A second Internal Security Act (ISA) arrest in less than eight hours after RPK – the Sin Chew Daily senior journalist Tan Hoon Cheng, 33, who reported that Umno Bukit Bendera division chief Datuk Ahmad Ismail’s speech at a Permatang Pauh by-election ceramah on August 23 that the Chinese in Malaysia are “squatters” in the country and which resulted in a nation-wide furore and political crisis.
Ahmad got off lightly with a three-year Umno suspension but why is the Sin Chew Daily reporter detained under the ISA, when her report had been confirmed as true when Deputy Prime Minister and Deputy Umno President Datuk Seri Najib had apologised “on behalf” of Ahmad?
Although Ahmad did not “recognise” Najib’s apology on his behalf, the Deputy Prime Minister’s apology is confirmation that Tan’s report was correct, especially as Najib was present when Ahmad had given the controversial speech at the Umno ceramah during the Permatang Pauh by-election.
Will the two reporters, one from Guang Ming and the other from Nanyang, who had collaborated Tan’s report of Ahmad Ismail’s speech be next on the ISA crackdown? What about all those columnists who had flayed Ahmad for his provocative, inflammatory and racist speech – are they all marked for the Kamunting Detention Centre?
Is Malaysia in the grip of another ISA madness, akin to Operation Lalang 21 years ago when there were mass arrests under the ISA (with Guan Eng and I among the first of the 106 persons to be arrested but were the last two to be released) and closure of three newspapers?
Ministers and leaders of MCA, Gerakan, MIC, SUPP and other Barisan Nasional component parties must demand in the Cabinet and requisition an emergency meeting of the Barisan Nasional Supreme Council for the immediate release of Tan and Raja Petra under the ISA as well as the withdrawal of the show cause notice issued by the Home Ministry to three newspapers as to why action should not be taken against them.
Their political parties had pledged after the debacle in the March general election that they would cease to be puppets and “yes-men” and would speak up for the rights of all Malaysians.
Tan Hoon Cheng and RPK are critical tests whether they meant what they say – in Cabinet and the Barisan Nasional Supreme Council – or they remain stuck in their incorrigible roles of being totally subservient to Umno “Big Brother”!

#1 by oLcA on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 12:40 am
A sad day indeed :/
#2 by Elwin Heng on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 12:41 am
Patient exploded!
‘Wolf-tale’ or ‘true-color’ shown!
God bless innocent!
Beauty and the Beast!
Hopeless if only waiting for MCA, Gerakan, MIC and others’ involvement of ISA detention (racist), as long as still joint-ventured BN? Why? You know the answer, don’t you!
The day I qualified voting right, my vote only towards DAP! Till now, confident myself make a smartest choice, and 100% of family members will only vote on Pakatan Rakyat (PR)! Will not or no longer or no chance our votes on BN : Umno, MCA, Gerakan and MIC!
Eye-on black hand’s unwelcome politic strategies or tactics, 916 percent of success : yes or no, is not important! Hereby need to clarify and emphasize, I/we wouldn’t disappoint, blame, complaint, or betray PR if 916 doesn’t exceed! Our heart or spirit will stay on and alongside PR till mission accomplish!
Cheers, PR!
PR everlasting!
PR rakyat choice!
TQ.
Warmest regards.
#3 by ReformMalaysia on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 12:42 am
As an objection to injustice done, we should get our voice heard by boycotting all products and services offered by any company that are related to UMNO(cronies and members).
#4 by One4All4One on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 12:46 am
DPM Najib’s apology is now in question.
If the apology is to be taken as attesting to the truth of the remark by Ahmad Ismail, then why detain the journalist who was merely doing her job as a journalist, and reporting what she heard?
What is happening here?
#5 by ReformMalaysia on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 12:52 am
The act to detain a journalist for reporting the facts deserve international condemnation….. and God’s damnation
#6 by AsalUsuLMalaysiaHacked on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 12:53 am
Ok This is it, theyve made the moved. Najis and his fellow comrade had already started to push the annoying Choked Speechless PM AAB… Mass ISA detention!
#7 by AhPek on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 12:55 am
Anwar,
We are counting on you to make it happen.Don’t disappoint the nation’s well being is at stake! Meanwhile the rest should stay come and watch the scene unfold.
#8 by AhPek on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 12:55 am
oops should be ‘stay calm’
#9 by 9to5 on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 1:33 am
There are 2 models where UMNO has successfully used in the past.
In the 1969 model, Tun Abdul Razak used the riots to instate an Emergency and eventually force Tunku Abdul Rahman out of power.
In the 1987 model, where a massive internal struggle within Umno moved Mahathir to attack imaginary exterior “enemies (non-malays)” in a massive Operation Lallang to strengthen his own fledgling position within Umno.
There is now an internal struggle within UMNO as well as fledging support from the malay voters. So their natural instinct is to apply a combination of the 2 models.
To kill two birds with one stone, they intend to create riots to instate an emergency rule to prevent Anwar from toppling the present UMNO Government. Coupled with this, they will also make imaginary “exterior enemies” out of thin air to justify a Operation Lallang II to strengthen their own fledging position with the malays. Their intention is to make one race hate another race.
Guys, don’t fall for their tricks! To be cheated once, shame on you. But to be cheated twice, shame on me!
#10 by cemerlang on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 1:46 am
Sounds like an acute case of rabies. Those who needed the act of law are allowed to go scot free. Misuse of power, corruptors, gangsterism, robberies, rape, stealing, loan sharks and all the other actual real crimes are dealt with so slowly. But citizens who never commit these and only speak their mind can get the action of law so fast. This is not fair. Malaysians are not that stupid. And it happens in the month of Ramadan. Instead of getting closer to God, it is getting away from God.
#11 by AhPek on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 1:58 am
‘It was their duties to report, and if the law prevents people to perform professionally, can we call this a civilised country?’. Loh.
Call it Mugabe country.
#12 by belalang pening on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 2:25 am
WTF!!! What is going on with this country?? They are Polis Diraja Malaysia or Polis Diraja BN?????
#13 by bagero on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 2:26 am
It is clear ZAK believes in a LAW that is un-Islamic. The likes of him and BN hooligans, will all surely change their tune when PR takes over the federal government.
#14 by m.hwang on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 2:53 am
zak wants us to believe that the detainees will be charged after 60 days of investigation. Obviously zak is quite new to the ways of ISA. When someone is arrested under ISA he is already guilty in the eyes of the government.
When under detention, the objective is to “educate” you to fit into the mainstream society, whatever that means. They are not interested to charge you because your detention can be indefinite so why bother? When someone close to you get arrested under ISA you will know the true meaning of ISA.
#15 by FromTheOutside on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 3:27 am
Pardon me, zak, but I think in the interest of fairness, the public SHOULD be made known of redundant albeit undemocratic measures taken by the government.
This process of deliberately stifling critical opposition is an antiquated roll-over from Colonial times, a process which today’s British government has abolished. It was also used frequently here in Singapore for example, during the communist insurgencies.
But on the subject of openness to the public, please refrain from comparing Singapore’s governmental policies with those of Malaysia’s. Singapore’s government has managed to, almost completely, quash all the views of its people under numerous, covert scare tactics, most of which, are not even reported to public. A ‘plus-side’ of ridiculously curbing and curtailing freedom of speech and opinion? You don’t get back-talk.
In Malaysia, however, you have case in point: a Mr. Hilmy Noor, who was detained in 1987 under the ISA with reasons such as, ‘..disrupting the Malay culture by being Christian.’ Justifiable? I think not.
So please, for RPK; who is unfairly being detained for a reckless comment posted by a reader, for the reporter of Sin Chew Daily; who was duly doing her job, and for YB Teresa Kok; who, till know, is being held for reasons unknown, I say: keep faith strong and know that justice is not blind.
#16 by akarmalaysian on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 4:39 am
is thr any site that i can really swear and curse my “mother tongue” language at those bus tards who can simply issue orders to arrest people who only spoke of the truth?
ohh…that idiot ahmad ismail can stoke up racial sentiments with his idiotic remarks and get away with it so lightly while the reporter who only reported wats being said by dat idiot kena arrest.wat kind of justice is dat.fr wat we people see…these are really cowardly acts….a point whr the present government got no jalan lagi.this is the filthiest and dirtiest government of today.aks them a question they will give u stupid answers.ask summore lagi till they cannot answer u they let u kena isa.
#17 by Tasslehoff on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 5:18 am
Not sure if you’re aware of this, but the Human Rights Watch has long been critical of the Malaysian ISA.
Here are two links you might like to have a read about:
http://www.hrw.org/english/docs/2005/09/28/malays11788.htm
http://hrw.org/reports/2004/malaysia0504/
#18 by kanthanboy on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 6:41 am
UMNO has blatantly abused the constitutional right of one Chinese female reporter of Sin Chew Newspaper in broad daylight. How on earth can MCA, Gerakan and SUPP claim they are the defender of the right of all Chinese in Malaysia when they can not even defend the right of one law abiding Chinese citizen.
#19 by yhsiew on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 7:12 am
The must be proper rule of law in this country – not this kind of rubbish ISA!
#20 by newchief on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 7:36 am
i’ve laid my case. my prediction was right.
SYABAS to BN for a ‘job well done’ for allowing the police to arrest THE WRONG PEOPLE WITH SWIFT ACTIONS!!
my next prediction is opposition MPs be arrested especially the 4 person who went to taiwan under ISA. if anyone especially oppositions oppose, ALL WILL BE ARRESTED !!
Then next is our DSAI . Take note that PAS is very smart. they lay low in order not to be detected.
#21 by Ash on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 7:36 am
I’ve had enough of this bullshit. I strongly urge everyone to stay calm as we witness how Anwar is gonna destroy all these BS and give us a new hope for our beloved country.
#22 by tenaciousB on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 7:45 am
What a joke, lately badawi has been a clown….LOL!
He said he is ‘surrrprised’ that muhiyiddin wants him to step down!!!hahaha.
Then he uses lets ahmad ismail a racist off with a suspension only, then he uses ISA on the poor journalist who wrote about ahmad ismails racism, then he caught RPK and a DAP MP as well! What a joke!
This clown of a leader is expediting the extinction of BN! T-minus few days to imploding!
#23 by tenaciousB on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 7:50 am
where is MCA when a reporter of chinese ethnicity is detained under ISA?????
i reckon all chinese should leave this MCA party indefinitely!
#24 by tesl_lecturer on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 8:05 am
oh my god !! 3 innocent people are detained without any proof…and that mothafocker ismail is enjoying his life out….keparat sial BN !!
#25 by AhPek on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 8:16 am
This is the state raw power employed to tell the populace to conform to their rule,in short the most effective way to cow them!
#26 by ktteokt on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 9:36 am
Committing a crime can be easily pardoned in Malaysia, but the person reporting it shall be penalized, ALWAYS! MALAYSIA benar-benar BOLEH (mati)!
#27 by Caleb on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 9:39 am
You blind guides! You strain out a gnat but swallow a camel.
#28 by mangodurian on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 9:53 am
A mutiny is being executed. This is not the work of AAB. The ship is sinking, the crew has run back to the old captain, and the old captain has agreed to help … probably with conditions … as the old captain, despite differences, also don’t want the ship to sink.
Just look at the top two vice-admirals making statements that “surprises” the current captain in the last few days.
The old captain cannot steer the ship yet, but can try to make calmer waters (thus the ISA). Then when the waters calm, the mutiny on board shall take place. Of course, it will not be the old captain then executing the mutiny, but the bargained one (who?).
#29 by plasma16 on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 10:01 am
The authorities are going crazy. This will certainly seal their downfall. The inhumane act should be abolished immediately.
#30 by mightymouse on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 10:21 am
where is this zak guy? why is he so quiet now that he knows BN/UMNO is in the wrong? Please could someone ask him to kindly show his debating skills on why Teresa and the journalist was arrested??
PLEASE post i would love to hear your side of the arguement again.. i read this whole thread just waiting for your absurd comments. but then again its a good read. especially when all you are doing now is showing what a BN/UMNO dog you are but please you humour me.
#31 by Cinapek on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 11:05 am
UMNO’s Supreme Council unanimously passed a motion that Ahmad Ismail was wrong and disciplined him.
If the parties responsible had made the same decisive decision right at the start instead of flip flopping and pussyfooting around, it would not have deteriorated to the extent that the ISA had now to be used.
The same can be said of all those issues that various parties had accused the Bar Council and other organizations of having a racial and religious slant in their efforts to find long term solutions. If the Govt. and the parties responsible had the political will and the guts to take the decisive actions to resolve them, the Bar Council and all the other parties would have no need to take the initiatives into their own hands. Instead they buried their heads in the sand and allow the problems to fester and get worse by the day. If they think they have resolved these open festering wounds with this ISA action, they are wrong. They are merely delaying the inevitable.
#32 by Godfather on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 12:04 pm
Zak is merely parroting his hero, the Mamakthir. What is good enough for Mamakthir is good enough for Zak the foreigner.
#33 by alhafar on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 2:49 pm
Forgive me but I am just another stupid ignorant pendatang squatter, but didn’t the honorable Ahmad Ismail hold a press conference? As far as I understand, the press only reported what was issued at the PC, and as far as my dim understanding of PC is concerned, isnt that precisely the desired effect, ie having your words printed in the press? And if this person calling the PC is a from the ruling party, doesnt it follow logic (if we still use that these days in Msia) that the press is obliged to report whatever was said at the PC? So what’s the crime? Very strange laws we have. But maybe I am just too stupid to understand our squatting country’s laws. Forgive me.
#34 by Plaintruth on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 3:40 pm
I read the postings and people are praying…. is this all we can do? We need to do somthing (within the law, of course).
Is signing petition to Agong the answer?
I posting on the blog the answer?
There must be a better answer to bring down this UMNOPUTRA government.
let’s hear your suggestions.
Enough is Enough ! The raykat are oppressed and suffered.
#35 by shamshul anuar on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 5:08 pm
Dear Cinapek,
What a double standard. If Chinese can be so upset with remark by Ahmad Ismail and demanded punishment to him, why Muslims can not demand action against RPK when he insulted Islam and Prophet Muhammad.
What would a PM do in this situation? Keep quiet. And says that no action can be taken even this RPK insults a religion simply because of so called “freedom of speech”. What freedom of speech we are talking about. We are talking about a poor banckrupt( literally and figuratively) soul who continously spread lies.
PM still tolerates it. But when he crossed the line and insulted the religion, he should know that his fate is sealed. I have no respect to a person who belittles a religion. Do not give crap such as the detention will put Malaysia into 3rd World status. The detention serves as a warning that there is a limit to everything.
The detention serves as a warning that those who play into racial or religious card that they will have to pay the price. If I were to be the PM, I would do the same. If I refuse to act, I must accept backlash from that community itself. And No PM would want to be in that situation.
So, my million dollar question to you SIr, It is OK to insult Islam or Prophet Muhammad or Jesus in the name of freedom?.
#36 by shamshul anuar on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 5:18 pm
Dear 9 to 5,
Get your facts right. During Operasi Lallang, not only Chinese politicians were arrested. Several Malay politicians were also arrested.
#37 by cheng on on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 5:20 pm
Reporters’ problems…
If we do not report what the gomen ppl said, our bosses will sacked us ! Nobody will buy the paper !
If we report what the gomen ppl said, the gomen will sacked us! SO HOW??? ANYBODY CAN GIVE A SOLUTION, THANKS
#38 by cheng on on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 5:29 pm
Hidup Pakatan Rakyat Says:
Yesterday at 23: 50.32
My vote to Pakatan Rakyat, PKR, DAP, PAS for
GE14, GE15, GE16, GE17, GE18, GE19, GE20, GE21, GE22, GE23,
GE24, GE25, GE26, GE27, GE28, GE29, GE30,……..GE100
How about GE13 ?? You are very greedy, you mean you want to live for another 250 years or more? even if there is a GE every 3 years. Be sensible lah!
#39 by cheng on on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 5:40 pm
Whether the person who apologize on behalf on Ah Mad Ism.. insulted anybody?? If yes, then can he be ISA..ed as well??
#40 by jenhz on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 8:28 pm
To Zak:
Some of the points you made with regards to RPK might be correct. I do not know much about Islam and Islam teachings so I cannot comment further. However, I urge you (like the rest here) to give us your stand on Teresa as well as Tan’s arrest. Reasons for Teresa’s arrest has not been made clear, while everyone knows why Tan is arrested. Can you tell me why you think that it is OK to let Ahmad Ismail off but it is not OK to let Tan be spared from all the chaos? Tell all of us here exactly what did Tan do wrongly that deserve such a 6-star treatment from ISA? Are you telling us here that reporting the truth and reporting on racism is against the law and moral? You still have not clarify that. Let me help you here. Tan is arrested as a scapegoat, not because she reported on racism, but because she was too daring to report on a racism comment made by a VIP. The moral behind this story is: if you are not a VIP or if you are not associated with any VIPs, do not make racist comments. I think perhaps I should get a VIP to become my godfather, then I can walk away freely chanting racist comments.
To Shamshul:
Let’s not talk about other countries. In Malaysia alone, since when did any VIPs got detain or arrest by ISA for making racist comments (directly or indirectly)? I can tell you I am a Christian and I’ve got many people insulted Jesus, but do Christians in Malaysia ever walk onto the streets and parade and ask for someone to be detained by ISA? Let me explain to you how our incompetent government uses ISA. As long as you report (whether you blog, write, talk, chant, swear etc) anything that is deem inappropriate, insulting or derogatory to Islam or the VIPs, you will be locked up. Period.
#41 by purpleberry on Saturday, 13 September 2008 - 10:28 pm
unfortunately MCA’s too afraid to speak up, its vice-president’s speech seemed to be on “their” side. MCA’s with Gerakan, creating the so-called “bangsa malaysia”…and as to what we’ve seen here, they’re merely creating their “own bangsa”, the ones acknowledging ISA and its discretion, keeping silent to avoid troubles. if we are one “bangsa”, then why can’t we discuss sensitive issues, with every party taking it openly? if it’s so hard to do so, with ISA and all, how can Abdullah expect us to unite then? the lacunae is so big, you think we are blind? and dumb??
#42 by Malar on Sunday, 14 September 2008 - 12:42 am
Today Kayveas of PPP spoke on the arrest of 3 people under ISA. Even he was against this act but mic and especially sami value has not voiced out anything in favour of the 3 people. He too could be angry with RPK for the article on the land scam. Unfortunately there is no one on behalf of the indians to speak. MIC is hiding behind PM’s sarong. Makkal shakti please pray for the safe return of these 3 people. There won’t be any arrest this week because syed albar is busy with the return of the MPs from Taiwan. After a short break, I’m not sure who are the unfortunates on the list. He would say, “They are not a threat but their lives are in a threat so I need to put them under ISA’. Does this sound interesting!
#43 by nty on Sunday, 14 September 2008 - 1:31 am
Go to hell BN. What the heck that the stupid guy that mention the real statement still free outside and continue bullshitting but the reporter that report the news truthfully without adding any own opinion. (Only 100++ word news) put in jail. This is so call Malaysia boleh? Malaysia really Boleh, but too bad in the wrong and stupid way. This just make us embarrass in front of other country. Go to hell BN.
#44 by ktteokt on Sunday, 14 September 2008 - 8:58 am
Actually, all these “penalizing the person reporting any crime” in Malaysia has given rise to the uncivicmindedness and selfishness of Malaysians. I often hear parents telling their children “to mind your own business and stop being nosey” in fear of getting into trouble with the law. The law in Malaysia has transformed itself into an “nasty monster” preying on the innocent!