Archbishop slams ‘irresponsible, baseless, provocative’ reporting


Malaysiakini
May 8, 11

Archbishop of Kuala Lumpur, Murphy Nicholas Pakiam, has slammed reports alleging a conspiracy to turn the country into a Christian state.

Describing the reports as “irresponsible, baseless and provocative”, Pakiam demanded that the authorities take action against what it said were quarters that seek to threaten the harmonious, multi-cultural and multi-religious make-up of the country.

A “thorough investigation” into the matter should be made to determine the source of these “insidious, provocative and malicious lies” and take action against those behind it, said Pakiam in a statement.

He was responding to the blog postings, on which an Utusan Malaysia report was based, accusing DAP of colluding with Christian pastors to make Christianity the country’s official religion so that a Christian can become prime minister.

‘We’ve never been treasonous, hateful’

Jelutong MP Jeff Ooi was named in the blog postings as the DAP leader who attended the meeting and joined the prayer session with the pastors, who were reportedly attending a mega-ceramah at the Catholic Christian Centre in Penang on Saturday.

“On behalf of the Catholic Bishops of Malaysia, I would like to categorically refute the allegation that such a meeting had taken place or will take place in a Catholic venue in Penang,

“It is clear that this reporting is baseless and highly irresponsible as the reporters and editors of the above newspaper have not taken any reasonable steps whatsoever to verify the allegations made by anonymous bloggers.

“Furthermore, this report comes after the National Evangelical Christian Fellowship (NECF), one of the organizers of the above meeting, having refuted the claims of those bloggers and the same was carried on online media.

“The NECF has further clarified that this meeting only covered the topic of ethical leadership and had no treasonous agenda as alleged by the bloggers and news report,” said Pakiam.

Pakiam said Christian authorities teach the community to be God-fearing and law-abiding citizens and conscientious decision-makers “based on justice which is reflective of moral and divine laws.”

Even in the Al-Kitab issue over which the Christian Federation of Malaysia has been in dispute with the government, Church leaders had always reiterated their commitment and readiness “to dialogue and work together with the government” and all parties for a just and reasonable solution.

“It is clear that our position has never been treasonous nor have we advocated hatred, antagonism or animosity towards any religion or groups of persons,” said Pakiam.

“I continue to call upon all Catholics, Christians and all Malaysians to pray, dialogue and work together to strengthen national unity and harmony. May God bless our leaders with a firm vision and the courage and strength to uphold and realise it.”

‘Utusan playing with fire’

Lending his voice in support of Pakiam’s remarks, PAS Youth chief Nasrudin Hassan also described the blog and Utusan reports over the alleged conspiracy as “irresponsible” and potentially destabilising.

“Other than potentially threatening the peace, such speculations are seen as a means of seeking cheap political publicity and (part of) continuous efforts to hide weaknesses and failure in protecting the sanctity of the (Islamic) religion,” said Nasrudin in a statement entitled ‘Utusan playing with fire’.

Nasrudin said it is a well-known fact that Islam is enshrined as the official religion of the federation, with Muslims making up the majority in Malaysia’s pluralistic population.

“For these reasons, Islam should not be in a position of being jeopardised and the Muslims would not allow Islam to be threatened,” he added.

If Islam is indeed perceived as getting weaker, said Nasruin, it was because of Umno’s failure to fulfil the mandate with which it had been entrusted to govern the nation, particularly in protecting religious practices and the people’s welfare.

“If Umno had taken care of (the practice of) Islam well and strengthened it, I believe and am convinced that such speculations (by Utusan) of moves to make Christianity the official religion of the nation would not have arisen.

“At the same time, Muslims would feel at peace and comfortable with practising their religion,” he added.

  1. #1 by on cheng on Sunday, 8 May 2011 - 4:02 pm

    so what even if it is true ! it is just like a small group of 7 year old kids, saying that they want to make a big group of adult giants to follow small kids order, and those giant want police to catch the kids, those giants are real brainless !

  2. #2 by on cheng on Sunday, 8 May 2011 - 4:04 pm

    those giants had recently forced books used by 7 year old kid must be stamped n hv serial nos, so are the giants scare of 7 year old kids ?

  3. #3 by Loh on Sunday, 8 May 2011 - 4:27 pm

    ///He was responding to the blog postings, on which an Utusan Malaysia report was based, accusing DAP of colluding with Christian pastors to make Christianity the country’s official religion so that a Christian can become prime minister.///

    There is no need to make Christian an official religion so that Christian can become Prime Minister. There is no restriction on the choice of persons based on race or religion, to become Prime Minister.

    ///Describing the reports as “irresponsible, baseless and provocative”, Pakiam demanded that the authorities take action against what it said were quarters that seek to threaten the harmonious, multi-cultural and multi-religious make-up of the country.///

    It was an over reaction by Pakiam. Islam has been made official religion and state funds have been used to promote the religion, making Christianity official religion would be good for the country too, when abundant state funds could be similarly utilized. Indeed government coffers do not choose as to who contribute, and funds are used to promote Islam, they can similarly be used to promote Christianity. Religions are meant to promote good and law abiding citizens. So, what is wrong in making Christianity an official religion?

    There is no threat to peace and security even if what was reported were true. Why should Pakiam be so defensive?

    ///Nasrudin said it is a well-known fact that Islam is enshrined as the official religion of the federation, with Muslims making up the majority in Malaysia’s pluralistic population.///

    Making Christianity official religion of the country does not in any way weaken another official religion. It just means that government funds can be legally alloted to promote that religion only. Indeed, practicing non-official religion in the country is not injurious to the nation. Yes Utusan Melayu wanted to create a sense of jealousy. But Christians should consider applying for the religion to be place on an official status.

  4. #4 by on cheng on Sunday, 8 May 2011 - 4:42 pm

    aiyoh, loh, dreaming kah? wan 2 make christian official religion?
    wait til year 2222 lah, maybe,
    now wan to build a new church oso so veri difficult, what more………?

  5. #5 by cemerlang on Sunday, 8 May 2011 - 4:42 pm

    Irresponsible leaders breed irresponsible followers. Cakap tak rupa bikin.

  6. #6 by Loh on Sunday, 8 May 2011 - 5:31 pm

    on cheng :
    aiyoh, loh, dreaming kah? wan 2 make christian official religion?
    wait til year 2222 lah, maybe,
    now wan to build a new church oso so veri difficult, what more………?

    It is within the right of citizens to request, and the authorities would certainly reject. What is pathetic is the lack of courage even to request. I say let Utusan Melayu says what it pleases, and Christians just take up the suggestion and request that Christianity be made an official religion to be eligible for state support. Why can’t government funds be utilized to build churches when they can be used to build mosques. It can’t ow because Christianity is not yet an official religion. Aren’t all citizens have the freedom to practice the religion of his choice, and is it too much to ask the government to help finance non-Muslims’ places of worship? Islam is the official religion now. It does not mean that another religion cannot be offered official status. Indeed official religion does not mean 1religion.

  7. #7 by Bigjoe on Sunday, 8 May 2011 - 5:54 pm

    Irresponsible, baseless, provocative? If precedent is law, what they did was criminal mischief potentially felonius. They broke the law. Period. Utusan is no more than a common criminal…

  8. #8 by k1980 on Monday, 9 May 2011 - 9:08 am

    In Mein Kampf, Hitler uses the main thesis of “the Jewish peril”, which speaks of an alleged Jewish conspiracy to gain leadership in Germany and the world.

    In utusan malysia, umno uses the main thesis of “the christian peril”, which speaks of an alleged christian-dap conspiracy to gain national leadership

You must be logged in to post a comment.