What a letdown!
Members of Parliament and Malaysians were promised when the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) 2008 Bill was debated in Parliament last December that the Prime Minister, Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi was finally going to honour his most important pledge when he became Prime Minister five years ago – to eradicate corruption and create a new political culture of public integrity with zero tolerance for corruption.
Parliament and the nation were told that MACC was going to become another ICAC (Hong Kong’s Independent Commission Against Corruption) respected world-wide for its uncompromising and no-nonsense commitment against corruption without fear or favour for position, status or influence.
In less than two months, the MACC has become a joke. Instead of building public confidence in its journey to become another ICAC, feared and respected by all, it has quickly become a joke, reduced into a “Malaysian Agency for Car and Cows” for the Barisan Nasional government to victimize Pakatan Rakyat leaders.
The unprecedented statement by the MACC Chief Commissioner Datuk Seri Ahmad Said Hamdan that the MACC has “good and strong evidence” of corruption against the Selangor Pakatan Rakyat Mentri Besar Tan Sri Abdul Khalid over the car and cows controversy has destroyed whatever credibility the MACC might have among Malaysians that it would be independent, professional and uninfluenced by the dictates of its political masters.
Although Ahmad Said said the matter would be referred to the Attorney-General’s Chambers for further action, the MACC Chief Commissioner has already taken the unprecedented step of proclaiming that Khalid had been guilty of corruption – which had never be done before in the history of ACA of over four decades!
Equally shocking was Ahmad Said’s statement that the MACC would also investigate allegations of abuse of power by Perak state assembly Speaker V. Sivakumar for suspending the illegitimate Perak Mentri Besar Dr. Zambry Abdul Kadir and his state executive councillors from the assembly, pledging: “If its’ true that there had been abuse of power, the MACC will take appropriate action”.
When did the Anti-Corruption Agency (ACA) ever declare in the past 40 years that it would take action against the Speaker of Parliament for any “abuse of power” although there had not been any lack of controversies over decisions and rulings of the Speaker during the period?
Yesterday, I had called on the Prime Minister, Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi to provide the leadership in the Barisan Nasional to co-operate with Pakatan Rakyat to keep the Rulers above the political fray in the Perak political and constitutional crisis as the issue in contention is not about the institution of constitutional monarchy but the people’s will on the elected government of their choice in a system of parliamentary democracy.
It is a matter of grave concern that the MACC has jumped into the Perak politic al crisis when it has no business whatsoever to get involved, as it raises the question whether the entire apparatus of state in the hands of the Federal government, including the MACC, the police, the Attorney-General’s Chambers would be abused and arrayed against the Pakatan Rakyat in the Perak political and constitutional crisis?
If so, this will be a pathetic end for the fifth premiership of Abdullah Ahmad Badawi and a most ominous start for the sixth premiership of Datuk Seri Najib Razak.
There have been calls for undemocratic, illegal and unconstitutional arrogation of powers to deal with the Perak political and constitutional crisis, such as the declaration of an emergency, the misuse and abuse of draconian powers under the Internal Security Act and Sedition Act, to prop up the illegal and unconstitutional Umno power grab in Perak.
This must be resisted for Malaysia’s democracy, international standing and competitiveness will be the greatest casualties.
The dissolution of the Perak State Assembly and a snap state general election within 30 days to resolve the political crisis state is the best solution in the circumstances.
Ahmad Said should resign as MACC Chief Commissioner as he has reduced MACC into “Malaysian Agency for Car and Cows” for the BN to victimize PR instead of another ICAC respected worldwide for its fight against corruption.
How can the MACC win the confidence of the people in its credibility, independence and professionalism when it is blind, deaf and mute to the mega scandals in the country, whether the RM4.6 billion Port Klang Free Zone (PKFZ) scandal or those involving top leaders whether in Barisan Nasional or in the public service like the Inspector-General of Police and the Attorney-General but only interested in Khalid’s “car and cows” controversy or Sivakumar’s decision as a Speaker which has nothing to do whatsoever with MACC?

#1 by Loh on Sunday, 22 February 2009 - 4:09 pm
MACC accused khalid, MB of Selangor of corruption with regard to repairs on the car owned by Khalid but which he had informed the government that the car had been assigned for his official use. Khalid is entitled to be provided a new car by Selangor state government for his official use. Though a new car, if not of Proton make, will have low repair and maintenance bill, there would be bills for depreciation that might be as high as 20% for the first year, and reducing subsequently. Assuming that the MB used a new 2,400cc Toyota Camry at RM 171,000, the depreciation would be RM 34,000 for a year. It was reported that some RM 8,000 had been spent on the repair of Khalid’s car which had been utilized as his official car. Comparing the amount spent between repairs and depreciation, Khalid had in fact saved the state government money using his own car.
MACC would argue that the issue is that in repairing Khalid’s car using government funds, Khalid had gained advantage in upgrading the car through repairs, and thus the value of the car has increased. It would be beyond rocket science to determine the value of the car that were put in service before any repair was needed, and the value added to the car on repairs, and when would that repair be worn off to compensate for wear and tear of other parts of the car. Under normal circumstances, repairs would only enable the car to continue to serve its function, and the value of the car depreciates with time. Khalid has not sold his car, and it would be difficult to know whether he had benefited from the repairs on the sale which had not yet taken place. How could MACC charge Khalid for corruption in using government funds to keep the car in working order, when he could have used government funds to buy a new car for his official use would be a subject for legal studies in universities? Such action has never been taken anywhere in the world is certain.
The Commissioner of MACC and his staff have spent their working hours investigating what they claimed to be a misuse of public funds which were yet to happen, and which amounted to less than the costs of paying the salaries and wages as well as other expenses of MACC officials for the time spent on investigation would also be the first of its kind in the world. There are corrupt cases particularly by the 18 sharks of amounts which could pay the entire MACC operations for years are left untouched. This is persecution by MACC as directed by the government headed by the incoming president of UMNO. The country has gone into the misuse of law for political purpose. UMNO has changed, as the UMNO leaders said that they had to change to survive. The change is not to make themselves responsible politicians, but to manipulate whatever power they have to kill off opposition parties in whatever means that lead to the desired ends. UMNO has become shameless.
MACC claimed that Khalid purchased cows for the benefit of people in his constituency. The Prime Minister and other ministers have organized open houses for hundred of thousands of people. Did they use UMNO funds or government funds? If it was the latter, the difference would be between raw meat and cooked meals. Or did the MACC considered the difference to be live cows and cooked meals?
If Ahmad Said has too much time on his hands, he should check on how the RM 3 million for each UMNO Divison Chief given by AAB from public funds was not corruption. He will have a lot of work to do to interview all the 191 UMNO leaders how they spend the money if he had been as energetic interviewing PR politicians.
#2 by jules on Sunday, 22 February 2009 - 7:35 pm
picked this one up from The Might of the Pen
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
ANDREW DOWDELL, COURT REPORTER
February 08, 2008 04:01pm
A MALAYSIAN Airlines co-pilot has been convicted and fined for bringing child pornography into the country on his personal computer.
Ahmad Said appeared handcuffed in Adelaide Magistrates Court today on a charge of importing a prohibited item.
Customs officers arrested the 25-year old at Adelaide International Airport yesterday, after finding three video files containing child pornography.
The videos were titled “Reped (sic) Virgin”, “10-Year Old” and “High School Students.”
“This material is repugnant and abhorrent – any decent minded person would be so affected by it,” Magistrate Simon Smart said.
Mr Smart said the rape scene featured a crying girl aged under 18 being forced to have sex with an older male.
“These are not victimless crimes – for every video that depicts such a scene there is a victim,” he said.
Said’s computer was searched after he flew into Adelaide as co-pilot on a Malaysian Airlines flight from Kuala Lumpur.
His lawyer Stephen Barratt said Said had been e-mailed the video files and had not shown anyone else.
“He was simply reckless, this was not material brought in to be disseminated,” Mr Barratt said.
Mr Smart rejected the defence assertion that Said had “no interest” in the pornography, saying there would be no market for such images without people like him.
Mr Barratt said the conviction could ruin Said’s career as a pilot at Malaysian Airlines after rising rapidly through the ranks in the past few years.
“The result of this conviction … could alter the whole of his life and his family,” Mr Barratt said.
Mr Barratt said Said’s arrest and detention in custody for almost 24 hours was “fairly harsh.”
“He has suffered from being kept overnight in custody and now sits before the court manacled, which he describes to me as one of the lowest points of his life,” Mr Barratt said.
Magistrate Smart fined Said $5,000 and ordered that his laptop be forfeited to the Crown.
===========================================================================
From Bernama
February 13, 2008 20:38 PM
Singapore Pilot Fined A$12,000 Over Child Porn Import Bid
MELBOURNE, Feb 13 (Bernama) — A Singapore Airlines pilot has been fined A$12,000 for trying to bring child pornography into Australia, court documents showed.
A newspaper website reported that Ng Kok Yauw, 40, captained a Singapore Airlines flight last Saturday from the city-state to Adelaide and when Customs officials searched his laptop they found video clips of child pornography.
Ng, who appeared in court on Monday, pleaded guilty to charges of importing banned material and making a false statement to a Customs officer.
Singapore Airlines said the airline was conducting its own investigation. Seven video files were found on Ng’s computer, some of which contained footage of rape, sexual violence and children engaged in sexual activity, the court documents said.
The maximum sentence in Australia for offences involving child pornography is a fine of A$275,000 and 10 years imprisonment.
While it is not an offence to bring pornographic material into Australia, an Australian Customs spokeswoman told “The Australian Online it was an crime to bring in “objectionable” or “abhorrent” pornography into the country.
This would include materials that “offend against the standards of morality, decency and propriety generally accepted by reasonable adults”, the spokeswoman was quoted as saying.
The pilot was one of three men, including a Malaysian Airline pilot, caught last week by Custom officials for importing “offensive” pornography.
– BERNAMA
Notice that Bernama omitted Shauqi Ahmad Said’s name in their report ?
#3 by waterfrontcoolie on Sunday, 22 February 2009 - 10:38 pm
We have all read flyers on Toyol and his corruptions , can’t PR Gomen file legal action against him, even if MACC refused to do so?
#4 by anna brella on Sunday, 22 February 2009 - 11:14 pm
“MS Corridor is a corridor of real estate and nothing else. Hey it was suppose to spearhead malaysia into the world of ict.”
MS Corridor and ict?
Mahathir’s Special Corridor into alleged ignorant, corrupt/catatonic totalitarianism?
“Imagine Power To The People” John Lennon.
#5 by ekans on Monday, 23 February 2009 - 12:35 am
The BN-led Terengganu state govt was ‘easily’ able to justify its purchase of new Mercedes-Benz cars for its state exco members, and on top of that, the BN-led federal govt was kind enough to exempt these Mercedes-Benz cars from duties & taxes so that the BN-led Terengganu state govt would appear to have saved some money.
But when the PR led state govts of Perak & Selangor purchased cheaper Camrys for their respective state-excos, the same BN-led federal govt refused to allow the same exemptions from duties & taxes like it had given to the BN-led Terengganu state govt.
If MACC was truly neutral & impartial, it would have inquired into why the federal govt had made it easier for the Terengganu state govt to acquire more expensive luxury cars while making it more difficult for the Perak & Selangor state govts to acquire cheaper cars.
But, of course, this never happened because MACC reports to federal govt leader no.1.
#6 by ALLAN THAM on Monday, 23 February 2009 - 7:49 am
So all have pour out their anger on MACC in YB Kit Blog. Today Nades has revisit on all these while on what she has done. Each of us who is concern on what has happen to the anti (Pro?) Corruption agency please get a copy of the Sun today and read what Nades has to say.
Much have been said by Nades he even challenge and very specific in his writing on what charge should be and on who. But yet it seem all those in the agency are either blind or dumb.
Well it is another day, it is another year and it will be any decade and I beat you nothing will change, despite all the shouting of slogan by BN that they need change ? What change, change for more corruption more abuse of power?
#7 by undergrad2 on Monday, 23 February 2009 - 8:29 am
MACC is not about ending corruption. It is about reigning in opposition politicians who misuse government property. You guys gotta be dumb to fall for it and now everyone is whining about how MACC becomes a tool of BN. Of course it is meant to be a tool of BN. Thank you for pointing out the obvious. Now suck it in and move on.
#8 by Yee Siew Wah on Monday, 23 February 2009 - 7:05 pm
Another one from a website:-
“As a public official, Ahmad Said must be free of any aspersions that suggest an inability to carry out his duties freely, fairly and independently.
Should Ahmad Said have a son, already found guilty overseas, who seems to have “escaped” criminal proceedings here in Malaysia, I think we cannot say that Ahmad Said is in a position to enjoy full public confidence.
After all, it then becomes reasonable for us to question: Has Ahmad Said been coerced into pursuing only selective MACC prosecutions against certain parties in return for having his son granted immunity from criminal prosecutions?
I wish to emphatically state once again that I have little interest in sullying Ahmad Shauqi’s name, in his crime, and especially in connecting whatever his misdeeds may be to his father. I am not interested in Ahmad Said’s parenting abilities, or the moral integrity of the rest of his family.
I am however, forced to take an interest in the ability of Ahmad Said to fulfil his duties as a public official impartialy. Should he fail in this task, then it falls to us as the public to investigate all the possible reasons why. Unanswered questions will only cast further asperations into the integrity of the already sullied MACC.”
Now I know why this retarded bum Ahmad Said from MACC was so “efficient and fast” in condemning our fellow PKR MB Khalid. His balls must be squeezed by Mr.C4 and our infamous sleepy flipflop, lame duck guy.
Rakyat should boycott MAS as long as this MACC head son Shaugi is not kick out from his job as a pilot.
It is amazing there was no follow up or prosecution on this Ahmad Shauqi. These bums thought that in time rakyat will forget his disgustful act. Not anymore. The rakyat especially PKR members must pursue this issue until this bum is charged. MACC, I puke when I heard of this. Worst than the former ACA. Another great reform by our sleepy, flipflop, lame duck outgoing bum.
#9 by milduser on Monday, 23 February 2009 - 7:39 pm
Dont expect a crook to install any anti crooks devices to detect their evil deeds.
Get rid of the crooks first, install the honest people n then form the real MACC n the \cows n cars\ type.
Get my point????????
Stupid voters
#10 by coretankhalayak on Monday, 23 February 2009 - 7:49 pm
for those who need this 3 video can get it from Ahmad Said – son ;)
1. Reped (sic) Virgin
2.10-Year Old
3.High School Students
“prakata” – the rape scene featured a crying girl aged under 18 being forced to have sex with an older male.
p/s – for those MAS pilot dun worry to bring all this video into Australia, MAS will not fire u if u get caught -:)
http://www.news.com.au/adelaidenow/story/0,22606,23179728-5006301,00.html
#11 by kbong on Tuesday, 24 February 2009 - 7:20 am
Very unfortunate for Ahmad Shauqi B. Ahmad Said. After a year the world has forgotten about his conviction for possession and smuggling of child pornography material. His father decides to abuse his authority as MACC chief and his previous conviction gets dug up and published for the world to comment on.
Ahmad Said Hamdan allows BN to make use of him to unfairly go after Pakatan Rakyat. Perhaps people should now make use of Ahmad Shauqi B. Ahmad Said’s child pornography conviction to go after Ahmad Said Hamdan.
#12 by merdekablog on Tuesday, 24 February 2009 - 11:53 am
Chairman of MACC (Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission), Ahmad Said has a son named Ahmad Shauqi, a Malaysia Airlines pilot, who was arrested in Adelaide Airport for importing child pornography material into Australia.
Could this charge have anything to do with Ahmad Said’s recent issuing of a public prejudgment that “there was strong and good evidence” against Selangor Menteri Besar Abdul Khalid Ibrahim in alleged wrongdoing in the maintenance of a luxury car and purchase of sacrificial cows? Is this why we did not hear much of the main stream media coverage on the arrest of Ahmad Shauqi?
Could the arrest have negatively impacted the independence of MACC for carrying out its duties? Could this charge be why the countless accusations brought up by the opposition leaders against BN are swept under the carpet with no investigation or follow-up actions? Is this the time for Ahmad Said to step down from his position for losing the public confidence on MACC?
In order to assure the impartiality and integrity of MACC, Ahmad Said should be interrogated for his ability to carry out his tasks freely and fairly.
#13 by -ec- on Tuesday, 24 February 2009 - 3:36 pm
let’s do some maths (…for the moment, in english.)
46 cows = RM110,400
1 cow = RM2,400 (average)
(a) RM4.6bil (or RM4,600,000,000) = 1,916,666 cows
(b) RM1.6bil (or RM1,600,000,000) = 666,666 cows
(a)+(b) = 2,583,332 cows vs 46 cows
there are just plenty of cows to count if macc cannot sleep at night. :P
#14 by lew1328 on Wednesday, 25 February 2009 - 8:37 am
Greetings!
Instead, MACC wasting so much of thier time catching “Cows” & create stories, I think they shall arm their strength and focus in big case such as the industry fault in application of permit where centre Government requested bribes from the investors not once bu from different level/department. (That’s case I heard from one my friend who worked in the MNC factory for their new set up besides Klang)
What’s a SHAME…
#15 by Ramesh Laxman on Wednesday, 25 February 2009 - 8:12 pm
YB Lim,
I like your wit. \Better a witty fool than foolish wit’ Twlefth Night