This SMS was sent to me at 10.56 pm last night:
“d crowd jeered loudly at semi value (samy vellu) at ‘d atta 100 vagai’ at PISA in penang just now (22/12). d crowd booed loudly when DJ announced samy vellu’s presence. d ‘BOO’ was so loud dat no one heard anything. Within 2-3 mins he moved back 2 d stage. A very gd lesson 4 d spineless… I’m here in PISA. samy has left d arena.”
May be those who were present at PISA in Penang last night could give us eye-witness accounts of this episode.

#1 by Aramaitii on Sunday, 23 December 2007 - 3:33 pm
Limkamput…rilekx la….so angry for wht? tht’s ppls opinion..dun get personal. We are all adults
#2 by limkamput on Sunday, 23 December 2007 - 3:47 pm
hello ARA MATI, just shut up. this all part of the game. we can all play, no problem. you ain’t seen nothing yet.
#3 by kcb on Sunday, 23 December 2007 - 3:52 pm
In another thread? Kit had to mention?amongst others:
“……. As it is, there is nothing to be proud at all, but to be very ashamed and distressed at the scores of postings which hijack the thread which trivialise the ISA detentions and the serious issues discussed…….”
Guys, let’s remind ourselves of Kit’s comments before submitting our posts.
#4 by ENDANGERED HORNBILL on Sunday, 23 December 2007 - 4:27 pm
YB Kit,
Has anyone posted anything on YouTube yet? It would be real fun watching Samy being taken down a peg or two, maybe even three or more.
To all Sg. Siput(ians), it’s time to let a lame, old horse go…..no, no, no….I don’t mean you should euthanise the horse! Just lay it out to pasture for the rest of his days. He has enough carrots in his barn and lots of hay too.
Come 2008, don’t ride this poor, pathetic, unprincipled horse anymore. Just don’t bet on this lame horse, don’t cast your votes on him.
#5 by limkamput on Sunday, 23 December 2007 - 4:31 pm
kcb, where were you when I get all the incessant insults. When I hit back, one advice after another will surface. Are you saying that I should accept all these head bowed? I am aware of Sdr Kit reminders. There is nothing I can do now. In any case what is wrong with my comments here? Do you think people like Undergrad2 and his sdekicks are so invincible? I think they have held sway with their unchallenged half bake opinions for too long. By the way ARA Mati above is a sidekick. This is the cowardice spineless game they play. You see, even in this they can’t be honest. What moral decency have they got to come here to talk about governance, fairness and justice? They make my hair stand on ends. Kcb, I know you are not one of them (yet, but we shall see).
#6 by fed-up on Sunday, 23 December 2007 - 5:16 pm
Politicians are all alot like diapers it should be changed frequently for the same reason. The time is now for a change. Adios BN
#7 by Evenmind on Sunday, 23 December 2007 - 5:37 pm
Semi Value, not even , he is of NO VALUE to the indian community, The only thing he is good at is licking the boots of the UMNO putras and the likes., cos in return they keep his cronies and him happy with the monetery goodies., and the indians continue to suffer, turning into crime etc, not to worry what goes around comes around., the roosters will come home to roost one day., may GOd have mercy on the BOTAK’s soul.
#8 by kcb on Monday, 24 December 2007 - 12:04 am
Dear limkamput, my post above is not directed at anyone in particular. I thought all of us should put in effort to avoid the situation Kit had mentioned.
My sincere apology if you find my post offensive.
#9 by mandelism on Monday, 24 December 2007 - 1:42 am
yes he was
http://www.bmahendran.com/?p=275
#10 by Bigfoot on Monday, 24 December 2007 - 2:10 am
Wow! It was only a few hours ago that a friend of mine told me that he saw the mentioned show on Astro, and now you mention it on your blog!
If I recall correctly, he said that it was some Indian dance competition shown on live TV. There were judges from the Mauritius, Sri Lanka, etc there. When Samy Vellu was called, the crowd apparently booed him. My friend said that neither the organizers, judges nor the camera crew who were filming it, knew what to do. They were stunned. So was Samy. I suppose that the time is now right to get people who were physically present in the studio to give their eye-witness accounts of what actually occurred.
In the meantime, I will ask my friend for a more detailed account of what he saw. I hope somebody has video footage of this.
#11 by U32 on Monday, 24 December 2007 - 9:09 am
A local newspaper which is Barisan Nasional controlled reported how Dato’ Samy Vellu defended himself. First of all, we Malaysians must acknowledge the fact that he must have done something good enough to last this long. He is one of the veterans, one of the evergreens. A person must always reflect. If you are correct all along, why are there certain unhappy quarters ? It is high time we all face hard facts. In Malaysia, we cannot deny the fact that we have to please our big people; the ruling Barisan Nasional. Even at grass root level, we do things to please them. But the Indians themselves must ask themselves. Why are they keeping him in power if he is no longer relevant ? Turn on the t.v. All the Indians who are interviewed condemned the Hindraf. Radio Television Malaysia protrays to the world that these Indians who are interviewed spoke on behalf of all the Indians. So what are the Indians doing then ? If most of the Indians think that whichever elected representative is not living up to their standard, then they should know what to do.
#12 by Jimm on Monday, 24 December 2007 - 10:05 am
Sv have been guaranteed of his constitutional seat by BN in the coming GE.
Stop dreaming that his career is over …
This is BN that we are facing … and with the entire mechanism EC geared to ensure the right desired result for all their people since the first GE, we must not dream on about any possibilities of seeing SV out.
#13 by k1980 on Monday, 24 December 2007 - 10:41 am
we must not dream on about any possibilities of seeing SV out—
Should the MIC lose more than 50% of the seats it contests in the coming GE, Samy would have no choice but to resign and migrate to Tamilnadu. To shameful to accept a senatorship too
#14 by justice_fighter on Monday, 24 December 2007 - 12:41 pm
here is the link to the youtube
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XPu1CwGix_0
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mHUuA71JmAo
#15 by anak sungeisiput on Monday, 24 December 2007 - 3:32 pm
The more the grass root Indian can write to Pak Lah about Sam the better. Pak Lah would soon realise Sam is a political liabilty.
I am posting here when YB Lim revealed that last week the Prime Minsiter has made Sam Head of Hindu Affairs. What a joke.
23 Dec 2007
Y.A.B. DATO SERI ABDULLAH AHMAD BADAWI
Prime Minister of Malaysia
Block Utama
Bangunan Perdana Putra Fax: 03-88883444
Pusat Pentadbiran Kerajaan Persekutuan
62502 Putrajaya
Dear Prime Minster
As an educated rubber estate worker, hailing from Kamuning Estate, Sungei Siput, I must question your wisdom in appointing Mr. Samy Velu of the Malaysian Indian Congress and the Minister for Public Works with the additional portfolio as Head of Hindu Affairs. Your unilateral decision without any consultation on the private community affairs is depoloarable.
This appointment once again reinforces and facilitates the polarisation of the various ethnic communities and capsulates them for easy social and political manipulation. It prevents the integration of Malaysians into one mainstream society with diverse political ideologies. Your action fences ethnic divisions and reinforces community divide based on race. This is abhorrent in the 21st century.
The British in granting the independence in 1957, segmented the Malayan population into their respective ethnic groupings, ( the British tend to label every non Anglo-Saxons as ethnic communities even now ) and since the Malayan Independence, as long as 50 years ago, the Malaysians have been capsulated into their respective ethnic enclaves, unable to crossover from their respective racial boundary into a mainstream society as Malaysians. In fact the BN dominated government has deliberately prevented the creation of a single mainstream Malaysian society. Racial divide is the order of the day, preventing a cohesive nation of pluralistic society. These racial classification has been slyly crafted for decades of sneaky politicians for the purposes of social and political control based on misplaced tribal loyalty of race.
Mr. Samy Velu revels in this form of segregation, as his political intellect is limited to questionable MIC leadership hinged on Indian tribalism. He is bankrupt of other political ethos or ideology.
Now, Sir, you have unilaterally appointed him as the Head of Hindu Affairs, as an additional tool of political power, at the expense of private Hindu religious activities. Sir, ethnicity, social customs and religious values should not be politicised in the modern day governance of a State. Race and religions are the private domains of the individual citizens and the community and they should be left alone, free of any form State sponsored political interference. This is the foundation of a strong nation. Political parties has no right to intervene in these private affairs of the respective communities, otherwise you are courting disaster.
Your move to appoint Samy Velu has the head of the Hindu Affairs shows lack of sensitivity on your part. The century old social and religious values and social customs do not need a half baked politician like Mr. Samy Velu to lead as the head. This only gives him more unqualified power to suppress the Indian community, and, Sir, we will desist and resist him more at the grass root level. He will attempt to politicise our private affairs for his own personal and political purpose. This, we at the grass root level will prevent.
As the political representative of the Indian community in Malaysia, mandated to work for the benefits of the Indians, with integrity and in a fair and fit manner, he is expected to be transparent. We at the grass root level has asked him to take the lead and voluntarily declare all his assets, owned by him and his immediate family members , including those involved in MICA and publicly disclose all his assets. He is refusing to do so. He is purported to have vast amount of assets accumulated in Malaysia, Australia, India and rest of the world. We have advised Mr. Velu to forgo some of his personal privacy as he is an elected leader, and that such an act of disclosure would be in the interest of the wider Indian community.
His total assets would may well reveal that it is not disproportionate to, and within the means, of his full time Ministerial salary, . This would allay the common perception, currently held by the Indian community, that his personal vast wealth has uniqueness of enormity, to that of a Indian leader charged with the Ministerial power on behalf of the millions of the Malaysian Indians.
It is not uncommon for the Malaysian government to allocate the share of national wealth for the Indians through the Malaysian Indian Congress in which Mr. Samy Velu is the head and as such he has the responsibility to the community to be transparent and accountable. The 9miilion telecom shares, of the 10 million share, allocated to Indians, is alleged to have been diverted to his son’s company and this issue is still in the minds of the Indians. Even though the Anti Corruption Agency, that was under the direct control of his friend the previous Prime Minister of Malaysia Dr. Mahahathir, has given him a clean bill of health, the prevalent perception of the Indian community still sees him under a cloud on this issue. The community is suspicion as to how he would have these vast wealth, which is well known, that he is alleged to have accumulated all over the world, and that such vastness is disproportionate to his fixed monthly minsters salary. I am sure you would like to ask him, as the Prime Minster of the country, to put an end to such community perceptions with facts. Further as a representative of the Indian community and head of MIC, through whom and which body, most of the government benefits for the Indian community have been channelled through, like the 10ml Telecom shares, he has an obligation to be transparent, and sacrifice some personal privacy for the common benefit of the Indian community as its leader. This is expected of community leaders through whom the government has opted to channel its share of national wealth now and than.
I therefore call upon to Government to :
· Dismantle government institutions that reinforces the race of it citizens
· Cease to allocate national share of wealth through the racially constituted political parties for the Indians and the Chinese
· Deliver government benefits and services without having to go through racially constituted political parties,
· Cease to intervene as form in the private social and religious affairs of the citizens for political control and social engineering,
· Regard the demand of HINDRAF leaders as genuine and not hand it over to MIC
· Release the HINDRAF leaders forthwith
As the general election is expected soon, we in the grass root level is committed to unseat Samy Velu and make MIC irrelevant, for his past antics and failure to safeguard the interests of the Indian Community.
Yours faithfully.
Robert Chelliah
#16 by pkrisnin on Monday, 24 December 2007 - 6:51 pm
He was lucky they didn’t bring rotten eggs and vegi. to throw at him.
He won’t be showing his face anytime soon, at least not without his goons in the crowd.
#17 by shortie kiasu on Monday, 24 December 2007 - 8:14 pm
Greenhorn & first timer, Ms. Maxine McKew could unseat incumbent PM John Howard in Bennelong, Sidney, which had held for more than 33 years, nothing is impossible when people are disillusioned and want change to take place.
Just refer to the campaign strategies that she deployed before the votes were cast in Australia. Take a leaf from there.
#18 by anak sungeisiput on Monday, 24 December 2007 - 10:27 pm
Hi Shortie Kiasu,
The rules of the election are uneven between the two countries, one truly indpendent of the political parties, the other totlaly compliant to the ruling political party. Sorry to damper your hopes.
Fron now till GE day, if every converted Malaysian Indian were to talk to 10 others on how not to vote for MIC or any BS poodles, imagine the grass root chatter outcome would be.
Anak Sungei Siput
#19 by anak sungeisiput on Tuesday, 25 December 2007 - 1:40 pm
Mr. Samy Velu
President
MIC
KL
Good morning Mr Velu,
In yesterday’s The Star you referred to Malaysia as the country of adoption for the Malaysian Indians. Do you understand what this terms means. This is what migrants refer to the country into which they have migrated to, Australia, UK and USA, not born in. You may not have the knowledge to use proper political terms, so I suggest sometimes it pays to have your lips gummed or seek intelligent counsel if you really have something useful to say. As a Malaysian, born of Indian parents, I find your remark offensive and lacking in political intellect. You are not talking to the uninitiated. Please don’t ever forget, there are educated Indians who have put you on judgement.
As far as Malaysian Indian are concerned, Malaysia is their country of birth with full birth rights equal to all and everyone in the country. I am a third generation Malaysian born and brought up in Perak, more precisely in Kammuning estate, not far from the estate where you were a Mandore or clerk along Lintang Road.
By your ill conceived utterance of the term, country of adoption, you are further alienation Indians of people of their rights in their own country. UMNO members may well reward you more. It is most unfortunate the majority of Malaysian Indians are served by individuals like you.
In future please think before you utter nonsense.
May Lord Murga expdite the process of Karma as it is written for you.
Anak Sungei Siput
#20 by AsIseeit on Wednesday, 26 December 2007 - 10:11 am
What can Opposition do re: Sg Siput and any other Parliamentary constituencies?
Simple. Have a coach tour for the voters of Sg Siput and any other relevant constituency, and get them to see the big mansions their politician is living in and how they have worked to benefit themselves rather than their constituencies!
It will be surely be a wonderful experience for the people from the rural areas to see how their leaders have benefitted from their support.
#21 by ktteokt on Wednesday, 26 December 2007 - 11:08 am
Yesterday’s paper announced Samy Vellu being put in charge of all Hindu temples. This means he will enjoy another source of extra income while building shoddy temples for the Hindus and should any one of these temples fall apart, he will just say “This is none of my business!”
#22 by SIMPLYJUSTICE on Wednesday, 26 December 2007 - 9:05 pm
Shameless s/v. this should be the treatment be given to all mic representatives at all levels. it will be a shamefull end, eventualy.
#23 by ktteokt on Thursday, 27 December 2007 - 10:09 am
Today’s report on the hijacking on the relief funds for flood victims proved who the real crooks are. Were they Indian?
#24 by stevendoc2 on Thursday, 27 December 2007 - 3:35 pm
dont worry brothers n sisters….This coming general election, all indian votes for DAP only….it is confirmed.
LKS is the next PM.
#25 by anak sungeisiput on Thursday, 27 December 2007 - 6:24 pm
We are the enlightened ones. blogging within our field. Every one of us should be thinking as to what role can each one of should undertake prior to the GE to promote the oppostiton and deny the MIC and the BS components parties to reduce their votes significantly.
Most of the rural voting Indians are exposed to simple carrots from the MIC during election days.
The opposition parties, not many though, will have to be assisted to (financial, voluteers, house to house cold calls etc) to attract the family vote to DAP and non-BN compliant parties.
As for Nallas party i would not caste a single vote as Datok Nalla has pledged his unquestioning loyalty to BN. My view is that he may well turn out to be another Samy Velu.
#26 by anak sungeisiput on Thursday, 27 December 2007 - 11:19 pm
What the Hindraff leaders have demanded are the equal rights for the marginalised and discriminated Indians. These are due to them after 50 years of indpendence. These rights were temporarily expunged by the Colonial British Government for expediency in the granting of independence in 1957. There were serious deliberations by the 4 eminent jusrists that constituted Reids Commission on the rights of every Malayan. Any special privelage extended to the Malays were temporary and the veracity the any law that grants these special privalges as it has been entrenched now need a fresh examinationof. HINDRAFF leadres were rightfully seeking the Mlaysian and the British government to revisit the arrangement and restore the jus solis ( natural birth rights ) of the Malaysian Indians.
The reality is that the UMNO, as the beneficary of the institutionalised privalged practice, based on the illegitimate (based on international race relations) supremacy of the Malays, will not give in to an inch. The Malays have incarcerated the champions of the working class Indians. Hence, the Malay dominated Malaysian government will have to be brought to the attendion of the international community. The struggle of the Malaysian Indian minorities ought to be lifted to inetrnational level. I suggest that the defence cousel ( Karpal Singh and Srinavasen with the approval of the immediate relatives of the 3 incarcerated leaders of HINDRAFF :
1. Lodge a formal complaint of their incarceration to the attanetion of Dr. Homa YounAlizaden – Email : alizadeh@un.org
Tel 66 2 881496
The Office of UN High Commission for Refugees
Regional Head Office in Bangkok.
2. WAYTHA Moorthy who is said to be in an European country should be advised to immediatly lodge an application for political assylum under the UN Human Rights and Humanitarian gorunds in one of the Euorpean countries.
3. Amnesty International should be asked to adopt the three incarcerated HINDRAFF leaders as political prisonesr of concience.
4. The International Red Cross and the Inrenational Red Crescent be requested to make periodical visits to the three incarcerated HINDRAF leadres.
5. Loby the Minorities Rights Council in London to take on board the Malaysian Indians issues into their agenda and lobby UN.
The South African Apartheid was overcome by concerted international support of various kinds of pressue on the white supremacy government to remove the repugnant discriminatroy practices, which was eventually removed on account of various kinds of sanctions .
People like Kris bearing Hishamuddin and Samy Velu would have to be made accountable to international norm of governance of discriminated minortites in ntheir own country of birth.
#27 by SIMPLYJUSTICE on Sunday, 30 December 2007 - 3:11 am
please support Hindraf’s course by signing at http://www.petitiononline.com/31081957/petition.html
please pass the same to others
#28 by ktteokt on Sunday, 30 December 2007 - 8:58 am
It would be wise for Semi Value to adopt the “ostrich principle”, bury his head in the soil so as to avoid shame!
#29 by senthilnat on Monday, 3 March 2008 - 12:57 am
I am really amazed by politics….This is actually my first time casting a vote and all my life as I grew up I always thought Mahathir was the best politician ever lived and wanted to vote for him all my life……………But maybe I was a bit immature; But realising the amount of marginalisation my community is facing; look I am becoming a racist again; realising how much pain is being face by poor ethnic indian malaysians are facing with curent leadership makes me to shed tears………..cause I have always grown from the above average group and never really faced this kind of hardship or even marginalisation; but realisng the MAIKA scandals and all the other MP making statesmen about the chinese and indian community is no longer tolerable.
LETS NOT GIVE THIS IDIOTS 2/3 MAJORITY AGAIN ! MY VOTE IS FOR DAP !
#30 by senthilnat on Monday, 3 March 2008 - 12:59 am
Please do let me know in what other ways I could be in service ?