Letters
by Allan C
I am a Chinese Malaysian male with diverse groups of friends – Tamils, Malayalees, Sikhs, Jaffna Tamils, whites, Eurasians, and Babas and Nyonyas.
The problem is I have very few Malay friends.
Umno tells them I am a threat to them..
Umno tells them I am undeserving of equal rights.
They might even believe it, and since I don’t want to think any less of them, I prefer to keep my own counsel.
Generally I don’t talk much about anything important with Malays, and certainly not about politics.
I think meaningful friendships between Malays and non-Malays are becoming rare in Malaysian society.
There is not enough dialogue between Malays and non-Malays at the ground level. Umno speaks from both sides of its mouth – telling the Malays the non-Malays are a threat to them, and then turning round to tell the non-Malays that their rights will be protected.
At other times it may say the reverse, the key denominator being what it needs to say to win votes at the time, and the ethnic composition of the audience. After 51 years of Umno’s divide and rule, it is no wonder that race relations are a joke.
With Biro Tata Negara, Khir Toyo and Ahmad Ismail to lead the way, only a fool will think Umno wants good race relations. Umno leaders wants good race relations only when it will keep them in power. Power and money are the real motivations for Umno’s political leaders.
After the twisted judicial treatments and twisted sentences meted out to the likes of Lim Guan Eng, Anwar Ibrahim, Teresa Kok and Raja Petra Kamaruddin, I think we can safely rule out any semblance of a sense of right and wrong and common decency as a meaningful guide to Umno’s decisions.
There are a number of things I want to put across to my imaginary Malay audience in cyberspace – you – particularly if you believe every racist, inflammatory, bigoted, and demonised stereotype, opinion piece and fabricated news that Ahmad Ismail, Khir toyo, Utusan Melayu, and Biro Tata Negara tells you about me.
If I were a Malay leader, this is what I would say. The Malays totally dominate the aristocracy, cabinet, parliament, judiciary, police, military, and huge government bureaucracy. The Malays have the highest birth rates.
You have benefitted from the racial quotas in education, commerce, licenses, contracts, jobs and promotions – funded by non-Malays. Therefore if you are feeling aggrieved, if you are feeling angry, and if you are feeling insecure, you need to ask yourself why…
If Umno tells you that your culture, language, race and religion is threatened by non-Malays and non-Muslims, i would suggest you think critically before you act. Umno has destroyed any hope of English literacy amongst the Malay masses.
Without English literacy the professions are out of the question for you. High-paying jobs will be hard to find. You will be handicapped in your career and business. Umno tells you that the non- Malays have advanced economically at your expense.
Umno loves to say that the non Malays have used unfair means to advance by cheating you.
The truth is Umno leadership has advanced economically and socially at your expense by destroying your competitiveness but to cap it all, they have succeeded in making you blame the non-Malays for their mistakes.
Umno makes you think that the way for you to reach global competitiveness would be to oppress and hamstring the non-Malays with steep racial quotas for jobs, licenses, and university places.
The truth is that it is the competitiveness and grit of successful Malays and non-Malays who compete in the open market in open competition that acts to provide every Malaysian – you and I – with the best goods at the cheapest prices.
You could buy a good quality, long lasting, reliable Japanese car in any other country for what you pay for a crappy Proton in Malaysia . Meanwhile, the AP scam that gives select Malays a license to smuggle in thousands of cars without paying duty will never be awarded to anyone other than the most overly privileged, wealthy and connected Umno elite insider – and definitely not to you if you are an ordinary decent Malay.
With Umno’s wholesale corruption, and racist propaganda that scapegoats and demonises the non-Malays to play on your fears and anxieties, our beloved country will come to resemble the uneducated, unproductive, expensive, impoverished countries like Burma , Indonesia , Philippines and Zimbabwe .
Umno leaders will do anything to stay in power and wealth, and that includes to divide and rule with lies, judicial abuse, and more. In the beginning the NEP picked the low-hanging fruit so there was an easy prosperity for everyone but now the signs of terminal decay are everywhere.
Economic and political reality has come back to roost, and if you are still poor, you need to ask why filthy rich Umno leaders are telling you that the non-Malays continue to cheat you of your rights and prosperity. The truth is that the success of any Malaysian in the open market that is subject to open competition will benefit all Malaysians.
Businesses, academics and professionals who have succeeded because of their competitiveness, innovation, hard work and determination bring prosperity to all Malaysians. Non-Malays and Malays who compete in the open market, if they succeed, it is because they offer everyone – you and I – a better product at a lower price.
Businesses and businesspersons who have succeeded because of a government-sanctioned cartel or monopoly that denies others the chance to compete will make all Malaysians poorer – that is, except the lucky filthy rich Umno-BN leaders who gave themselves or family or cronies the cartel or monopoly – APs, Proton, UEM, Renong, Bank Bumi – in the first place.
If you are reading this letter, I can presume that just like me, you did not get the exclusive contract, license, cartel or monopoly either. The truth is you and I and everyone else have been made poorer by the system that Umno has created.
If the economy is heading for a downturn, and if the financial crisis affected your business, and you are wondering why people in other countries don’t work as hard as you, and still earn much more money, then you will begin to understand that they live in a superior system.
Their leaders do not rob and abuse their citizens as much as in Malaysia . If you drive a Proton and they drive a Japanese car for the same price, then you are never going to be as well off as them.
Advanced progressive modern countries have achievement- based values, equal rights, open competition, meritocracy, and legislate against racism.
Such countries will have wealthier and healthier citizens who are not any smarter than you, and who will not be working harder than you, but they will be better informed than you, their kids will receive a better education than yours, and they will be earning lots more money than either you or me.
Umno will tell you that advanced countries like Singapore have prospered at your expense. The truth is that Umno will never give you a superior system. It cannot reform because it has an addiction problem. Umno leaders are addicted to huge amounts of easy money – your money!
Umno will tell you that their addiction to your money is in your best interests. Umno will say they only take money from non-Malays. Umno will say it is your fault if you are addicted to Umno’s Ketuanan Melayu policies and bumiputera privileges..
The truth is that Umno is addicted to your tax money, and Umno will try to weaken your will to succeed on your own by getting you mentally addicted to their falsehoods. Unless Umno can make you feel addicted to your privileges, and make you feel unable to compete, and frightens you with the non-Malay bogeyman (or bogeywoman like Teresa Kok), and that he or she is a threat to your safety, finances, future, race, language, culture and religion, then Umno knows it will lose your vote in open competition to PKR and PAS.
The biggest obstacles to Malay progress are low standards and low expectations.
Umno tells you that you cannot compete with the non-Malays. Yet there are so many parameters to what is better or not that it is impossible to measure them all. It is illogical to think that someone else is better than you.
To believe that you cannot compete is a very low expectation that guarantees very low standards, and it is the last thing you would ever want to leave to your children. The solution requires guts and faith – in you. You must insist on open competition, meritocracy, equal rights, and an end to all forms of racism.
You are not inferior, you can compete, and you control your own destiny.
If you allow Umno to brainwash you, and your children, then low standards and low expectations become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
The NEP has inevitably deteriorated to become a scam whereby Umnoputras will get all the benefits and be laughing all the way to the bank and everyone else gets poorer funding their excesses – mansions, wives, fat bank accounts, licenses, contracts, monopolies, APs. You get nothing, and I get even less than nothing – blamed for being the pendatang.
PAS and PKR want to change the NEP so that it will help the poor of all races but since the Malays form the bulk of the poor, then the Malays will automatically benefit exceedingly, and no one will feel left out or despised.
We must create a superior system of government that will be efficient, productive, progressive, competitive, and meritocractic – one that can hope to outperform Singapore – if we are to hold our heads up high, in open competition, and without prejudice.
The Malays will still totally dominate the aristocracy, cabinet, parliament, police, judiciary, military and government but in a country that is progressive, meritocractic, educated, progressive, prosperous and respects equal rights, human rights and freedoms.
This would be real legacy worth leaving to your children.
Choose wisely . . . . .

#1 by no on Monday, 1 December 2008 - 1:18 pm
cintanegara
The BN MP have not ask for your back side for power yet? Meh,
Why you so free to posted your stupid commend here?
‘Fairness’ – Extremely difficult to achieve in multi racial country. It is undeniable that the majority should get special privileges to address the imbalance of economic equity.
What kind of stupid answer you sent here?
The NEP policy only benefit few bunch of corrupted people connect to UMNO. Where the rural Malay is in poor shape. Is this what you called fairness?
You should ask those professional expatriacte to tell you f..k off from their office else you are insulted them using their name to insulted human rights posted by you, all expatricate fully respect human rights.
You supported children 10As is not brain drain rejected by local but government took it as brain drain if they dont accept the Malays even his/her is only 5Cs.
We can see you are 99.9% racist.
Your special position on others for over 51 years is earned by cheating on others, refused others demand for review.
Your special position is supposed to help you instead now you are using it to oppress other races in Malaysia, it is totally abusing and unacceptable.
Like I said,
YOUR CURRENT SPECIAL POSITION OVER OTHERS FOR OVER 51 YEARS IS EARNBED BY CHEATING, REFUSED OTHERS DEMAND FOR REVIEW.
DO YOU GOT IT? CHEATING
#2 by Shamsudin on Monday, 1 December 2008 - 1:33 pm
The problems:-
1. The best person do not get the best job.
2. The best student do not get a place in the best U.
3. The best company do not get the contract.
4. The best person do not serve in the government.
Limited resources are not efficiently and optimally utilised = wastage.
How long can the oil revenue last to sustain all these wastage???
God bless Malaysia.
#3 by Godfather on Monday, 1 December 2008 - 2:07 pm
Guys:
cintanegara is a product of the NEP. He is sitting pretty in the bus, and he is not about to give way to those who are more in need of the seat. He is also telling us that if he has to get off the bus, his seat is reserved for one of his own kind only. If you want a seat, go to another bus, don’t appeal to him to give up his seat.
Don’t be angry at those who have come up through the crutch system perpetuated by UMNO. Reason with a cool head. Just vote wisely.
#4 by AhPek on Monday, 1 December 2008 - 3:29 pm
‘It is undeniable that the majority should get special priveleges to address to address the imbalance of economic equity.’. cintanegara.
Really! ‘Undeniable’ it seems.That’s very insightful.I always thought that it is a ploy for a special group of priveleged Malays to clean the coffers of the nation.
#5 by OrangRojak on Monday, 1 December 2008 - 3:58 pm
“It is undeniable that the majority should get special privileges to address the imbalance of economic equity”
NO. This is absolutely the biggest mistake ever made in the history of a nation. I have an opinion as to why this method was chosen – it is, after all, extremely simple to describe and to operate. You are the right colour, you get special. You aren’t the right colour, you don’t get special. Given a button to peck, even a pigeon could operate such a system.
But it completely misses the point. Economic imbalance is a fact of life. Some love it, some wish for more equal distribution. Basing the system of penalty / favour on colour is collective punishment for non-kopi-coloured, and indiscriminate favour for kopi-coloured. If you are non-kopi-coloured and wish and act for fairness – you are the most penalised of all. If you are kopi-coloured and wish and act selfishly, you are the most favoured of all. On both sides, the Malaysians of whatever colour who wish and act for fairness are the ones who get the worst deal – there is no incentive to act fairly.
A fairer, more difficult to operate system would be based on means alone. If one colour Malaysian is disproportionately poorer, they would be disproportionately favoured by a means-tested rule. If one colour Malaysian is disproportionately richer, then they will pay more tax. Tax the rich, help the poor: if there’s racial imbalance in earnings, there’ll be racial imbalance of payments. If (IF!) there’s an immutable correlation between race and earnings, there’ll be a corresponding immutable relationship between race and support. Such a scheme penalises the richest (which is what poor and reasonable people want) and supports the poor (which is what reasonable and poor people want).
If (IF!) there was the slightest possibility that an imbalance existed because of anti-social financial practices, the reasonable (but requires effort) response would be to enact strict business laws governing anti-social ways of doing business. You can’t sell this last option to anyone. Poor people don’t understand – it doesn’t say anything about sunburn, blistered hands and children handicapped through disease their parents can’t afford to treat. Rich people will hate it and instruct their pet journalists to say bad things about it, which poor people will believe, because they want to be like the rich person and have a Mercedes and dangly jewelled accessories for their handphones. But it really is the only way to fairly fight unfairly acquired imbalance.
If someone complained about anti-unfairness rules, you could laugh in their face, and I would stand next to you laughing too. Giving government handouts to kopi-coloured people who drive Mercedes isn’t funny – it’s idiotic. It’s time for the Malaysian poor to form a community around their most pressing common issue, and not the most superficial.
#6 by ryan123 on Monday, 1 December 2008 - 4:01 pm
cintaUMNO have no idea about equality and equity. As simple as that.
I do think that the article is kind of aggressive, but at least it offers an alternative perspective for MORONS like you to see. But you just reject it without further considerations, don’t you think that you are ignorant?
Your so-called GREAT contributions? Many are doing that as well, I see no weight in your works.
“Undeniable”, I dare to say that Malaysia is the only country doing so. Please list out another example?
You don’t have jealousy, but you have fear towards fair competition, as simple as that.
I was rejected by Local U for my first 5 choices of course, but was awarded scholarship in a foreign countries, while some people get admitted with numerous B’s, so? I don’t see any sincerity in the local education system in avoiding brain drain. Perhaps they treasure people like you.
Have you seen US whites mentioning to the African American that – “I brought you here, granted you citizenship. Hence, I shall have privileges which you shouldn’t have”? In other hand, I see affirmative actions given to those who really need it.
Don’t be defensive all the time. Spend a little bit of time to think from the perspectives of Chinese, Indians, Kadazans, Dusuns, Ibans, etc etc
#7 by shortie kiasu on Monday, 1 December 2008 - 4:24 pm
Sometimes we really yearned that British Colonists were fairer to all in the country, and would preferred the British was still the master rather than what we have now although independent, the race discrimination is much more worse.
Non malays were treated as third class.
Despite the fact that malays are given special privileges, special quotas & rights in all spheres of life here, like government contracts, scholarships, universities places, civil services jobs, top positions in GLC and civil service, judiciary, legal service, police and army top brass…. you name it they have it in this country, and yet in any businesses and ventures set up by non malays, they have to give malays 30% too.
When we build houses, we must reserve 30% for malays, whether they will buy or not, we have to give 5 to 10% discount to malays.
And these discounts will be at the expense of non malays. In some states like Kedah, 50% of houses built must be reserved at discounted prices for the malays, why? Non malays aren’t human beings too? We also need to live and eat and work, but whatever non malays struggled and succeeded, 30% must be handed out to malays, besides all the special privileges and treatment guaranteed by the constitution?
Isn’t such a situation worse that those colonial days for non malays? At least all were equal under the laws then.
#8 by AhPek on Monday, 1 December 2008 - 4:53 pm
‘I don’t see any sincerity in the local education system in avoiding brain drain.’.
ryan 123.
Talking about brain drain it reminds me of a conversation many years ago between Tun Razak and Lee Kuan Yew.LKS in the course of the conversation remarked to Razak on the leaving of professionals ‘Are you not worried about the brain drain in your country.’.Razak shot back,’What! You mean trouble drain.’.
This mentality coming from Razak has ever since set the tone in this country as to how non Malays are to be treated.He hasn’t got the slightest concern for the well-being of the nation!
#9 by OrangRojak on Monday, 1 December 2008 - 5:43 pm
“you have fear towards fair competition, as simple as that”
And where would a Malaysian go to find fair competition? Malaysian business is almost universally viewed as dishonest. I tell companies overseas that I’m in Malaysia, they don’t want to do business with me. It’s all cash up front or they don’t want their fingers burnt twice in the same fire. This is the same thing my jogging partners tell me while we’re sweating our way around the local palm plantation, and so do their friends. When they introduce me to their friends, their friends ask me to represent them overseas (prawns, building blocks and electronics in the last month), because overseas companies don’t trust them. It’s no good me telling them I have the same problem, they tell me “No, you are white, one of them, they’ll trust you.”
The problem is that the local racist glasses through which Malaysians view everything are not used overseas. I mention the “M” word to a non-Malaysian, I might as well have said “Arrrr, shiver me timbers, me hearty, deal with me, or I’ll run you through with me cutlass!”. What colour I am is completely immaterial to a non-Malaysian. Where did this point of view come from? I assert without proof and with the warning that I’ll use my worst Anglo Saxon on you that there’s no international conspiracy to paint Malaysia as ‘dishonestly Asia’. Malaysians have earned their reputation with their own ‘hard work’.
Malaysia has a problem with unfairness, and it’s as communal as it is constitutional. Abolishing the NEP without addressing the root cause of Malaysia’s international reputation as the “Black Pearl of Asia” is a complete non-starter. The constitutional obstacle is an easy target because it’s out in the open. The hidden problem that holds Malaysia back is no less important and harder to deal with because it’s unofficial.
#10 by de_Enigma on Monday, 1 December 2008 - 9:23 pm
I really find the following comments by Cintanegara Amusing:
1. My professional career contributes to a massive growth to the country
- A statement which is absolutely hard to quantify by all means. I don’t even know which field you are in.
2. I pay tax to the country to alleviate the hardships of the poorer people in the country and also to provide for needed infrastructure
- You pay tax and we really appreciate that, I have heard from a Malay from his mouth saying ‘Orang bodoh baru bayar cukai, saya tak minta dari mereka sudah kira baik’. Putting this aside, you need not forget, high percentage of your tax paid goes to the UMMO cronies, Ali-baba procedures and wastage due to inefficiency of appointed ‘forever learning bumiputra companies and agencies’.
3. I have numerous Non-Malays and professional expatriate working closely with me in the similar environment. Why would I have such jealousy whatsoever towards them?
- The jealousy topic you mentioned should be the other way round, I have the thought you were where you are to fulfill the quota of so-called ethnic diversification. If that’s the case, you just have to thank the wonderful system put in place by your beloved cronies.
4. ‘Give n take’ concept will ONLY work if both parties willing to sacrifice. It is not just one sided. It wouldn’t work if one side demanding others to eradicate their privileges while they themselves not willing to do so.
- kindly name any Non-Malay Privileges? If it is possible to transfer our brains and our hardworking attitudes, it would already be listed under ‘Malay-Privileges’. Guess what, equity and quota are achievable and please look around before you tell me I’m wrong.
5. With regards to the corruption, we have appropriate channel to address that. I believe you’re aware that several ministers/MB were charged for corruption and misconduct. Remember, what happened to ex-Selangor MB in 1976?
- Very well said, in Malaysia wrongdoers will be charged. However, politically connected people won’t be convicted. See what happened to Zakaria in my Hometown Klang with over 20 charges against him? He got away, allowed to keep his Mansion and started eying another piece of land next to it until finally god decide to take him out (Definitely not by your trusted ‘Appropriate Channels’)
6. Why didn’t you appeal if your children scored 10As but got rejected by local U? I believe the Government will consider the entry to avoid the brain drain.
- Do you think those 10A scorers would be too lazy to appeal? Have you any idea how difficult it is to appeal? (Have you experienced it – no?) Imagine you have done your best, yet you still have to appeal for something you actually deserved?
7. ‘Fairness’ – Extremely difficult to achieve in multi racial country. It is undeniable that the majority should get special privileges to address the imbalance of economic equity.
- The above just proven how shallow your thinking is in this whole issue. In a functional country, MINORITY are supposed to be given special privileges. Not the other way round like what you see here. Not to mention, your last sentence just suggested Communism.
Dear Cintanegara,
I really acknowledge your courage to be here commenting against our views. However, posting your views with only information from mainstream media and government sweet lips alone will just make you a laughing stock here.
#11 by pkrisnin on Monday, 1 December 2008 - 11:19 pm
W very well written article by Allan and excellent commenting by de_Enigma.
When I hear DEB/NEP Ketuanan Melayu I think of
Proton, Tenaga, Telekom/TM Net all monopoly business but still can lose money and need gov. support still. And now Angkasawan scandal.
Petronas, well as long as there’s oil its imposable to lose money unless the new CEO and UMNO decide to suck all the profits. Maybe that’s why they are planing a leadership change for Petronas.
Che Khalib, the current Tenaga boss, is said to be eying a Petronas job. GOD help us
These are the true results of DEB/NEP
MAS only came up recently due to competition from Air Asia.
An excellent example of what competition can produce.
#12 by oedipus on Tuesday, 2 December 2008 - 10:59 am
i actually am grateful for cintanegara for he has enabled us to have a meaningful discussion in a very civil manner, i do wish he drops by more often.
i have been to forum that often threatens, abuses and bullies posts that contradictory to what they wish to hear!
just ensure the discussion focuses on the topic, no personal attacks!
#13 by cemerlang on Tuesday, 2 December 2008 - 10:34 pm
Some non Bumiputras have this mentality. The Bumiputras will have it all. Even non Bumiputras are putting down non Bumiputras. If there is unfair, dirty competition, the Bumiputras cannot get far. They look good. But inside them, there is nothing. They will never know what it truely means to be fair and to be truely clean. Even their religion will fail to awaken them to be true believers.