By Kee Thuan Chye
I am proud to call myself Malaysian first and Chinese second. And if I were to tell other Chinese Malaysians that, I don’t think they will shun me.
Even if they do, so be it. Let them. If they are so narrow-minded as not to see the beauty of calling oneself Malaysian first, I don’t want to have anything to do with them.
I have two children to whom I have given Malaysian names, i.e. Malay, Indian and Chinese names. It is my contribution to Bangsa Malaysia. Their identity cards bear their full names.
In both cases, their Malay name comes first. And that is the name my wife and I call them by. We call our daughter Soraya and our son Jebat. To us, Malay names are also Malaysian names, and our children are Malaysian. We have no hang-ups about it.
Now, why can’t this be the norm in this beautiful, rich, multi-racial nation – a nation that is beautiful and rich because of its many races and cultures? Why must we separate ourselves into divisive categories? Why can’t we take the inclusive approach, consider each of our fellow citizens as being part of a whole, as part of us instead of as the Other?
Why is it so hard for someone no less than the deputy prime minister of this country to acknowledge that he is Malaysian first and Malay second? Why does he give the excuse that if he were to do so, he would be shunned by the Malays? How does he know for sure? Why does he presume the negative? Why would they shun him?
He is a leader of the country. Should he not instead be leading by example? For all we know, if he were to actually declare himself Malaysian first and Malay second, he might find others doing the same – and they may well be not just Malays but people of other races as well. Why does he fear to lead and instead prefer to take the safe and untested route? Why does he even take the exclusive line and say, “I am a Malay first”?
The basic function of leadership is taking the first step before anyone else, isn’t it? Especially if it’s a step in the right direction, towards the noble purpose of bringing the people closer together. It may be a risky step to take but if it’s the right one, morally and logically, who can judge you harshly?
PM waffles in interview
Walk the talk, leaders. Do what’s right, not what’s politically expedient. Why does the prime minister defend the deputy prime minister for saying he is Malay first? Why does the prime minister himself not say he is Malaysian first and Malay second when the TV station Al Jazeera put the question to him?
Granted, the Al Jazeera interviewer didn’t pose the question sharply. Instead of saying to the PM, “Let me then just ask you, are you a Malay first and a Malaysian second?”, she should have asked, “Would you say you are a Malaysian first and a Malay second?” That would have been to-the-point.
He would not have been able to wriggle his way out by saying, “Well technically, if we talk about the Constitution, I am a Malay but I’m comfortable being a Malay in a Malaysian society …” He wasn’t actually answering the question. And the interviewer wasn’t on-the-ball enough to pin him down.
Perhaps someone else should now pose the proper question to the PM so we can see how he responds. I would be disappointed if he waffled again. He is, after all, the man with the 1Malaysia slogan, the one that aims to unite all Malaysians. If he can’t walk the talk, how much credibility can we give the 1Malaysia concept? In fact, if he can’t walk the talk, how much trust can we give the PM?
At the end of the day, will it only be left to ordinary citizens like me to declare ourselves Malaysian first and whatever our race is, second? I’m sure there are many others out there – ordinary citizens – who will make that declaration with readiness and sincerity. Perhaps if our leaders won’t take the lead, we ordinary citizens should do it, ironic as it may sound. Perhaps we should show our leaders how to walk the talk. Why not?
Let’s band together and exercise our right, our power, as the rakyat. Let’s show Malaysia – and the world – that if our leaders will not take the lead, we the people will take up that responsibility. We will not be doing anything wrong. In fact, we will be doing what is good for our country. We will be bringing about the real 1Malaysia.
How about it? I am a Malaysian first and a Chinese second. What about you?

#1 by baochingtian on Tuesday, 6 April 2010 - 8:25 am
The pm preaches acceptance and tolerance. Unfortunately he endorses race before the country. Under such leadership, the rakyat should shun away from him as there will never be peace in the country, one race is always treated above the other, even above laws of the country itself. How then would there be acceptance and tolerance among the different races in the country?
Both PM and DPM are malay first, satu malaysia second; who are the ones in satu malaysia then? So satu malaysia consists of only the non-malays and the orang asli? Or they have also lined up numbers for the non-malays as well?
#2 by syc on Tuesday, 6 April 2010 - 9:23 am
I am Malaysian First. Enough said
#3 by kpt99 on Tuesday, 6 April 2010 - 9:39 am
Bolehland is always bolehland. Regarding awarding the top 30 spm last year,KPM only explains the system of averaging being used to the public after complaints arise.
#4 by Motorist on Tuesday, 6 April 2010 - 10:56 am
UMNO must probaly have a special IC & passport which doesnt bear the flag of M’sia (like IC) or the crest of M’sia Gov (like passport).
The special IC probaly bears the flag of UMNO & states at the top Kad Pengenalan Melayu.
Passport probably bears the kris of UMNO & states at the top Pasport Melayu.
#5 by Godfather on Tuesday, 6 April 2010 - 12:09 pm
We must analyze the latest JPA scholarship awards announced by Moo Hee Din. I think the first criterion is race, and that accounts for 60 pct of scholarships awarded. That’s the definition of 1Malaysia ? I’m surprised that Ibrahim Katak hasn’t made any noise. He should be asking for 70 pct for the dominant race.
#6 by SENGLANG on Tuesday, 6 April 2010 - 12:30 pm
Absolutely i have not doubt about that I am Malaysian First then I am remain a Malaysian second but with not choice I you ask further than I will say I am of Chinese decedent, and I am not Chinese in the true sense mean people born in China and in a Family of Han descendant.
I might say I am Malaysian of Han Decedent but am very sure I am not a Chinese which mean a China National born in China.
So all other also call Malaysian than if you wish to insist further differentiation only than you identify yourself what decedent you are from but at the end of it you are remain Malaysian first.
#7 by cinaindiamelayubersatu on Tuesday, 6 April 2010 - 5:02 pm
umno style
1malaysia
umnoputra didahulukan
pencapaian wang ringgit diutamakan
the star monday 5 april 2010
Kota Kinabalu; Burglars escaped with a pistol and bullets whenthey broke into the house of a state assemblyman in Luyang here. The burglars also escaped with about RM40000 cash, jewellery, a watch and keys to the Mercedes belonging to the assemblyman in the 4am break in yesterday. The Umno assemblyman…….. alahai ahli umno rupanya. kepada perompak perompak yang arif rompaklah rumah ahli ahli umno yang penuh dengan cash di rumah mereka, janganlah merompak rumah rakyat jelata yang biasa biasa…
#8 by frankyapp on Tuesday, 6 April 2010 - 10:04 pm
Well guys,Hulu Selangor voters will have the chance through the by election to give the seat back to PR. This is the best way to telling NR that his 1malaysia and NEM would not be acceptable by the people.
#9 by chan2523 on Tuesday, 6 April 2010 - 11:15 pm
no problem to say that I’m a Malaysian 1st.
For somebody who fear to say it out, pls change ur nationality ASAP!! Every Malaysian should be proud to say that they are Malaysian 1st but not race!
#10 by Bunch of Suckers on Wednesday, 7 April 2010 - 5:08 am
Hanjin Chengho would say he is a Chinese first and Malaysian second so that he can pocket more,,,
In fact, Hanjin Chengho is no longer a Chinese! He is a Hanjin or Running dog! Time comes to see he will be skinned off….