“under the pretense that he did not write”
Do you imagine you’re in the legal profession zak? What makes you so certain a man is guilty of a charge? Have you also already decided a sentence? What is it? Are you caged within easy reach of a keyboard, foaming at the mouth, screaming “kill them all! kill them all”? Since the man is in court, the court is only doing its job when it tests the reliability of the evidence presented.

“so-called ‘martyr’ ”
Hahahaha, oh you caught me out. Anybody else have the New Testament stamped verbatim onto their memory from an early age? I try always to be more radical than Richard Dawkins in matters of spirituality these days, but this phrase reminded me of “it is you who say it” – remember that one? I’m not trying to invoke religion here, just revealing my own little psychotic episode. You too are hearing voices, zak, nobody but you said “martyr”.

“the opposition wants to ’salute’”
My personal view, expressed in the understanding that a trial is in progress and it is prejudice, is that one of the articles apparently written by RPK appeared to me to /invite/ prosecution under Malaysia’s sedition law. A certain combination of words which would have been regarded as harmless hyperbole in many other countries appeared to me to be an open invitation of legal action here in Malaysia. There are many recent events in Malaysia that I find puzzling. Then again, there are many things in Malaysia that don’t appear to me to be the consequence of rational activity.

I personally don’t consider the ISA to be a ‘legal action’, since its local definition effectively renders all your other laws inferior – it permits your fellow citizens to do whatever they please with absolute immunity. Such a rule, in my mind, invalidates the legal process in its entirety. It does not matter to me what RPK did – he could have boiled my grandmother down for soup – I would still support his cause if he wasn’t treated the way I would expect to be treated in his place.

That last point is probably what motivates much of RPK’s support. Without a reliable and fair legal process, his fellow citizens can have little hope of the protection that would normally be provided by law. By all means, charge him with sedition. It’s a silly law in modern times anyway, it could probably benefit from a few test cases to check whether it has any value. After actual law-breaking and incitement* to law-breaking, the activities that sedition laws might cover are painfully close to reasonable democratic dissent.

*That one alleged article of RPK’s I referred to (I haven’t read all his articles) appeared to me to invite legal action on the grounds of “incitement to cause criminal damage”, but only barely. So what? Fine him and bind him over (or whatever is the local equivalent). Blackbagging him was incomprehensible.

Emmm, zak, I think there are libel and slander laws in Malaysia that can be used if that were the case.

Ever wonder why those who have been “slandered”, and in RKP’s case, “libelled”, do not want to charge him in court? Instead, they chose the cowardly way of using sedition and ISA.

Wow im really excited what could have happen next.

Firstly… RPK was charge/claim under ISA for insulting Islam, now they(AAB) release him from kemunting for trial…

2nd… Why now why provoke the sedition case ‘Let’s send the Altantuya murderers to hell’?…

3rd… esok lusa anouncement AAB is gonna compete for PM seat and contestant for new DPM were (Exit) for “Najis” or “AAB”?

what u mean by disparaged and slandered?do RPK said anything wrong,discredit, belittle. all he said was a fact that u can’t accept. becauce all fact will hurt u. it is true? u don’t have the courage to accept the true fact.

can RPK shake the stability of our country? how can he be so powerful, because he disclosed so many insider news and all the trues that many PPL no dare to say. So here ISA apply it is true?

No country would tolerate such a detrimental individual to their security, u mean RPK so powerful he can affect the security of the country, by just using his pen. i think u are mentally retarded.

YB’s from PR must strive to have our beloved RPK freed from the evil clutches of the bn scoundrels. Sack these useless corrupt bn
@#%*$ and get rid of them. They are worthless human beings and so drunken with their self-importance that they are behaving like GOD. Justice will & must prevail for all to see the majesty of the divine existence & presence.

Let’s all pray for a fair and just trial
For not just one person but whole nation is on trial
==========================================

Well said, these BNed components are todays legal Pirates, they can abduct and lock you up without reason. Claim anything seditious they wish to claim regardless of fact towards victim is stupid like nobody business.

(C) Samuel Goh Kim Eng – 061008
http://MotivationInMotion.blogspot.com
Mon. 6th Oct. 2008.

RAJA PETRA, FATHER OF DEMOCRATIC MALAYSIA

RPK, Your name is engraved in Malaysian History as The Great Warrior of Truth, Justice and Peace.

Peace be with you, Mahatma, O Great Soul!

I think you got it all wrong. According to that non-Malay Deputy Minister on Youtube, can’t remember his name, just remember he looks a bit retarded…. Raja Petra was arrested under ISA for persistently ignoring the government’s warnings not to continue doing what he was doing, so after two three months, no choice lor….

The ISA is used for matters not chargeable in court, such as not being pro-Barisan Nasional, etc etc., while sedition is definitely a court matter. So two different stories, right?

Raja Petra should have joined UMNO, like Ahmad Ismail. If only he had done so, he would have got off ISA by being suspended for three years from holding any office in UMNO and as the Botak says in Youtube, “in that sense, [Ahmad Ismail] has already been punished.” Sounds wierd, but this is Malaysia, isn’t it?

p.s. RPK’s latest pic reminds me of the infamous Salman Rushdie :^)

You think so?
If our government is at all perturbed by public opinions, whether local or international, they wouldn’t be doing what they are doing now!
It’s just that they don’t give a damn!
Just like the government of Myanmar.

He is already under ISA and yet he got charged under Sedition Act. What type of justice is that from our present bunch of scumbag idiots running the government.
What are those components parties lapdogs doing now?
They claim they work for the rakyat. Pooh.. just talk.
When PKR take over, I hope they whacked and kicked all these lapdogs into DBKL garbage trucks.

>> Strange. RPK is standing trial for sedition. That we all know. But he is being detained under ISA for what?.

Sedition is a term of law which refers to covert conduct, such as speech and organization, that is deemed by the legal authority as tending toward insurrection against the established order. Sedition often includes subversion of a constitution and incitement of discontent (or resistance) to lawful authority. Sedition may include any commotion, though not aimed at direct and open violence against the laws. Seditious words in writing are seditious libel.

Sedition in this instance is deemed a risk to national security and stability.