Penang’s economy buzzing again


By Carolyn Hong, Malaysia Bureau Chief
Sep 10, 2011 in http://www.businesstimes.com.sg/

GEORGETOWN (Penang): On a small table in the office of Penang Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng sit half a dozen gold-coloured cats.

They were gifts, and a reminder of his much-cherished Cat principles – Competency, Accountability and Transparency.

Mr Lim, now in his fourth year leading one of Malaysia’s wealthiest states, is convinced that those principles have guided the recent revival of Penang’s fortunes.

He has much to shout about. Under the Pakatan Rakyat (PR) government, Penang received the lion’s share of foreign investments in Malaysia last year, for the first time in the country’s history. It also had the third-highest number of tourists, and raked in two-thirds of the country’s earnings in medical tourism.

‘Penang was in a graceful decline, but it’s now growing again. What has happened was the change of government. We refused to be tied down by the old conventional crony system,’ Mr Lim told The Straits Times in an interview.

Mr Lim, 50, became Penang’s chief minister after the opposition PR unexpectedly won five states in the 2008 General Election.

He touted his government’s emphasis on efficiency, pointing out that this had been acknowledged by the Malaysian Auditor-General’s Report and anti- graft organisation Transparency International.

‘We went back to the basics. We are running a government that is clean and efficient, and investors have seen the changes… and they like it,’ he said.

On the streets of Penang, the revitalisation is palpable. Its heritage enclave, covering a wide swathe of state capital Georgetown, is buzzing with life, with many decrepit shophouses now refurbished to their former beauty.

The Penaga Hotel, restored by famed Malaysian architect Hijjas Kasturi, has opened its doors to the well-heeled. Two old British department stores – Whiteaways and Logan – have gleaming coats of fresh paint, and have reopened as chic outlets.

Penang is drawing visitors by the hundreds of thousands, and its streets are often gridlocked with cars and tourists. The island’s property prices have soared to the level of Kuala Lumpur’s.

It is a lot cleaner too, and crime fell by 27 per cent last year.

But it is not just anecdotal evidence that points to Penang’s renewed success. Economic data tells the same story. The state drew RM12.2 billion (S$4.9 billion) in foreign direct investments last year, and its economy grew 7.9 per cent, compared with 7.2 per cent for the entire country.

Datuk Toh Kin Woon, a senior research fellow at the Socio-Economic and Environmental Research Institute, a state think-tank, said: ‘The sources of growth are sustaining their momentum, and overall, the picture is good.’

Penang’s recent success is a vindication for PR, often dismissed by the ruling Barisan Nasional as too inexperienced to rule, as well as for Mr Lim himself.

The son of opposition veteran Lim Kit Siang, he was detained for 18 months under the Internal Security Act during a crackdown in 1987, and jailed a year in 1998 for publishing a statement deemed to be false in a statutory rape case involving former Malacca chief minister Rahim Tamby Chik.

Mr Lim, an economics graduate from Monash University in Australia and a qualified accountant, said he wants Penang to be as competitive as Singapore, and has gone many times to the Republic to woo Singaporean investors.

He said he has also approached Singapore’s Housing Board to help build public housing in land-scarce Penang.

‘We want to learn from the masters,’ he added.

The state has allocated 81ha on the western side of the island to build up to 20,000 units of public housing.

Singaporeans, too, are being drawn to Penang’s shine: They invested RM4 billion last year in factories and businesses there, and consistently make up one of its largest proportions of visitors.

The turnaround comes after a tough decade for Penang. Its boom had been driven, since the 1970s, by the influx of electronics companies like Intel, which set up their assembly plants in its free trade zone.

But in the last 10 years, the island had lost its draw as a manufacturing hub, with foreign investors flocking to the cheaper destinations of China and Vietnam.

Tourism also waned, as its inner city areas became dilapidated and hollowed out after its residents were forced out by soaring costs following the repeal of rent controls in 2000.

The tourism revival began in 2008, when Georgetown was recognised by Unesco as a World Heritage Site. That was the same year that Mr Lim took office. Tourists started to return, and investors flooded the city, refurbishing heritage shophouses, turning them into stylish cafes, hotels and shops.

Its manufacturing revival, analysts say, came around the same time as costs began rising in China, especially in its coastal cities.

Penang was led by Gerakan chief Koh Tsu Koon from 1990 till he lost his seat in 2008. Tan Sri Koh has derided Mr Lim for unfairly taking credit for the successes that were due to the solid foundations laid by his administration.

The influx of investments has benefited the entire northern Malaysia, comprising the states of Perlis, Kedah, Penang and Perak, according to the federal Northern Corridor Economic Region chief executive Redza Rafiq.

Analysts and manufacturers say Mr Lim did not simply arrive at the right time. The boom, they say, was helped along by his new government’s policies.

Political analyst Andrew Aeria, a Penangite working at Universiti Malaysia Sarawak, noted that Penang’s success must be seen in the context of the solid base built over the last 20 to 30 years.

‘But at the same time, I think the Democratic Action Party-run state government is much better than the previous one, and this helps a lot,’ he said.

Mr Lim’s philosophy is simple: ‘We offer value for money.’

He said Penang cannot compete on costs, and does not want to be a sweatshop, anyway. It emphasises speed and efficiency, he explained, for instance by allowing investors to build their factories with conditional approval to speed up the process.

‘We are always on call,’ he said, recalling how he sorted out work permits for a large multinational while campaigning in the Sarawak state election in April. ‘This sort of news spreads, so we get a good reputation.’

Mr Lee Kah Choon, who heads the state’s investment agency InvestPenang, said once a deal is struck, it is usually implemented within 12 months.

The state has also begun moving into the higher end of the manufacturing process, such as product development, as it seeks to distance itself from the low-cost models.

‘We are focused only on investments that we want, and industries that are high-tech and knowledge-intensive,’ said Mr Lim. Priority sectors include those involving medical devices, aerospace, renewable energy and the higher end of electronics.

Companies like Flextronics International, a large electronics manufacturer, have begun to use Penang as a launchpad for products such as the parts for the world’s fastest central processing unit, said Mr Manny Marimuthu, Flextronics’ senior vice- president of finance in Asia.

He said its subsidiary Vista Point Technologies developed 85 per cent of its products locally.

As troubles in the global economy threaten future foreign investments, Penang has prepared itself to take up the slack by commissioning RM8 billion worth of infrastructure works.

Mr Lim is hopeful that the state’s renewed optimism and vibe will survive the storm.

  1. #1 by joehancl on Saturday, 10 September 2011 - 10:12 pm

    Penang is a Blessed state with people who is always mindful of God. If you have not heard, Penang is a people who prays hard to God in all its colours.

  2. #2 by boh-liao on Sunday, 11 September 2011 - 12:56 am

    No! No! No! How can HE and PR b so thick skinned 2 claim MY n BN’s efforts as theirs?
    D bo hood protested, crying Wee! Wee! Wee! all the way home

  3. #3 by yhsiew on Sunday, 11 September 2011 - 7:10 am

    ///They were gifts, and a reminder of his much-cherished Cat principles – Competency, Accountability and Transparency.///

    Guan Eng has got the formula right. Well done Guan Eng!

  4. #4 by Bigjoe on Sunday, 11 September 2011 - 8:26 am

    DAP and LGE has an amazing political venture opportunity in Penang. The possibility of creating a long term independent and thriving state, to roll back federalism, will be nothing less than historically glorious. It will contribute greatly to long term liberaltarian ideology of self-reliant in Malaysia at least institutionally.

    Why PR will hold on to Penang is not only because they are doing a good job but also because the Chinese votes are permanently not going back to BN on their own. Like it or not, the only people that can chase the non-Muslim votes in Penang back to BN is PR themselves.

    The BN formula, at least the reality of it, not the original promise of Alliance founding, has been rejected permanently by Chinese in this country. Unless BN fufill its original promise of the founding of this nation, which it can’t so long as Mahathirism is not rejected by the Malays, there is no way the Chinese votes are ever going back. There is no reason for it. The crux of the matter is Mahathirism is a failed ideology to minorities in this country and Chinese, being the most urban, knows it ahead of everyone else.

    So long as UMNO B/BN continue not to change fundamentally at its core so long it will fail to garner back their votes.

  5. #5 by monsterball on Sunday, 11 September 2011 - 8:32 am

    And all you need to do is wait for Koh Tsu Koon crying for help…claiming he did all the ground work and Lim Guan Eng gets the credit.
    In his 18 years..as CM of Penang..he is only good …at polishing Mahathir’s shoes.

  6. #6 by cintanegara on Sunday, 11 September 2011 - 10:02 am

    OMG, never knew LGE had a master? If he had a master, well who is LGE? Office boy to his master???

    According to Malaysian Investment Development Authority (Mida) senior director (investment) Phang Ah Tong, Johor would always be the preferred destination for investors from that country due to its close proximity with the republic.He said of the total RM14.95bil investments by that republic investors to date, RM6.9bil was invested in Johor.(based on 2010 reports) It is an actual fact that Johor is the biggest trade partner with that republic.

    As far as Malaysians know, Johor MB never regard their business partners as their masters. WHY? It is merely because Johor MB has his pride and dignity of being a loyal Malaysian. Unlike LGE he always belittle his fellow countrymen but adores the orang asing. Such an incompetent leader he is…

    • #7 by ChinNA on Sunday, 11 September 2011 - 1:07 pm

      You did misunderstand the area that you commented on, right? Please read it again. You are off-target.

  7. #8 by undertaker888 on Sunday, 11 September 2011 - 10:37 am

    Cinta my foot is master-bating again. Like umno, syiok sendiri. Although with 30% or more advantage but still jealous of LGE. LGE still produce results although handicapped by the corrupted federal govt.

    Tell the Johor mb todo that without any preferences. cinta my a$$.

  8. #9 by waterfrontcoolie on Sunday, 11 September 2011 - 12:43 pm

    Let forget about cinta with his ONE TRACK RAILROAD thinking, he will never be able to change even if he wanted to; because he would not know where to start with!. On the positive side, it is hoped that the lesson at Penang could be ‘transferred’ to all other PR-controlled States and this should be doen soonest! Yes, the test is always in the eating of the pudding!

  9. #10 by k1980 on Sunday, 11 September 2011 - 1:21 pm

    “Khairy is a good boy, he has the potential to become a future PAS leader…I’m serious. Why should I debate him when the one who has been attacking me is the Umno deputy president,” Mohamad Sabu said to squeals of laughter from the audience.

    So is Pak Jib…..the leader of the opposition after the 13GE
    http://tv3suku.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/najibpakaiserban.jpg

  10. #11 by boh-liao on Sunday, 11 September 2011 - 2:06 pm

    Cintai lah negara, rakyat; don’t forget 2 wear CLEAN YELLOW shirts 2 d Malaysia Aidilfitri-Merdeka 2011 Open House 2 b held at SMK Guar Perahu 2day, 911

  11. #12 by boh-liao on Sunday, 11 September 2011 - 2:30 pm

    Walao, MCA n Gerakan siao liao, telling rakyat dat they no want 2 accept any Cabinet post if they fail 2 perform well in d next GE; sound like got hood leh
    But, honestly, they no need 2 worry abt dis 1, cos if rakyat kick UmnoB/BN out of Putrajaya, UmnoB, MCA, Gerakan, MIC, etc all sama sama NO Cabinet post lor, only got opposition
    So, no need 2 xia lan n b so blur abt their own condemned future
    Relak lah, get ready 2 ta pau n chap larp!

You must be logged in to post a comment.