Malaysia Looks West for Investments


By MATTHEW SALTMARSH
The New York Times
August 16, 2011

LONDON — With Europe’s economy mired in a debt crisis, governments in the region have been looking east for a helping hand, tapping the likes of China and Japan to buy their bonds and step up investments.

But at least one Asian country — Malaysia — still sees value in turning the opposite way, to enhance opportunities for its more assertive multinationals as well as bolstering investments from the West.

The Malaysian prime minister, Najib Razak, led a large official delegation last month to Britain via Turkmenistan, to capitalize on his country’s strong economy and investment inflows and assuage concerns about political agitation in the multicultural Southeast Asian country.

In past years, “it was just ‘please come to Malaysia,’ ” the trade minister, Mustapa Mohamed, said during an interview on the trip. “Now we are going to foreign countries to help provide access to Malaysian companies.”

Part of the sales pitch is selling the economic recovery story. The economy grew by 7.2 percent last year after shrinking 1.7 percent in 2009, and the government anticipates expansion of about 5 percent this year and next. The Malaysian inflation rate has been creeping up, though it remains moderate by global standards, at an annual rate of 3.5 percent in June.

But officials were also eager to ease potential concerns about the Malaysian political challenges.

“I think many investors have been to Malaysia, they understand the complications in Malaysia — multiracial, multireligious,” Mr. Mohamed said. “We need to have laws in place to ensure that things don’t get out of hand.”

The Coalition for Clean and Fair Elections, or Bersih, an amalgam of nongovernmental and activist groups, has pushed for changes in electoral law from the coalition government led by the United Malays National Organization, which has dominated politics since independence from Britain in 1957.

Bersih was declared illegal July 1, after which hundreds of activists were rounded up. Most of them were quickly released, but some were held longer. On July 9, thousands of protesters defied a government ban and held a large street protest, during which the police fired tear gas and water cannons and arrested about 1,700.

“We have to engage,” Mr. Mohamed said, “we have to continue changing, reform.”

Underneath the political tension is an economy that has proved increasingly attractive to overseas capital.

Nonequity foreign direct investment inflows in 2010 were $9.1 billion, according to the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, up from $1.4 billion a year earlier. The government is confident that it can retain that momentum.

“It’s not having an impact on investor confidence,” Mr. Mohamed said of the recent disturbances.

Ian Bryson, an analyst in Singapore at Control Risks, a consulting firm, said that there was less political risk in Malaysia than most of its regional peers and that the country benefited from relatively low corruption and a fairly dependable judiciary.

“I don’t think the current political agitation is pivotal or that the country is at a tipping point,” he said. “Malaysians are not interested in a full-scale upheaval.”

“The opposition is factious but vociferous,” he said, adding that splinter, conservative groups from the United Malays group still had the potential to destabilize the governing coalition in the next election, which is expected to be called in 2013.

On the economic front, Mr. Bryson cited concerns about limits on equity ownership in certain sectors — favoring ethnic Malays known as Bumiputera — and the employment of foreigners. He also noted broader skills shortages and restrictive local hiring and firing rules. “It’s generally very open to business, but with some cultural and sociopolitical limitations,” he said.

A report from the World Bank’s private sector arm, the International Finance Corporation, ranked Malaysia 21st out of 183 economies globally for the ease of doing business. The country scored lower for starting businesses and enforcing contracts.

Among Malaysian companies seeking global opportunities is the energy group Petronas, which announced last month that it had drawn its first natural gas from a field in Turkmenistan, where it has invested $5 billion. Others include the automaker Proton, which controls Lotus, a maker of sports cars; and the utilities conglomerate YTL, which owns Wessex Water in Britain.

At home, the government has used its $25 billion sovereign wealth fund, Khazanah Nasional, to take strategic stakes in businesses, including the energy group Tenaga Nasional, Malaysia Airlines System and Bank Lippo. More recently, the fund has been making tentative forays into Singapore and Indonesia. It opened its first overseas office in Beijing in 2008.

Speaking in London, Mr. Najib, the prime minister, sought to address potential concerns like those highlighted by Mr. Bryson. The government, he said, is “committed toward divesting government holdings,” citing the sale of post office assets, two Petronas subsidies and a sugar business. “There will be quite a few more holdings that we will divest,” he added.

He said there had been a “policy of gradual liberalization” of Bumiputera quotas, and “in the forthcoming budget we are expected to make further announcements.”

European companies that have invested in the country include BP and Royal Dutch Shell in energy, HSBC and Standard Chartered in banking, the vacuum cleaner maker Dyson and the retailer Tesco.

Tesco has invested more than $1.5 billion in Malaysia and employs about 14,000 people in the country. In a report in April, marking 10 years in the country, the chief executive of Tesco Malaysia, Tjeerd Jegen, said that he was “as bullish as ever on the prospects of the Malaysian retail sector.”

He cited “continued economic growth and prosperity, buoyed by sound economic reforms, robust consumer confidence and political stability.”

Perhaps mindful of recent unrest in the Middle East and rising inflation in Asian economies like India and China, Malaysia has been quick to express its desire to stay on a steady course.

Mr. Najib said there was a “huge commitment by the government to keep prices as low as possible,” and there would be only a “gradual” easing of subsidies on food and fuel.

Appointed in 2009, Mr. Najib has initiated several economic plans to draw investment and address the lack of skilled workers in Malaysia, focusing on bolstering productivity and research, easing red tape for investors and improving inclusiveness.

The government is also seeking to fill its labor shortage by biometrically registering all workers and offering permits of a maximum 10 years for illegal workers.

“We’ll legalize them as workers, not as citizens; that would be a disaster,” Mr. Najib said. “If all those things are executed, God willing, we will be a fully developed nation. It will give us 6 percent growth that we need for the next 10 years.”

According to the government, one million Malaysians live abroad, a sizable proportion of the country’s population of 28.7 million. Some estimates peg the number of Malaysian nationals based overseas much higher. Singapore has been the biggest beneficiary of the outflow, attracting more than half of those who have emigrated.

Mr. Najib also said rising wages in China could present an opportunity for Malaysia.

“More and more people are beginning to realize they need a ‘China plus one’ policy,” he said, “They don’t want to put all their eggs in one basket.”

As a result, he said, “we’re seeing companies seriously looking at Malaysia.”

  1. #1 by Loh on Thursday, 18 August 2011 - 1:15 am

    ///“I think many investors have been to Malaysia, they understand the complications in Malaysia — multiracial, multireligious,” Mr. Mohamed said. “We need to have laws in place to ensure that things don’t get out of hand.”///

    The strength in diversity has been converted into complications because of race policy; the NEP sums it all. In a country that respects rule of law, there is no need for law to take care of race issues, if all citizens are treated equal. It might be understandable if some concession treatment is given for people placed in a special position of weakness, for a fixed duration of 10 to 15 years. But to have converted that time bound special handouts to permanent feature, the government does not deserve to govern. The country has to invent reasons why double standards are practiced by the government.

    ///Ian Bryson, an analyst in Singapore at Control Risks, a consulting firm, said that there was less political risk in Malaysia than most of its regional peers and that the country benefited from relatively low corruption and a fairly dependable judiciary.///

    It would be more complete to insert after the words low corruption, ‘that are not institutionalized. Also after the word judiciary, if the government and the cronies of UMNOputras are not involved in the disputes.

    ///On the economic front, Mr. Bryson cited concerns about limits on equity ownership in certain sectors — favoring ethnic Malays known as Bumiputera — and the employment of foreigners. He also noted broader skills shortages and restrictive local hiring and firing rules. “It’s generally very open to business, but with some cultural and sociopolitical limitations,” he said.///

    NEP is still a curse to the country.

    Mr. Najib also said rising wages in China could present an opportunity for Malaysia.

    ///“More and more people are beginning to realize they need a ‘China plus one’ policy,” he said, “They don’t want to put all their eggs in one basket.”///

    That plus one, if it is only one, would not be Malaysia. Thus Malaysia will have to compete with other nations, even in ASEAN. Why then mention the plus one as though Malaysia could be an insurance? Malaysia is neither big nor attractive to foreign investment to serve as an insurance for investing in China.

  2. #2 by monsterball on Thursday, 18 August 2011 - 2:05 am

    No need to look East..or West…for this and that.
    Just look around..be alert…be smart..be well read and be prepared.
    But that’s expecting too much from dealer wheelers looking for big commission …in every deal.

  3. #3 by monsterball on Thursday, 18 August 2011 - 2:38 am

    Only a crooked government dare to stoop so low and say…”Willing Buyer. Willing Seller” as an excuse to cheat billions from Malaysians.

  4. #4 by Joshua on Thursday, 18 August 2011 - 5:42 am

    Ian Bryson, an analyst in Singapore at Control Risks, a consulting firm, said that there was less political risk in Malaysia than most of its regional peers and that the country benefited from relatively low corruption and a fairly dependable judiciary. ”

    Fairly dependable judiciary is truly an understatement.

    If the concerned parties on free and fair elections pursued with me in my two High Court cases on GE2004 and GE2008, there is no need for Bersih 2.0 to take to the streets.

    The High Court just strike off the cases (not interested to deal with the details of the cases) and the Judge was so quickly ‘rewarded’ with promotion and a Datukship after serving in the Court for a few years.

    I think many earlier judges did not get their datukship until near retirement and after retirement.

    So you want to say that as ‘fairly dependable’..

  5. #5 by Joshua on Thursday, 18 August 2011 - 6:12 am

    The High Court ignored my complaint that the defendents did not turn up in the Courts for GE2008.

    So like a football match, it would be walk over for me.

    So if the defendents did not turn up, the case should proceed to look at my suit and find the defendants guilty and instead, the case was simply struck off by the limitation of time of 6 months to dispose of the election case at the stages of several affidavit in support and protest by both parties. The delay was actually due to the non attendance of the first meeting at the Courts by two months.

    The defendents were only interested right from the start to strike off the cases – GE2004 and GE2008.

    I sure to win the GE2008 with my presentation of real fact and truths too shinning bright for the eyes of the defendents and the Judge just gave in to that knowing the gravy train to come.

  6. #6 by undertaker888 on Thursday, 18 August 2011 - 7:27 am

    Who will come and give 30% freely to these freeloaders umno NEP ret@rds? The east has been fooled. They think they can fool the Kwai-lo. Fool the rural Malays bolehlah.

  7. #7 by yhsiew on Thursday, 18 August 2011 - 7:28 am

    Only a desperate government will look everywhere for investments including health-threatening investment from Lynas Corp of Australia.

  8. #8 by boh-liao on Thursday, 18 August 2011 - 10:00 am

    Zimbabwe is west of M’sia

  9. #9 by monsterball on Thursday, 18 August 2011 - 9:09 pm

    Timbuktu is at your backside.

  10. #10 by waterfrontcoolie on Thursday, 18 August 2011 - 10:46 pm

    You know the other day, I met a young lady who has, or rather had been in ligitation rpofession in Malaysia for some 7 years. She decided to change profession, and when asked why? as legal practice should be more lucrative than acting as spokeman for for large institution? Her reply: in Malaysia, it isn’t what the case is about: you say! It is who you can connect with!! having heard that, I truely admire thsoe legal minds who fought for truth; but sadly they are in the minority! Indeed Zimbabwe is just to our West!

  11. #11 by monsterball on Friday, 19 August 2011 - 12:29 am

    And the “Journey to the West” from India to China…by one…never forgotten.
    “North to Alaska” by some gringos and found gold.
    “East of Eden” lives a cracko
    “South of the border..down Mexico way”….if you wish to enjoy yourself.
    Chinese have always treated “The Good Earth” with respect and most travel to “The Inn of the 6th Happiness” at Tiansin to listen to stories while dining.
    East is East…West is West…and Zimbabwe is West from Malaysia?…I did not kown that.
    But ask any UMNO B filthy rich crooks..”where are they going?”.
    They will say proudly…to the West…USA for shopping and fun.
    WEST is a direction ….always meant to be USA…because Americans make sure you remember that with
    “Wild Wild West” planted into your brains.
    And so….our smart PM paid RM71 million for one year service to some smart American Jews to plant something into Malaysians brain and vote for UMNO B forever.
    IT DID NOT WORK!!!

  12. #12 by undertaker888 on Friday, 19 August 2011 - 7:55 am

    Afghanistan is also west of Malaysia. They will invest AK47 manufacturing and export their T@libans here.

You must be logged in to post a comment.