and Wee Choo Keong are classic examples!!!!
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 38.21
[It is an open secret that Chinese education background DAP leaders are always sidelined by those banana men who cannot speak and write their own mother tongue.]
[Po Kuan already sent a strong signal to banana men in Perak and elsewhere, without the grassroot support of Chinese educated ah pek and ah soh, banana men are irrelevant in Malaysian politics]
———————————-
It is obvious that someone is using this blog to exploit situation by driving a wedge between the Chinese educated and the English educated members of DAP.
By calling some DAP leaders “banana men†proves that you are not a friend of DAP. DAP needs leaders dedicated to the cause of justice, equality and freedom for all Malaysians. It doesn’t matter whether your education background is Chinese, English, Malay or Tamil.
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 39.22
Since ‘The Star’ is so biased in its reporting,stop buying it.I have stopped reading the paper for quite some time and I will read it again if it adopts a fairer approach in reporting like ‘The Sun’.
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 42.43
Gawwddd……just what the opposition needs now…….Ngeh guy better clean up this mess……or maybe put his sister who was an ex magistrate in Fong’s place…..she is pretty good tooo……but sought it out mannn….and fast……
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 44.44
This is all BN,s properganda.. Head lines in all major papers ,just because of G.E, If not for G.E do you guys think that she will get this kind of publicity.
We will read more of this kind of half truth in the BN control papers..Why dnt the papers write anything about, the bad blood that is flowing between BN compornent parties.The best one is about PPP ,asking their members not to vote for M.I.C. candidates
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 45.20
Thats the trouble with young blood especially woman (am a woman too) that when they are in power, they think the whole world owe it to her! Uncle Lim, moves on and take good care. Rest whenever you can cos’ there is so much more to one FPK. Just a 2 time MP, she is already so big headed. Imagine if she is elected again?
We can’t turn the clock backward for the damage she made. Carry on with your plan and the issue will die off. My family will continue to support DAP!
To FPK, there may be tonnes of anger in you right now, but you will live with regrets till you wake up from your fantasy world.
HIDUP DAP!
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 47.13
Yes, Poh Kuan, Malaysia needs you! Please reconsider your decision. As a Muarian, we would like you to come down south to contest in Bakri Muar (ex-Health Minister’s constituency) since you are now forming your new family here (hope I’m right). This will be a big threat to BN. I’m sure Muarian Ah Pek and Ah Soh will go all the way to make sure you would topple BN! I give my assurance I will take 1 week off my job to help you to campaign in Muar!
Incidentally, I wish also to express my regret over your such shocking move. Really, it’s a big blow to both you and DAP! I really hope you would try your best to make it up.
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 49.28
The timing of this is critical. However the DAP and the OPPOSITION is not about 1 person. If anybody for whatever reasons want to quit right now is the best time. Don’t reach the nomination time then quit, then the Opposition lose out a seat due to disqualification it would be worse!
If YB Fong wants to quit, wants to give up the fight, wants to let down her supporters and let the BN male chauvinistic pigs who bully her for whatever reason then so be it.
We must move ahead and ensure we do not lose Batu Gajah seat just because someone wants to quit at a time like this. Stop the incessant squabbling about why she wants to quit or what caused her to quit.
We must unite in full force and VOTE FOR DAP! VOTE FOR PKR! VOTE FOR PAS!
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 53.47
There are plenty of capable people to stand in BG. For example, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8NwVLIhxih0
Feng Shui or not Feng Shui, power and money corrupt a human’s soul. When you have nothing, you just fight and work, once you accomplished something, different thoughts settle in. Only true leaders are unpurturbed by these forces.
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 55.33
I strongly recommend that Sdr Thomas Su Keong Siong to be the ideal candidate for this seat, due to his dedication, being action oriented and sincerity …….bla bla ……. the Party decides to field Sdr Thomas as a candidate of Batu Gajah Parliamentary seat, I will personally assist him in the election campaign.
so she mean if it’s not thomas, she will not help, just like betty vs kerk in kota melaka and the result to wong nai chee !! i thot she wants to follow her husband to johor instead ? whatever it is, if she thinks she’s indispensable, she’s damn wrong, just like an employee in MNC. it’s obvious that in oppos there will be NO job satisfaction since they will be deprived, low benefit, insulted, mocked, scolded, jested, vilified, ridiculed, just like a small kompany in globalization vs MNCs. if she doesn’t like it and feel oppressed, quit and join MNC (ala BN) instead!
February 18th, 2008 at 13: 58.32
Wee Choo Keong is aiding the MSM with all kinds of rubbish!
February 18th, 2008 at 14: 07.01
If FPK wants to quit for family reasons etc, there are much better ways of doing so. In addition, the timing could have been much better. I therefore have to summise that these are not the reasons.
It is not just a matter of FPK not wanting to contest. What is more worrisome to me is the internal bickering and the inability of the party leaders to keep their own house in order. The leadership of the party has to take responsibility and be accountable. Period.
February 18th, 2008 at 14: 08.05
We should not be too harsh and tough on Poh Kuan…….understanding is important to attract potentially capable people to join the struggle.
February 18th, 2008 at 14: 08.14
One important factor to note: Both Senior and junior Lims through their statements clearly confirmed Fong Po Kuan is very much needed by DAP. This only shows they and others (majority) in DAP want her to remain active. I see this as positive and a form of strong endorsement of her services. This alone I believe can be good reasons for Po Kuan to reconsider her decision.
Whatever reasons let it be as I am sure it can’t be bigger than the CHANGE we are talking about. And base on her post at her blog her heart is very much with DAP and its struggle and I’m damn sure she would not want to be seen responsible in anyway for DAP’s downfall.
February 18th, 2008 at 14: 20.13
Reading through some of the comments make me laugh. Someone say he loss confidence with DAP. for having such infighting. One comment how can one run a nation if you cannot manage your own party. Let us keep our sasses and be mature and think.
Now, infightings are everywhere “people are peopleâ€. Do you think that BN no infighting meh? I tell there is worst infighting in BN BUT all conceal by the media which they control. But. when it comes to opposition infighting it is being exploited by BN propaganda machine.
Poh Kuan already leaves no room for negotiation when she says that her decision is final. Then we wish her the best in all her future undertaking.
Maybe it is marital pressure as she is newly wedded; maybe she is a young lady in a hurry, maybe political pressure. We do not know. But she insinuates that it is party infightings and change of constitution, lah….. And her timing is just perfect and she must surely know the damaged it causes to the DAP election plan
A young man I used to be but now I am old, I see a young lady that did not put party above self. I do hope that I am wrong but she may be a LLT or Wee in the making.
February 18th, 2008 at 14: 21.47
Ai Yah! no edit button.
Let us keep our SENSES and be mature and think.
February 18th, 2008 at 14: 24.01
kanthanboy Says:
===
Some power crazy banana men in DAP are destroying DAP than anyone else.
Why Lee Lam Tye and many other capable DAP men left DAP?
I call it self-destructive, and don’t blame others for your failure.
February 18th, 2008 at 14: 32.29
some ppl thot dap is “holier than thou - everybody in the party is saint”, and bn “is ok to have black sheep and corrupted”…… if i’m lks, i gulung tikar long long time and join bn, why suffer and drag along his son for dap sake. some ppl think dap=lim dynasty, if i’m lks son i would feel very terrible coz have to struggle for the party, have to play saint (no gamble, no bookie betting, no visiting spa, no kopi-o, etc), and masuk jail and isa for other ppl coz (are you stupid to do this, me cabut for me to do this). i would prefer to be kj, lky son, or ling son who can turn me billionaire by 28! .
February 18th, 2008 at 14: 48.07
The decision should be left to Po Kuan; she is both adult and parliamentarian to boot. There may be many sides to the story, as some have speculated. Be that as it may, the fight must go on. Malaysians must remain focused on the Battle Royale and not be sidetracked by fringe differences and petty squabbles. Squabbles are an inevitable facet of life but life goes on & the larger battles of life must be waged. Distractions like broken nails must be filed and we must raise our shoulders to the wheel….PUSH, PUSH, PUSH.
Malaysians must rally behind DAP and PKR to score a resounding victory against all the enormous odds; what with lack of funds and media coverage! We have to be resolute to spread the message of CHANGE by word of mouth and on foot.
GO! GO! GO! We must win.
February 18th, 2008 at 14: 48.37
i posted my comment this morning and it disappeared just an hour later. is my comment to harsh that someone up there can’t swallow that warrants it to be destroyed. if being so, what is the different U and ACA.
Kudos to the editorial of this blog. but before that, let me assured u that i m 110% pro DAP and not an undercover for BN. however, i could not stand the top brass of DAP who are selfishness and indispensable attitude which will kill DAP sooner or later. we need fresh blood (old or young), new ideas but not dead woods and holier than thou leaders.
Let’s be realistic, we need unity and meritocracy to survive and win the election. this what DAP always believe and preach. get rid of factionalism and cronies, the future of DAP will be bright.
Lastly, let me thank Mr LKS for his long period of service and contribution to Malaysian at large.
It’s time to face reality and don’t kill the golden opportunity to deny BN 2/3 majority.
February 18th, 2008 at 14: 52.58
Those ELITE, land owners, BN MPs that claimed that they are serving people of this land are lying as the result shows. They are only ‘robbing’ the wealth of this land.
February 18th, 2008 at 14: 57.43
What has this got to do with the so called banana men? What’s so great about being chinese educated? Do you think that being chinese educated is more superior and China will take you back with open arms? Come on, You need english to survive in this competative world. Just look at singapore. without english singapore can never succeed.
February 18th, 2008 at 15: 09.45
Just let her go! No need to persuade her to reconsider her decision.
Why some of you people are being so stubborn? If she(FPK) had DAP in mind, she would not go to the press conference and blasted Perak DAP. Who she think she is? Above the party? She was being too impulsive.
Let us stand from Perak DAP’s point of view. I am a member of DAP too. She had married to Johor. What’s wrong in asking someone like Nga Kor Ming(who’s more outspoken than FPK, mind you) to contest in Batu Gajah [i am assuming this is the likely reason for of this FPK issue]?
February 18th, 2008 at 15: 15.57
I too am reminded of the tearful LLT announcement in 1990. Does this latest announcement tell us more about Po Kuan or about DAP?
February 18th, 2008 at 15: 30.58
To: Fong Po Kuan
Having met you (introduced by Guan Eng) and spoken to you at the DAP PJ’s dinner on 1st November 2007, my family, friends and I know that you are made of better stuff - speaking without fear and favour. You have done a great job and are an asset to DAP, of which we are eternally grateful.
Having party squabbles just before election is part and parcel of a democtratic process. Being effective and popular, you will attract unnecessary attention and jealousy to herself. As the Chinese proverb goes, “A tall tree attracts strong wind”
My two cents worth of advice, “Po Kuan, the country needs you. Be strong. Be part of history - deny BN their 2/3rd majority. Just change it. Remember the success of person is not measured by the number of times he/she falls but the number of times he/she stands up after the fall”
God bless
February 18th, 2008 at 15: 34.08
Typo error
Having party squabbles just before election is part and parcel of a democratic process. Being effective and popular, you will attract unnecessary attention and jealousy to yourself (herself). As the Chinese proverb goes, “A tall tree attracts strong wind”
February 18th, 2008 at 16: 32.20
“Why Lee Lam Tye and many other capable DAP men left DAP?†malaysiatoday.com
————————————–
The reasons are:
He is now Tan Sri Lee Lam Thye.
He is now the Chairman of the National Service Council.
He is now the Non Executive Director, Arab-Malaysian Corporation Berhad
He is now the Non- Executive Director of Media Prima Berhad (Media Prima
ps. I don’t mean FPK is like LLT. As a matter fact FPK is still a DAP member. I’m not judging her intention.
February 18th, 2008 at 16: 37.43
Oh, woe is me!!
Whenever I have my meals, I must have my cili padi.
But now I hear Ms Cili Padi is not going to tanding. Oh woe, how can I ever enjoy my meals again?? Things are just not going to be the same anymore without you, Ms Cili Padi.
You have stood firm and conquered Kinbatangan. You have put Jerai to shame. What more, the one-eyed jack.
By why, Cili Padi, why? Is it because of Ngeh and Ngah? Surely these two are no match for you, my Cili Padi.
Oh, please, please, please, my Cili Padi.
Please reconsider. There are bigger issues involved. More mountains to overcome and we need you.
You are Batu Gajah.
I dedicate these to you :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zxc8QxQfYbs&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15EWSi0NZ64
February 18th, 2008 at 17: 08.56
pohwatchdog Says:
Today at 08: 39.24 (8 hours ago)
What so great about YB Fong Po Kuan? Let her go…. noone is indispensable. One flower gone ….another millions come.
Agreed…..
February 18th, 2008 at 17: 20.14
I am not sure whether YB Fong is reading all the comments at this blog and her own blog. Will the moderator please call YB Fong to read all the comments and come out with a posting at her blog.
YB Fong,
If you are reading all the comments, you will see that 99% are very strongly against what you are doing.
For the sake of the country and the rakyat call Malaysians, please cool down and reconsider your decision. Give the racist islamic state umno a big kick in their asses.
Your decision had given the racist islamic state umno the biggest ammunition that they needed.
I had beg, plead and even willing to kneel down to you to change your mind.
As time is not there for us to drag on this matter, would you please make an announcement here or at your blog so that we can move on.
Whatever your decision after reading all the comments, we will have to accept it. We hope that you will give us a very positive answer.
May GOD Bless You.
Fellow Malaysian
Although this is an ugly episode, let us not be distracted but continue with our support for the oppositions to teach the racist islamic umno a lesson that they will never forget.
50 years is ENOUGH
Vote For A Change
Vote For Any Opposition
Give Them A Chance To Change For A Better Malaysia
Remember bn Is A Useless Grouping Of Self Serving, Corrupt, Dictator, Power Crazy, Racist, Kris waving, etc, etc type of parties.
February 18th, 2008 at 17: 20.32
Just puzzle! why wan to change the candidate for Bt Gajah, when FPK had shown that she is almost a “sure win” candidate!
February 18th, 2008 at 17: 28.32
don’t go Po Kuan, we all need you. Please continue your fight for better Malaysia.
we need to unite to fight mighty BN
February 18th, 2008 at 17: 29.18
seems to me from lim statement FPK should stay at BG, but probably she wants changed to johor to be with her husband, just maybe. or she cannot tahan in-fighting in perak dap and the leadership style overthere. anyway, if her decision is final, this is it. but some overzealous voters and opportunists want to exploit this to bring down DAP in BG/Perak, just like betty vs kerk vs wong nai chee in kota melaka.
February 18th, 2008 at 17: 47.30
The harsh reality in Malaysia - it is never easy to be an opposition politician.
If you want reward, $$, and title, just sacrifice your principles and conscience, and become a BN politician.
Just look at “Mr. Opposition” Tan Chee Khoon ’s son. He decided not to follow his father’s footstep. He became a BN politician and his smooth-sailing path is so different from that of his late father.
Just look at LLT and many others.
Politicians are humans and mortals too.
February 18th, 2008 at 18: 06.50
It is most disheartening to read the negative comments that have appeared over Fong Po Kuan’s desertion of the party that for the past 8 years she professed to love and to represent. Most of the commenters do not understand the intricacies and complexities of the field of politics and take things at face value and thus have erroneous opinions of the situation.
Just ask yourself a simple question. How much does Po Kuan love the party to deal it such a body blow? Over the years has Uncle Lim not served the party selflessly? Does he deserve such a stab in the back at this critical hour? In spite of his back pain, he has to rush up and down the country trying to get things organised and sacrifice his sleep also. A lesser man would have given up if he was ask to “swallow a dead cat” as in this case.
I fully appreciate and am thankful to the great leaders of the DAP who have all these years trudged the thousand of kilometres, many hours and days of suffering to represent us. All because we do not know and many of us who do not dare to face the difficulties. I salute leaders like YB Lim and his family members, YB Karpal Singh and many others. I was at the PJ open house yesterday and had the privilege to shake the hand of Dr. Chen Man Hin, such a steadfast and humble man. Such are the types of leaders we need in the DAP, people who will stick with the party through thick and thin. In politics,inevitably you will meet with differences of opinion at all times. If you are a committed party member, you do not wash dirty linen in public. What more in this case, you call a press conference in front of the national TV and press and present the BN with a million dollar present and deal a body blow to your comrades. Search your conscience, Po Kuan. Did you not betray your friends?
I have full confidence in the leadership of YB Lim Kit Siang and his team. I implore you all to do the same and let us get on with the battle that is looming ahead. This time round, WE MUST WIN & WE WILL WIN. Long live the DAP
February 18th, 2008 at 18: 11.48
DAP needs to show more sincerity in persuading Fong Po Kuan to return to Batu Gajah. One blog post is not enough. Where are all the other DAP leaders? We as opposition supporters or BN haters will be very disheartened if Fong Po Kuan is allowed to leave in such a bitter note.
Why must DAP allow the stupid BN media to capitalise on such issues at a time when public impression matters most?
WHY?
February 18th, 2008 at 18: 20.39
From the little we know of her fighting spirit, I do not think the decision was easy. She must have gone through a lot of soul searching before arriving at the decision.
Having said that, the infighting must also have been really bad and to allow this to deteriorate to this stage, I am sorry to say the top DAP leaders must be held responsible for not having stopped it earlier. For it to happen just before the GE, the fallout is not just the BG seat. The damage is to the whole party especially someone of FPK’s stature. The general public will view this as a serious failure of the DAP because if it cannot even control the infighting among its own members, how is it going to stand up against the BN?
Those that help precipitate this disastrous episode must be reminded that Batu Gajah is not a shoo in for the DAP. Much of the electoral success is due in no small part to the high esteem FPK enjoys from among the voters. The next DAP candidate may not enjoy the same support. Unlike the BN candidates, where voters vote them because of the party, for the DAP, it has much to do with the individual candidate. Those that has vested interest in forcing her out for personal gain should be condemned for betraying the peoples’ trust and be relegated to the political scrapyard permanently.
As for FPK, inasmuch I respect and understand your feelings and frustration, I also feel you should have spared a thought for the massive damage done to the party and Opposition with this move, not to mention destroying the hopes of many people who thought they finally saw some light in this GE to deny BN the two third majority in a long, long time. Surely this infighting is not an overnight problem and if indeed you had felt so strongly about quitting, you should have done it long before the announcement of Parliament dissolving.
Anyway, the damage has been done. I hope the DAP leadership can salvage whatever is left.
February 18th, 2008 at 18: 28.33
YB FPK
On one hand I want to give you a motherly hug and tell you to pull yourself together and be the cilipadi that you are reputed to be. I wish to think that you must be facing stress that has overwhelmed you and need a little rest.
On the other hand, I wish to wag you and tell you girl, dont be so sensitive, think of the rakyat, the oppressed, the neglected, the marginalised who cant get out of their sorry state without help from fortunate people like you who has God-given brains and money to get an education!
Plse, I think you still have the fire burning! If being a politician is as smooth-sailing as we wish it to be, there would be an abundance of them!
Now when the iron is hot, dont abandon ship for you may regret it later..what are you going to tell your children, grand children, great grand children when they read about this episode sometime to come? ” Mommy, POPO/ Ah Mah was angry with……….so I quit lah!!”
Come on girl! berkhidmat untuk negara and the whole nation will love you for that till posterity…
-A little advice from a pensioner who is also a cilipadi in my own way..
February 18th, 2008 at 18: 43.05
I think Po Kuan and DAP are falling into traps set up by MAC the running dogs.
It is just too easy to create havocs by all the running dogs.
February 18th, 2008 at 18: 46.11
Po Kuan should stay because she represent the new generation.
Po Kuan should stay because there are so few female candidates around!
Po Kuan should stay as she serve Batu Gajah and Parliament well!
February 18th, 2008 at 18: 50.25
///The general public will view this as a serious failure of the DAP because if it cannot even control the infighting among its own members, how is it going to stand up against the BN?///– Cinapek
BN can easily control its members because they were all waiting for goodies, and they cannot afford to have their differences surfaced. The oppositions are a group of people of the willing, against the same enemy, but with very different outlook, and freedom; they are not there to share the spoils. DAP therefore cannot exercise the type of control BN could.
Fong Po Kuan has decided to quit, and she is not going to work against the interest of DAP in Batu Gajah. Yes, she has shown herself to be a capable MP, and she would be welcomed had she decided to offer to stand again. But if she had decided that to quit the contest was the best solution, for her at least, we should respect her choice.
Quite obviously her adversiary are also members of DAP. Now that Fong has left, it is hoped that the next candidate would receive support form the people, and make BN lose its seat there.
February 18th, 2008 at 18: 51.07
As I said earlier,it was treacherous and unpardonable for FPK to let off this bombshell at this critical time.Her action deeply hurts and aches the hearts of many a DAP supporters.Whatever infighting (if there is) should not have propelled her to take such a drastic action.As opposition politician,she should place party interest above anything else.I think she is too impulsive and immature.Her action has caused irreparable damage to DAP and the opposition.It is especially so when the MSM is biased and controlled by the 50 year old ‘DEVIL’.We hope she is not another LLT,waiting to be showered with wealth,position,title and what not.Anyway,time will reveal the truth.Meanwhile,all voters should cast your votes for DAP.PKR and PAS to deny 2/3 majority of the 50 year old political monster.
February 18th, 2008 at 18: 57.51
kanthanboy Says:
Today at 16: 32.20 (2 hours ago)
“Why Lee Lam Tye and many other capable DAP men left DAP?†malaysiatoday.com
————————————–
The reasons are:
He is now Tan Sri Lee Lam Thye
================================
Money is only factor changing Lee Lam Thye?
Lee was a respectful politician when he was with opposition. As a matter of principle, he is still not joining any political party to fight back DAP.
Although he is aligned with BN, he has contributed a lot to society and nation than a bunch of “commentators”. With BN itself is not a sin or guilty.
DAP has to be more “democratic” to accept dissenting views in the party. Many of DAP leaders still do not understand democratic spirit.
February 18th, 2008 at 19: 01.55
Surprised by Po Kuan’s reaction (or over-reaction). No matter how bitter, leaders must learn to keep emotion in check and always put the best interest of the greater good first and foremost. Knowingly or unknowingly … she has given the enemy weapon and ammunition to shoot and kill her own friends and family ….
Washing dirty linen in public … everybody will stand to lose …
February 18th, 2008 at 19: 09.28
P.O.T.S Says:
Today at 18: 11.48 (46 minutes ago)
DAP needs to show more sincerity in persuading Fong Po Kuan to return to Batu Gajah. One blog post is not enough. Where are all the other DAP leaders? We as opposition supporters or BN haters will be very disheartened if Fong Po Kuan is allowed to leave in such a bitter note.
Why must DAP allow the stupid BN media to capitalise on such issues at a time when public impression matters most?
WHY?
==========
I remembered she used same tactic in last GE in saying no contest.
She already made those “small guys” in Perak DAP knew that don’t simply bully a little woman.
It’s time for her to recall her “final” decision and work hard to deny BN 2/3. At least BN controlled media have given her a free coverage, she already won the political game to defeat “DAP small guys” judging from many responses in internet.
February 18th, 2008 at 19: 16.40
Bro Kit,
You will need lots of luck & prayers. We hope you keep well especially in this trying time.
As for Po Kuan, for someone who says the DAP is a 2nd Family to her, she sure chose a good time to quit!
It’s stuff like this that will make the “Fence Sitters” decide who to vote for (or not to).
The DAP needs to sort this out. The DPM has alreday started “shooting” at her so-called 2nd Family!
February 18th, 2008 at 19: 20.59
Mr Lim Kit Siang, you should use all your political skills to convince YB Po Kuan to continue the journey and not back out at the last minutes. The soldiers are preparing for the final action , day and night staying away from home to fight the enemy and we need every able bodied leader to boost the moral. The departure of YB Po Kuan shall demoralise our grassroot support and handover the victory to Ong Ka Chuan.
YB Po Kuan, you are a leader representing the people and be brave to face the challenges as people are solidly behind you. This is a leadership process and you have to face the enemy from within and outside but show them you are made of steel. Stay to fight the battle and serve the people who put their hope in you. Who will benefit when you leave and it is not DAP but Barisan.
Pray that you will change your mind.
February 18th, 2008 at 19: 35.09
when the going get tough,the tough should get going!!to u,YB fong !!!
February 18th, 2008 at 19: 58.28
hopefully,she is not on the same track as with the lee nam tye guy years back!!i’ve never addressed that guy as a tan sri till todate…!!i hav been calling him a jerk since the day he sold his soul n principle…anyway,i’m a nonpartisan!!
February 18th, 2008 at 20: 04.13
[...] 3. Lim Kit Siang : [...]
February 18th, 2008 at 20: 31.20
For all we know, Poh Kuan could have been life threatened by the likes of Khairy
February 18th, 2008 at 20: 32.17
I subscribe to the notion that there is no smoke without fire. Whatever happened to force MP Fong’s hand I know not for sure but definitely malaysiakini had carried am article of her been squeezed out of Batu Gajah a few days earlier.
Will she reconsider to put back some faith in the current DAP leadership?
February 18th, 2008 at 20: 38.48
I hear from my friends in Kuching that DAP will really kick Taib’s butt this time round. Its high time that this “peh mo” as many call him step down as CM.
February 18th, 2008 at 20: 43.27
Whether Poh Kuan is in Batu Gajah or not - I think the votes will be wise - they will still & always vote DAP!
February 18th, 2008 at 20: 49.13
Many unfair and unnecessary comments are made on Fong Po Kuan. Stop it.
Lets look at all the bright smart people commenting on her, calling her arrogant, weak, insensitive, failure to sacrifice – what else? Are you Po Kuan? Which one of you leave university with a LLB and sacrificed the prospect of chambering and called to the bar? Which one of you sacrifice youthfulness and marriage and entered politics? Which one of you had done MORE for this nation than her?
I can understand if you express regrets and sadness, but to brand her with all sorts of label, isn’t that unfair? What had she done to deserve all your scolding? And all the older uncles and aunties, you have 24 yr old sons or daughter, give him/her to politics. And you, young men/women, join DAP now.
February 18th, 2008 at 21: 01.19
I went to read the press statement by Poh Kuan. Sounds to me she has never or not successful in expressing her goal or wish for herself to DAP leaders. She must have some BIG plan for DAP but it was not been looked into by DAP decision makers. Thus the result is DAP leadership is planning something else, unaware of Poh Kuan’s wish, to battle the 12th GE, and this decision has hurt Poh Kuan.
Poh Kuan should realize not all leaders are born to read mind. She should make her intention clear to DAP leaderships, such as the press statement she made about her resignation. If she has problem, she should talk to boss; not to keep in the heart and explode it during critical time.
All DAP members must lend a hand to Poh Kuan and welcome her back to the mothership. It is a growing pain and we must give opportunity and patience to her.
February 18th, 2008 at 21: 13.46
“oknyua Says:
“Today at 20: 49.13 (14 minutes ago)
“Many unfair and unnecessary comments are made on Fong Po Kuan. Stop it.”
oknyua is right. Stop all derogatory, hurting and unfounded allegations against Po Kuan for I can vouch for her sincerity and dedication although I cannot agree with what she has done.
I still hope Po Kuan can heed the party and public pleas for her to reconsider and return to the frontline of the DAP battle in the 12th general election.
Nothing will give the ordinary Malaysians greater satisfaction and hope or the Barisan Nasional leaders greater trepidation and fear than for Po Kuan to again contest in the Batu Gajah parliamentary seat come Nomination Day on 24th February 2008.
February 18th, 2008 at 21: 19.25
Just two minutes ago on prime time news, RTM1 cunningly sowed seeds of doubt about the DAP leadership and the exit of YB Fong, through crafty words. I could sense the glee behind the words - gleeful about DAP’s current BG issue. DAP supporters, do not doubt the DAP leadership at this crucial time. To err is human - we need to have big hearts to weather misunderstanding, unkind words spoken hastily amongst party members. Suspend judgement, keep a cool head - many a disaster is turned to triumph when patience and forgiveness is given more room than criticism. WE NEED TO BE UNITED - to see history change for this nation. Dear people - Go to the polls and change history.
February 18th, 2008 at 21: 21.14
YB Fong,
u r better than this… x quit now…else those BN slugs will laugh at u…. strive for our nation..!!!
February 18th, 2008 at 21: 36.41
Juat_True,
Yup, DPM actually labelled Po Kuan a “Ahli Parlimen Yang Berkaliber”, now that she has decided not to contest. You could see how he was anjoying the moment!
Po Kuan,
Come back & give the BN a “good slap” in the face!
February 18th, 2008 at 21: 38.52
Stop blaming YB Kit and Guan Eng on this issue as they have never said want transfer Fong out. Am sad with some accusation by some bloggers here. Do you know many of MCA MPs and SAs have been dropped too and this was not highlighted in the press.
My support for DAP will not change unlike some bloggers here so confused with the BN propaganda blowing out Fong’s case.
You are still relevant- DAP! Together we will deny BN 2/3 majority!!
February 18th, 2008 at 21: 59.12
I hope the opposition politicians do not make any negative announcement during this period. Whoever wants to step down should do it after the election, party comes first. As we know the local media is control by BN which is like hungry ghost also look out for any negative news about opposition and publish it big. I know that MCA has its internal problems but little we know from the media.
February 18th, 2008 at 22: 01.31
YB FongPK,please reconsider your decision.Your decision to contest again in BG will tear down the ugly faces of the UMo leaders.DAP is the party that can bring back justice and progress to the country.A lot of people are behind the party and their support is unwavering and is growing even stronger now.
February 18th, 2008 at 22: 04.25
DarkJustice,like you said it! We are all behind YB LKS, DAP, PKR and PAS! We need to be united. Seeing how FPK’s resignation is us