A Law To Prevent Defections


(Speech when moving a motion in Parliament on March 21, 1978 to seek leave of the House to introduce a private member’s bill intituled Members of Parliament [Prevention of Defection] Act 1978 to ensure political integrity of Members of Parliament)

I rise under Standing Order 49(2) to move a motion to seek leave of the House to introduce a Private Member’s Bill intituled Members of Parliament (Prevention of Defection) Act, 1978, which would require a Member of Parliament to vacate his seat within 30 days and cause a by-election to be held on his resignation or expulsion from the Party on whose ticket he was originally elected.

In November last year, I was invited by a Tamil national daily, Tamil Nesan, to answer question submitted by Tamil Nesan readers. One question that was asked was about the defection of Opposition Members of Parliament and State Assemblymen after their election, in betrayal of the confidence and trust placed on them by the electorate.

I was asked what effective measure could be taken to prevent such opportunistic political betrayal of the people’s confidence. I replied that the most effective way would be for the enactment of a law requiring a Member of Parliament to vacate his seat and cause a by-election to be held on his resignation or expulsion from the Party on whose ticket he was originally elected. I promised to move a private member’s bill on his matter considering its importance.

Such a Bill is important so as to ensure the political integrity of elected MPs and to prevent political corruption.

Nothing disgusts the Malaysian public more than to see MPs or State Assemblymen elected on one party’s ticket and then betray the Party and the people’s trust by switching parties. This makes them very little different from con-men. Such practices debase politics, and strengthen the general impression that ‘politics is dirty’, when it is the dirty people who get into politics to make politics dirty.

The defection of MPs or State Assemblymen from parties on whose ticket they got elected is most undesirable and unethical, because they are elected not because of their personal qualities, but because of the Party they represent. Such practices also permit elected politicians to be bought and sold as if they are on the market place.

If an elected MP resigns or is expelled from the Party on whose ticket he was originally elected, then he should resign his seat and cause a by-election to be held. If the resignation and expulsion is over a matter of political principle which has the support of the people, then the MP or State Assemblymen concerned should have no qualms about getting re-elected.

We all know that Barisan Nasional parties require its candidates to sign undated letters of resignations to keep their elected MPs or State Assemblymen in line. Just before the Kelantan state general elections last month, the Kelantan UMNO State Liaison Chairman, Tengku Razaleigh, felt it necessary to declare publicly that UMNO Kelantan has taken steps to prevent UMNO candidates from betraying the party after they are elected. He said every UMNO candidate is required to sign undated letters of resignation to be kept in custody by UMNO, which it would use in the event of betrayal.

Of course, under normal circumstances, the Government party can keep its MPs in control through its wide paraphernalia of patronage, influence and largesse. This, however, tantamounts to another form of political corruption.

A law which I am proposing will uphold political integrity of MPs and be a serious deterrent to political corruption. Those who wish to see a cleaner political atmosphere should give it support.

  1. #1 by madmix on Tuesday, 25 March 2008 - 9:56 am

    Cases of BN reps hopping into the opposition is extremely rare. Almost all the katak cases were non-BN joining the BN gravy train. So why are they so agitated about the prospects of their own joining the other side? A taste of their own medicine.

  2. #2 by lkc57 on Tuesday, 25 March 2008 - 10:08 am

    Suddenly it is suggested to have law to curb MPs to “jump ship” when BN is under threat! BN has been all along happily welcoming opposition to join them a tinge of guilt. All this only shows how irresponsible and unethical of our “leaders”.

    There are two sides of a coin. The question is whether the elected MP pays allegiance to the people or his party. He has got to make a wise decision: to leave the party whose leadership has already totally lost direction (who bring more harm to the nation) to continue serving the people.

  3. #3 by lkc57 on Tuesday, 25 March 2008 - 10:09 am

    Correction: … without a tinge of guilt.
    Sorry

  4. #4 by lkc57 on Tuesday, 25 March 2008 - 10:42 am

    Change is inevitable. Malaysians have evolved to become more informed of their rights. March 8 saw Malaysians rose up. It was a pity that the wind of change had not swept to East Malaysia. Otherwise, history would have been rewritten.

    What is so wrong if MPs switched camp, if it comes to their realisation that they were misled by their party. It is important that their conscience is right. They are not bribed to do so. Ok, if switching is immoral and irresponsible, then just make way for a re-election. See what the people want this time around. This, I feel, is more pressingly important instead of continue living under uncertainty.

  5. #5 by wag-the-dog on Tuesday, 25 March 2008 - 10:45 am

    The US sub-prime crisis in graphics – Part 1 & 2
    The US sub-prime mortgage crisis has lead to plunging property prices, a slowdown in the US economy, and billions in losses by banks. It stems from a fundamental change in the way mortgages are funded. There seems to be no end to this and with the collapse of the investment banking giant Bear Stearn last week, it is believed more is to come.

    It is inevitable the there is going to be a global economic crisis unlike the 1997 crash which started in the stock market, this has started in the core of the economy – Housing. In no time it will see our shores and our new cabinet has to be ready to face it. This two part article is to give us Malaysians a better understanding of this crisis preempt our government.

    How it went wrong!

    visit http://www.wagthedog-malaysia.blogspot.com

  6. #6 by madmix on Tuesday, 25 March 2008 - 11:23 am

    Now the FROG PRINCE is calling for the extermination of all frogs:
    NST on line:
    PUTRAJAYA: Parti Bersatu Sabah (PBS) supports the proposal to ban party-hopping as the practice caused political instability.

  7. #7 by lakilompat on Tuesday, 25 March 2008 - 11:33 am

    Political instability is caused by cronies, a sleeping PM, and an end product of Oxford (Khairy).

    The Frogs are just there bidding their time with their eye open bidding for the right time to jump.

    They will join the rakyat to slap those cronies, Khairy, and to awake the sleeping beauty PM.

    It’s funny to see the sleeping beauty PM rudely awaken got slapped in his face then suddenly lost 5 states, lost the power to appoint MB in Perlis and Terengganu, and thankfully still have a new wife to enjoy.

  8. #8 by pjboy on Tuesday, 25 March 2008 - 12:20 pm

    Lakilompat: Maybe it is Oxford Tuition Center (UK = Ulu Klang) lah.

    If any party members were sacked, don’t see why they can’t join the parties of their choice since they will have automatically become an independent. I think the basics here should be ‘freedom-of choice’.

  9. #9 by lakilompat on Tuesday, 25 March 2008 - 3:52 pm

    U dun join a party to get restricted by “freedom of choice” u join party becos u think your little talent and wit can make the party stronger.

  10. #10 by limkamput on Tuesday, 25 March 2008 - 11:53 pm

    LadyGodiva Says: Yesterday at 19: 50.31
    “Anti-hopping law – constitutional or unconstitutional? What is clear is that you cannot keep the cake and eat it at the same time.”

    You think you so smart. Keep half and eat half lah, that is your expertise.

  11. #11 by lakilompat on Monday, 21 April 2008 - 3:17 pm

    There is no law for this hopper, everyone is free to hop around.

You must be logged in to post a comment.