Spare the Rod, Spoil the Country

by John Berthelsen
Wednesday, 24 February 2010

Malaysia seeks to organize an international caning conference

Malaysia appears determined to make an international fool of itself. The latest news, according to Shahrizat Abdul Jalil, the Women’s Minister, is that the country is considering organizing an international conference on caning and whether it is an appropriate punishment for women under Islamic law.

The announcement by Shahrizat comes on the heels of a government statement last week, nine days after the fact, that a shariah court had ordered the caning of three women for adultery. A fourth, far more publicized, is the case of Kartika Dewi Shukarni, a part-time model who was ordered by a shariah court to be caned for drinking beer. The case is still hanging fire while the Regent of Pahang decides how to treat the matter.

This all is in addition to the widely publicized show trial of opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim on charges of consensual sex with a male, a selective prosecution at best even if he did it, since Kuala Lumpur throngs with gay bars, and political persecution at the worst over widespread suspicion that the charges were trumped up. There is also the January violence in the wake of a high court judge’s decision to allow the Malaysian Catholic Church to use the word Allah as a synonym for God in its Malay-language editions of its newspaper, the Catholic Herald. Eleven churches, a Sikh temple and two Muslim prayer rooms were attacked.

Many critics hold UMNO responsible for fanning racial disharmony. In the cases of the prayer rooms, eight UMNO members were arrested for attacking them in an apparent attempt to make it look like either Chinese or Indians had done it. There are similar suspicions that ethnic Malays had thrown pigs’ heads with money in their mouths into mosques in Kuala Lumpur.

That, plus the continuing political turmoil, appears to be driving up flight capital totals and citizens who are leaving along with their money. And it is giving international investors some serious second thoughts at a time when the export-led economy is finally starting to emerge from the global financial crisis that began in October of 2008.

As to the caning, in the first place the government ought to organize a conference on whether caning, Malaysia style, is an appropriate punishment for anybody, anywhere, unless for crooked government politicians, of which Malaysia has a surfeit . Although caning is officially outlawed in only 25 countries, it is rare in a lot more, and in very few is it practiced as barbarically — on men — as it is in Malaysia, which until quite recently was regarded by the world as one of the globe’s most advanced Islamic states.

Now that reputation is in shreds, largely driven not by religion but by politics. Parti Islam se-Malaysia, or PAS, a traditionally conservative opposition Islamic party, has expressed concern about the canings, announced by Hishammuddin Hussein, the Home Minister. It may well be that PAS will end up more lenient on caning than UMNO, and thus draw in more moderate Malays alienated. Dzulkefly Ahmad, the Islamist party’s chief strategist, called the canings politically motivated and said Islamic justice calls for fairness without cruelty or corruption.

The caning itself makes one wonder if Malaysia can do anything right. Hishammuddin told reporters the caning was carried out while the women were fully clothed and seated, and the person wielding the whip was not allowed to raise his (or her) arm above the shoulder. The caning, he said, “did not injure them, [but] the three women said it caused pain within their souls.”

One would assume that the purpose of corporal punishment is to cause pain. And when it is done to males in Malaysia and other countries that were once part of the British empire, the damage from the rotan, a thick rattan whip, can be so traumatic that they pass out after one or two strokes. The wounds can take months to heal, at which time the authorities may subject the offender to the rest of his strokes. Offenders have been known to beg for more prison time to escape the rotan. Authorities use only a light rattan stick to hit women on their backs.

So what the caning of the women has done is to show that to much of the world the authorities look like barbarians, while to the rest of it they look like fools for sparing the rod and trying to have it both ways.

Certainly, the outcry across both Malaysia and the world should have been enough to give pause to the government.

“The case constitutes further discrimination against Muslim women in Malaysia,” said Hamidah Marican, executive director of Sisters in Islam, a moderate Muslim women’s group, in a statement. “And to do this surreptitiously implies that the government wanted to hide this degrading and unjust treatment from public scrutiny.” Sofia Lim Sui Ching, president of the All Women’s Action Society (AWAM), told local media the government must explain itself for allowing the punishment to be carried out in a government prison in secret without addressing issues raised in Kartika’s case, which is still hanging fire while the ex-model meets with the Regent of Pahang.

“The caning of these three women is just the tip of the iceberg,” said Donna Guest, Deputy Director of Amnesty International’s Asia-Pacific program, in a prepared statement. “Since 2002 the Malaysian authorities have caned over 35,000 people, mostly non-Malaysians for immigration offenses.”

The rights organizations also object on the basis that Malaysia has a two-tier justice system. Muslims come under the jurisdiction of shariah courts for personal matters as a result of changes pushed through by former Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad in the 1990s to create a parallel court system. The other 40 percent of Malaysia’s 28 million people, mostly ethnic Chinese and Indians, come under the regular civil courts. Under the country’s civil justice system, flogging of wmen is forbidden. Thus, the rights groups say, Muslim women are being discriminated against.

Nonetheless, Shahrizat said she plans to invite ministers from other Muslim-majority countries, academics and religious experts to exchange “ideas and experiences with regards to the implementation of shariah law.”

This is not particularly a product of Islam. Judicial corporal punishment in Asia is practiced only in countries formerly ruled by the British. The late Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto put an end to the practice in Pakistan.

Despite the concerns over the Anwar trial, which has drawn criticism from lawmakers in Australia and the US as trumped up to snuff out a legitimate opposition, tourism visits are up – or were, hitting about 1.5 million from January 2009, a rise of 7.2 percent year-on-year in October. Expectations of a double-digit increase in 2010 tourism may be dampened by the publicity.

  1. #1 by yhsiew on Friday, 26 February 2010 - 7:47 am

    Spare the Rod, Save the Country!

    Caning of women will frighten off potential foreign investors.

  2. #2 by chengho on Friday, 26 February 2010 - 8:08 am

    interesting write up ; “opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim on charges of consensual sex with a male, a selective prosecution at best even if he did it”

  3. #3 by Lee Wang Yen on Friday, 26 February 2010 - 8:53 am

    If Chengho had understood the meaning of ‘even if’, particularly its use in the rhetorical strategy of granting for the sake of argument an assumption denied by someone so as to show a fortiori that the statement affirmed in the conclusion is false or unjustified, he wouldn’t have found that sentence particularly interesting.

  4. #4 by pemudakl77 on Friday, 26 February 2010 - 9:19 am

    Mr Old Man Kit Siang,

    Pls mind your Civil Law business. An Ultra Kiasu leaders, only stupid Malays will believe in your words.

    Pray that you will leave this World a.s.a.p!

    Bye Mr Old Man

  5. #5 by Joetan on Friday, 26 February 2010 - 9:20 am

    Malaysia is heading towards Taliban regime all because of UMNOputras greediness to grab more of the country’s wealth and power. Umnoputras wanted to paint themselves holier than PAS to win the heart of the muslims. Now, even the Womens right has been violated.

  6. #6 by Bigjoe on Friday, 26 February 2010 - 9:25 am

    Bottom line is that the UMNO/BN system continue to perverse the priorities we need to address. If you believe in canning, its not women for immoral reasons that should be address first, it should be canning of corrupt politicians, rapist and wife-beaters that need to be addressed first but those are under not under the jurisdiction of syariah.

    It underlies the fact that UMNO/BN system and ideas have run its course and perverted. It simply not focus on what we should be focussed on and making changes not where change need to be.

    I don’t know if there is no benefit to canning women BUT I am sure I don’t care for it over corruption and rapist and criminals that I want dealt with by my goverment.

  7. #7 by ktteokt on Friday, 26 February 2010 - 11:12 am

    I always thought it was “Spare the rod and spoil the Malays!”

  8. #8 by Dap man on Friday, 26 February 2010 - 11:21 am

    When Pakatan takes over Putrajaya I suggest the entire Najib Cabinet (that includes the women ministers) and himself be caned in public.

    Make sure Hishammuddin feels the pain. And also Jakim, Jais and Mais officials.

    They have done worse things than these three poor helpless women who probably have no connections with the top echelons (and the palace) to escape this humiliation.

    Have you ever heard of UMNO warlords and the royals ever breaking the same laws that these girls broke? Why has God exempted/excused them from punishment?

  9. #9 by limkamput on Friday, 26 February 2010 - 12:08 pm

    If you can see, the strategy is to create as many controversial issues as possible so that all of us are confused and do not know which one to focus on. While appealing to the moderate Malaysians, they are also appeasing the conservatives and the rightists. I think the strategy is working and I can sense the increased confidence among them. It is that simple: appealing to the insecurity, racism and bigotry within the largest community in the country and with that they hope to retain power forever. The Malays within PR must take the lead in fighting what is wrong in this country. As I see, the non Malays in PR are too prominent and this is creating discomfort within the Malay majority even thought they know PR has more enlightened policies and enduring programmes.

  10. #10 by k1980 on Friday, 26 February 2010 - 12:44 pm

    The 3 women should had paraphrased Jesus: “Let him who had not sinned swing the first stroke of the cane.”

    Then kerismoodin would admit: “Not mini me. I had drunk beer.”

  11. #11 by boh-liao on Friday, 26 February 2010 - 1:48 pm

    M’sia is a progressive country n it dares 2 do things that other countries dare not do
    Malaysia Boleh spirits – uniquely n truly M’sia
    M’sia is a leader, a pathsetter, not follower
    It has decided 2 play a leading role in the Islamic world, 2 show other Islamic countries how 2 cane immoral women
    It will soon run international training courses, workshops, seminars, n conferences on ‘The Art n Science of Caning Muslim Women’
    It will promote d events on YouTube n make money from various fees paid by participants
    International participants will contribute $$$ 2 our domestics economies n tourism
    Good business too 2 rotan manufacturers – all participants will need 2 buy special canes
    All thanks 2 NR n his cousin, HH, tapek

  12. #12 by negarawan on Saturday, 27 February 2010 - 12:07 pm

    This kind of thing happens when you have fools leading the government. Sharizat was even voted out in her constituency and she is made a minister by UMNO. Malaysia under UMNO is getting increasingly primitive. International respect and investments are plunging. UMNO is making Malaysia into a pariah state.

You must be logged in to post a comment.