I challenge the Information Minister, Datuk Seri Zainuddin Maidin to regularly update the RTM website with my blog postings to let the Malaysian public evaluate their quality and veracity.
Yesterday, on the sidelines of the Umno General Assembly, Zainuddin announced the RTM website www.rtm.net.my will publish selected comments from blog.limkitsiang.com to let readers judge for themselves my blog.
Yesterday, the RTM website started a new “Media Baru” section which carried a YouTube video of the parliamentary exchange between Zainuddin and myself on press freedom and two of my blog postings, Zam – Info Minister under coconut shell or bidding to be Mat Rempit “Godfather”? (26th October 2007) and Zam sees red in being called “monkey” in this blog (November 7, 2007).
Let Zainuddin state where I had made “sensationalized, racist and chauvinistic comments” in these two blog postings.
In my Oct. 26 posting, I said that Zainuddin “has provided proof that he runs the Information Ministry like a frog under the coconut shell blissfully unaware that in the era of globalization and international competitiveness Malaysia cannot turn a blind eye to complaints, whether by Malaysians or foreigners, about misgovernance”.
This was in connection with the complaint by a visiting Canadian consultant, Manjit Sokhai, who had complained to the Parliamentary Caucus on Human Rights and Good Governance “about the menace of Mat Remptism, of which he was the most recent victim”.
Manjit , 43, from Montreal visits Malaysia three to four times a year in connection with his work. He was driving his four-wheel drive along Jalan Rasah, Seremban at about 11pm on Oct 20, with three friends from India when he was confronted by some 40 Mat Rempits on motorcycles, who assaulted him and went on to damage his vehicle, smashing the rear lights, wipers and number plate.
At the media conference at the Parliament lobby, where Manjit attended, I cited the recent crimes of Mat Rempitism, including murder, where even police and road transport officials had become victims, and called on the Prime Minister, Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi to give his personal attention to wipe out the Mat Rempit menace subverting law and order, creating fear among Malaysians and visitors about their personal safety, giving the country a bad name internationally and undermining Malaysia’s international competitiveness.
In my November 7 posting, I referred to the parliamentary exchange on 5th November 2007 where Zainuddin started by accusing me of calling him a “monkey” in my blog, but backing down when confronted and admitting it was a comment left on the blog.
Zainuddin had distorted what transpired in the parliamentary exchange by claiming that I had apologized for the comment. I did not apologise. I did express regret at the language used which was brought about by the low level of discourse caused by Zainuddin’s mischievous and irresponsible utterances.
Yes, I had said in my blog that I was surprised that the RTM on 6th November had telecast the parliamentary exchange. Why? This is explained by one email which I received on the parliamentary telecast:
“Dear Mr Lim:
“I hardly watch TV but made it a point to watch last night’s telecast of your debate with Zam.
“Since Zam (I presume) controls RTM, I can only conclude that he had the debate shown as it would (he thought) make him look good.
“This really perplexes me – I would be ashamed, if I were him, to behave like that as a Minister. He demonstrated his stupidity and shallowness of thought to the whole country on national TV, seems to me that calling him a monkey is less an insult to him and more of an insult to the real monkeys in the forest, and you may quote me!
“Richard Teoh”
Zainuddin should stop misleading the Malaysian public. I never called him a monkey in my blog as he had first alleged in the parliamentary exchange, as borne out by the Hansard, viz:
Datuk Seri Zainuddin bin Maidin: Bagaimana kredibiliti, bagaimana kualitinya DAP apa yang ditulis tentang saya dalam DAP. Say baca… .. “Zam is behaving like BN monkey that gone bananas over nuts”… .
[Dewan riuh]
Datuk Seri Zainuddin bin Maidin: Malu! Malu! Seorang anggota Parlimen menulis macam ini di sini, malu!
Tuan Lim Kit Siang [Ipoh Timur]: Siapa tulis itu?
Datuk Seri Zainuddin bin Maidin: You tulis, tapi tak usahlah… you tak usah kata you tak tulis, ini Lim Kit Siang blog.
Tuan Lim Kit Siang [Ipoh Timur]: Itu komen atau saya tulis? Bukan, adakah saya menulis? Itu komen pelawat-pelawat.
[Dewan riuh]
Zainuddin should be educated about blogs, which consist of two parts — my postings and comments from visitors.
I am responsible for every word of my own postings. As for the comments from visitors, I accept responsibility for providing the platform for divergent views expressed but I do not accept responsibility for every view expressed — which will be most ridiculous when diametrically contrary views are aired!
Just as I never called Zainuddin a “monkey”, the Information Minister was very mischievous and irresponsible in alleging that I wanted him and Khairy Jamaluddin to be killed by Mat Rempits.
The comment he referred to was not any incitement to kill Zam and Khairy but an expression of disgust at their irresponsibility in ignoring the menace of Mat Remptism whose depredations are race-blind, causing the poster to give expression to the despair that both of them would only realize the nefarious nature of Mat Rempitism if they themselves suffer the criminal worst in the hands of the Mat Rempits.
Again, it is regrettable that such a comment is posted, but does Zainuddin understand why his indifference to the menace of Mat Rempitism has driven many Malaysians to despair?

#1 by malaysiatoday.com on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 2:34 am
After I watched Zam’s interview by Al Jazeera in RTM, I feel shame with Zam’s performance as an Information Minister
He was not responding like a mature man and also spoke broken English.
=========
Zam Refutes Al Jazeera’s Claim Police Used Force On Protesters
KUALA LUMPUR, Nov 10 (Bernama) — Information Minister Datuk Seri Zainuddin Maidin has refuted satellite television station Al Jazeera’s claim that police had used force on hundreds of protesters here today.
He told the station that police had tried to disperse the protesters by using water cannons as the gathering was illegal. “When they refused to disperse, the police allowed them to march to Istana Negara to hand over a memorandum demanding for a clean and fair election.
“The police managed to handle the situation as best they could,” he said over the phone in a live interview by Al Jazeera here.
He was responding to the illegal assembly organised by the Coalition for Clean and Fair Elections or “Bersih” comprising 26 non-governmental organisations and which also involved opposition parties, to hand over the memorandum containing their demands, to Istana Negara.
Asked why Malaysia did not allow such gatherings, Zainuddin said they were unnecessary because general elections had been held without fail in this country and according to the scheduled dates.
The minister also hit out at Al Jazeera for having the wrong perception when posing questions.
Al Jazeera reporters had their own perceptions about Malaysia before coming here, he said, adding that “Malaysia is not Myanmar or Pakistan; it is a democratic country”.
Zainuddin said many television viewers in Malaysia were laughing at the antics of the Al Jazeera reporter who seemed to be trying to portray the situation as ugly.
“The reporter was seen shouting, so much so the situation seemed unreal to the viewers.”
He also criticised Al Jazeera for only interviewing journalists known to be pro-opposition but not getting the government’s views.
– BERNAMA http://www.bernama.com.my/bernama/v3/news.php?id=295412
#2 by malaysiatoday.com on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 2:40 am
Malaysia mainstream newspapers is deteriorating to “piece mouth” standard in the communist countries.
#3 by wits0 on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 2:45 am
I’m not sure it’s possible to take a Banana, er…Bernama report on the weather seriously.
#4 by Programmer on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 3:02 am
Zam Zam ala Kazam….
Truly a man without intelligent aka stupid …..blogging oso dunno ….
#5 by HJ Angus on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 7:04 am
Sounds like the Iraqi Info Minister who became famous for his remarks about the US troops in Baghdad!
#6 by Godfather on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 7:43 am
We never disallowed postings from cybertroopers loyal to BN. They send UMNO apologists from time to time like RealWorld to distract and to provoke, but even they could not sustain their arguments against the lies, the cheating and the stealing. They end up asking: Are you sure you can do better when you come to power ? That’s all they can do – justifying their stealing on the basis that it is normal behaviour and anybody in power would do it.
#7 by k1980 on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 7:57 am
New York-based Human Rights Watch slammed the government’s stance on the mass rally, which Prime Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi had vowed to suppress, and police had threatened to arrest protesters. “If Malaysia wants to count itself a democracy, it can begin by upholding constitutional guarantees of free speech and assembly. The way the system works now, only the ruling coalition can get its messages out,” it said. Human Rights Watch said Malaysian elections have been sullied by vote-buying, the use of public resources by the ruling parties and accusations of bias against the Election Commission.
http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/afp_asiapacific/view/310787/1/.html
#8 by AhPek on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 8:16 am
Come on lah, Zam, of all people you, calling yourself Minister of Information not knowing the difference between a blogger and a commenter of a blog.One is expressing his opinion and the other a response to that opinion.
The thing about you Umnoputra people is that over the years of shameless cheating you people have evolve a skin no longer sensitive to such a thing call shame,I wouldn’t expect you to resign.After all they are people amongst you who commit heinous crime and getting away from it scotch free.
#9 by Godfather on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 8:54 am
Zam’s English in the Al Jazeera interview was terrible. Reminds me of Syed Hamid’s interview with BBC Hardtalk. Can UMNO please send ministers who can speak proper English ? Don’t send people like Mat Taib, who has confirmed he doesn’t understand English. Don’t send Azeez Rahman who hasn’t gotten rid of his Indian accent.
#10 by Bigjoe on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 8:59 am
Posting on the RTM website? That mean lying. Zam is the head of those people that can’t stand the truth especially about themselves. Of course they see they convince themselves that its really their point of view, but you know deluded people can’t be helped.
Today they report that the Bersih rally was a failure because no 100,000 people showed up. 40,000 people is a failure for the opposition but they get a few of people to shout about something and its a national agenda. to them…Its a lie by almost any measure except the real sicko….
#11 by Bill Gates on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 9:18 am
What do you expect from a man who didn’t even understand the word democracy to understand what a weblog is ….
Memang tepat si mamak ni ibarat katak di bawah tempurung lapok.
#12 by justice88 on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 9:35 am
This is a very good example on how the Malaysian education system has failed. Just like how our beloved PM reacted to the BERSIH demonstrations. Suggesting the people to vote whereas we want electoral reform. How can we vote when we have no confidence in the government? That is why Malaysia is tumbling down in every ranking. Zam, if you’re reading this, I want you to know that you do not deserve your post. Your response to Mr. Lim has exhibited your true level of education. Please kindly relinquish it.
#13 by mendela on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 9:47 am
Similar to the extreme popular website weloveiraqiinformationminister.com, can someone out there start Malaysian version of welovemalaysianinformationminister.com?
#14 by hansoh on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 10:30 am
http://www.rtm.net.my/forum/viewforum.php?f=10
Check the link about, you can see some sex content in RTM forum. How can these kind of forum appear in RTM web site? Those people are sleeping? What kind of management quality is this?
#15 by Jong on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 11:29 am
Bigjoe,
You know who this Goblok Zam reminds me of? – the last Iraqi Information Minister in Saddam Hussein’s government, Muhammed Saeed al-Sahaf aka MSS. That gig was always in denial syndrome. Even after the first US coalition bomb was dropped over Bagdad, he still denied it and braved cameras to aske foreign reporters, “Are their troops in Bagdad yet?” Joke of the century!
#16 by Jong on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 11:31 am
Even the Iraqi military was fooled by this gig!
#17 by Jong on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 11:32 am
macam macam dalam dunia ini!
#18 by k1980 on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 12:13 pm
The confrontation between the country’s nine sultans and the government appears to be deepening as well, with Mizan Zainal Abidin, the Sultan of Terengganu, who currently holds the rotating kingship and is Malaysia’s constitutional head of state, ordering his royal guards to stand aside so that the marchers could deliver the petition despite the fact that police had refused to grant a permit for the rally.
http://www.asiasentinel.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=863&Itemid=31
Human Rights Watch,the US-based human rights advocacy organization, issued a press release Friday evening condemning the Malaysian police for refusing to grant the permit, saying that “If Malaysia wants to count itself a democracy, it can begin by upholding constitutional guarantees of free speech and assembly.”…The rally is to some extent an outgrowth of a previous one on Sept. 26 when an estimated 2,000 lawyers marched on Putrajaya, the country’s administrative capital, to demand that the judiciary be cleaned up in the wake of allegations that a well-connected lawyer connived in 2002 with Ahmad Fairuz Sheikh Abdul Halim, who was then the chief judge of the Federal Court, to select pliant members of the bar as judges.
http://www.asiasentinel.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=862&Itemid=31
#19 by lakshy on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 12:24 pm
Read what it says in the star about Zam’s comments……
“Asked why Malaysia did not allow such gatherings, Zainuddin said they were unnecessary because general elections had been held without fail in this country.”
Note that neither he nor Najib denied the fact that the elections were not free and fair!
And the chief of police, who has a higher title of Tan Sri, than our PM, said that, the water cannons and tear gas were deployed as the crowds refused to disperse. Anyone have recordings of the police giving such warnings? Why doesn’t RTM/TV3 show the footage?
Chief of Police, I think you have forgotten who you are employed to protect!
I take my hats off to the 100,000+ who reacted calmly to the water cannons and tear gas and did not retaliate. Now thats something of Gandhian magnitude! I salute you guys!
And the Star article further claims that they let the marchers through instead of admitting that the marchers used back lanes and alleys to get to their destination!
SYABAS!
#20 by aurora on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 1:40 pm
Quote:
Datuk Seri Zainuddin bin Maidin: Bagaimana kredibiliti, bagaimana kualitinya DAP apa yang ditulis tentang saya dalam DAP. Say baca….. “Zam is behaving like BN monkey that gone bananas over nutsâ€Â….
[Dewan riuh]
Datuk Seri Zainuddin bin Maidin: Malu! Malu! Seorang anggota Parlimen menulis macam ini di sini, malu!
Tuan Lim Kit Siang [Ipoh Timur]: Siapa tulis itu?
Datuk Seri Zainuddin bin Maidin: You tulis, tapi tak usahlah…you tak usah kata you tak tulis, ini Lim Kit Siang blog.
Tuan Lim Kit Siang [Ipoh Timur]: Itu komen atau saya tulis? Bukan, adakah saya menulis? Itu komen pelawat-pelawat.
[Dewan riuh]
end quote.
Sorry…one trivial question..did the above conversation took place in parliament? If it is, I’m very, very disappointed. “You” repeated 3 times. That’s not Malay! And I remember long time ago, the gov intended to use Malay in all official matters. Well, there’s goes one of the gov “policy”….*sigh*…hangat-hangat tahi ayam….
Secondly,
“Datuk Seri Zainuddin bin Maidin: You tulis, tapi tak usahlah…you tak usah kata you tak tulis, ini Lim Kit Siang blog.”
I assume that this is not how a Minister should behave. That’s a harsh remark and i dont see any proof to that claim. If there is any, plz present.
*sigh*…
#21 by June07 on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 4:04 pm
Please do not go to the site http://www.rtm.net.my/forum/viewforum.php f?=10 above as I just got the trojan virus when attempted to click to latest thread.
#22 by justice_fighter on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 5:44 pm
Zam’s interview at Al-Jazeera is a total disaster!! A standard 1 student can speak better English than him. What a big Shame to be our Information Minister!! Better call himself MIS-Information Minister!!
#23 by sj on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 8:46 pm
So it proved to us beyond a shadow of a doubt, Zam deserves to be fired. He is not minister material. This dude does even have a common sense for goodness sake. Listen to the way he speaks and you know his mind is full of garbage and warped mentality. Mind you he is but one UMNO member, group together all the UMNO members and voila you have yourself a few millions of moron trying to run the country to the ground. Enough is enough, get rid of these stupid incompetent morons. Everyone does not want people like them to run the country.
#24 by Sagaladoola on Sunday, 11 November 2007 - 9:15 pm
As an Information Minister, one has to be savvy on Information Technology.
We are living in the Information Age. If an Information Minister cannot understand the concepts of the Information Age tools and differentiate between posting of the website owner and other visitors, I sincerely do not know how this fella here is going to do his work.
Sometimes, Uncle Kit, it is hard for us to argue with a person who is of low intelligence.
Furthermore, there is an issue of ethics. Can a Minister use a mainstream public media, which is supposed to be independent of political affiliation to further one’s political ambitions….
I feel ashamed, not only for Zam, but for myself.. How am I supposed to tell my foreign friends that he is the Information Minister of my land when they ask?
I think I’d rather get scarce and find a hole to hide my face.. Malu !
Regards,
http://sagaladoola.blogspot.com
#25 by Bigfoot on Monday, 12 November 2007 - 1:53 am
Somebody, please send our Minister for Public Enlightenment and Propaganda to some charm school on social etiquette. While you are at it, please send him for a course on the how to speak the English language, without sounding like a scratched record playing backwards!
Zam’s handling of the Al-Jazeera interview was a complete embarrassment…even to staunch BN supporters!
Zam may as well have taken a line from Mohammed Saeed al-Sahaf’s (former Iraqi Minister for Information) treasury of deathless quotes, “I blame Al-Jazeera – they are marketing for the Americans!” http://www.welovetheiraqiinformationminister.com/
At least Mohammed Saeed al-Sahaf was entertaining. Zam is a complete embarrassment. Even Goebbels would be rolling in his grave!
#26 by wits0 on Monday, 12 November 2007 - 3:23 am
Certainly Mohammed Saeed al-Sahaf aka Bagdad Bob was far more entertaining.
Zam’s denial resembles the floor tantrum of a spoilt 5 year old.
He’s totally unable to rebut the matter.
BTW,
To rebut means: 1. Overthrow by argument, evidence, or proof
2. Prove to be false or incorrect.
To deny means: 1. Declare untrue; contradict
2. Refuse to accept or believe
#27 by k1980 on Monday, 12 November 2007 - 1:18 pm
That’s why uncle Zam is so against the teaching of Mathematics and Science in the English Language. He’s scared kampung school kids would be so proficient in English that they would laugh at his pitiful English
#28 by lupus on Monday, 12 November 2007 - 9:57 pm
All I can say about Zam is that he is a MORON. We should disown this MORON as this is the voice of MALAYSIA and he is a moron compared to Jeff Ooi in the interview. If you are reading this ZAM – you are nothing but a moron, foolish idiot that is the product of NEP – someone whom did not work to get to where you are today. I wish I could say that to your face but I will have to settle that you might read this on the DAP website. Afterall, you are not a man, just a monkey boy like those in the village with a long leash to gather fruits and the other end, the PM holding your leash.
#29 by watgoblok on Monday, 12 November 2007 - 10:24 pm
[deleted] take Uncle Kit’s challenge if you have one or two.
#30 by bra888 on Tuesday, 13 November 2007 - 12:51 am
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHC1ogF4ai8
I noticed a few things.
Zam only reveals the ‘negative’ part of the blog.
He exposed things like:
“Zam should be killed by Mat Rempit”
“Zam behaves like a monkey”
I also noticed that there was a long pause (like 7 seconds), then he claims that there are more bad things in this blog.
He claims that Lim Kit Siang apologize for the first time.
Lots of repeats of the same words and phrase (waste of the reporters time if you ask me)
“Be responsible”
“Lim Kit Siang is the greatest politician in Malaysia”
“This is Lim Kit Siang’s Blog”
Repeats English sentence in BM.
That’s clearly biased already. I don’t think he’s fit to be an Information Minister.
Even students need to recognize what is bias and what is not to get good marks. I wonder how much marks would a lecturer evaluate him. Jeffrey, I heard you are a lecturer, how much marks would you give him XD.
#31 by Man_of_Honour on Tuesday, 13 November 2007 - 12:56 pm
Slap on the face Zam! Haha, what a shameful “Minister of Infrogmation”… This is how BN ministers behave in the Dewan Rakyat… Aiks… It’s known to the entire world… and now, BN call this glamour!
Duh! Cut the crap and continue with your “teh tarek” oops, I mean “work (singular)”.
Don’t BN ministers know that in the eyes of the RAKYAT and International societies, they are being laughed at and some even think that they are clowns?
And those BN ministers still felt glamour and happy! Pening!
For goodness sake, please stop saying Zam or other BN ministers are behaving like monkeys!
This is an insult to the monkeys and will spoil the monkeys’ reputation! We have to be fair to the monkeys!
#32 by ktteokt on Wednesday, 14 November 2007 - 10:21 am
They always say, “Tell the truth and nothing but the truth” but they left out an important part at the end for this is not the complete sentence. This should be followed by “But for God’s sake, tell only that much of the truth that will do you the most good!!”
#33 by josephswn on Thursday, 15 November 2007 - 2:40 pm
hey Zam
thank you for giving mileage to Kit Siang to publish his blogs. pls, publish more… you should publish everything and create hyperlink as well.
is good that you finally use RTM for unbias show of ppl’s opinion. you behave like a small kid buddy. ppl are free to voice their opinions via blog and at least Kit Siang is stopping others from voicing their voices. unlike your stupid mercenary RTM and the rest of The STAR and NST, everybody know that it is BIG FAT LIEING media for you and BN. wake up buddy, please google the meaning of BLOG and BLOGGING. if you are still katak bawah tempurung, pls don’t act like a smart donkey aka IDIOT.
why not create debate session between BN and Opposition party and live telecast it. bring your best speakers from UMNO since the rest of the parties are useless anyway and challenge the speakers from Opposition or maybe the common citizen. beat you flat on your face