Sabah Progressive Party (SAPP) has dropped a bombshell when its president Yong Teck Lee announced that its two MPs, Dr. Chua Soon Bui (Tawau) and Eric Majimbun (Sepanggar) would move a no-confidence motion against Prime Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi when Parliament resumes on Monday.
But will the bombshell land in Parliament on Monday?
With the ruling coalition commanding unbroken two-thirds parliamentary majority in the 11 general elections since Merdeka in 1957 until the recent political tsunami of the March 2008 general election, there had never been any no confidence motion against the Prime Minister in Malaysian parliamentary history.
The Parliamentary Standing Orders do not have special provision for a no confidence motion.
In the circumstances, a no confidence motion may be regarded as an ordinary motion under Standing Order 27 which requires notice of 14 days to be given – making it impossible for such a no confidence motion to be tabled on Monday, June 23, 2008 as the earliest would be July 2 if the no confidence motion is submitted today.
Standing Order 18 which allows an MP to move a motion to adjourn the House to discuss a definite matter of urgent public importance will be inappropriate and unhelpful as it only allows one hour debate on the specified issue without any vote being taken at the end of the debate.
The only way for a no confidence motion to be tabled and debated on Monday is for the Speaker ito treat it as a substantive and extraordinary motion which should take precedence and priority over all parliamentary business which does not need to comply with the requisite 14-day notice and publishing it as the first item of parliamentary business after Question Time in the Parliamentary Order of Business on Monday.
In doing so, however, the Speaker is likely be in direct loggerheads with the government of the day and must be prepared to pay the consequences of such decision.
I see little possibility of SAPP’s No Confidence Motion against Abdullah as Prime Minister being tabled and debated on Monday unless there is a second political tsunami in the next few days, with waves of support from other Barisan Nasional MPs from Sabah, Sarawak and Peninsula Malaysia making it a credible parliamentary move.
Whether the SAPP no confidence motion is tabled and debated in Parliament on Monday, its very announcement has set off political shock waves in the country confirming the longstanding, widespread and deepseated discontent of the people of Sabah at their unfair treatment by Umno leaders, whether at Federal or State level.

#1 by BoycottLocalPapers on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 4:37 pm
Hope MCA, Gerakan, MIC and other component parties in Sabah and Sarawak will join Pakatan Rakyat. For the sake of Malaysian of all races, LET US ALL ABANDON RACIST UMNO FOR THE BETTER FUTURE OF MALAYSIA!
#2 by Anak_Penang on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 4:43 pm
Which party do you think will form the next government of Malaysia ?
Express your feeling at votingmalaysia.blogspot.com
#3 by NG on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 4:44 pm
HAHA. our PM most frighten nightmare will begin.haha!!!!for the MP of SABAH, show PM you all have the balls.
#4 by max2811 on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 4:45 pm
I don’t think many BN MPs will join PR. It will only give them more bargaining power to ask for more perks and money from AAB. To stay in power, UMNO will rather sell off(gadai) the nation. Though I hope there will be a change of Gov. Just no more UMNO.
#5 by BoycottLocalPapers on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 4:46 pm
MCA, GERAKAN, MIC, Tun Lim Keng Yaik, Tan Sri Koh Tsu Koon, Ong Ka Ting, etc, WHAT SAY YE?
This is not the time to be selfish. Think about your children future in this country.
Dear Tun Lim Keng Yaik, Dato’ Seri Samy Vellu, and Ong Ka Ting,
If you are reading this blog, please support Pakatan Rakyat. The Rakyat will appreciate you and forgive your past misdeeds.
#6 by ch on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 4:50 pm
Dear All,
It does appear that the goodies promised by PM Abdullah for Sabah were not sweet and good enough to prevent the bold move by Yong Teck Lee(YTL). It goes to show that they (Sabah politicians) are riddled with discontentment starting from the refusal of two from UMNO to be appointed as Deputy Ministers and now YTL, who is apparently aghast and behest with the lack of speed from the Federal Government acting on several activities reported. This is a defining moment and unprecedented in our nation’s history where politicians from both ruling and opposition standing against a Prime Minister. But then again we should also remember that PM Abdullah is trying hard to fix something which has been purportedly reported as grossly damaged by the former regime?
Let’s hope for the best by expecting the worse.
#7 by oedipus on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 4:51 pm
uncle lim, im just afraid that it will be tabled (sooner or later), and what if its a political ploy to flush out the rats within the BN and also to force the PR to be at loggerheads with each other?
will DAP be ethical and support the motion? will PKR support the motion also (though i doubt it) or will PAS come out in swinging support of Abdullah Badawi?
either way, the press will pick it up and drum to BNs’ beat if this political chess goes their way! pls be careful uncle lim.
#8 by limkamput on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 4:51 pm
I wish whatever Sabahan MPs and leaders said are true: that the Federal Government has been insensitive, unfair and slow to respond to the needs of ordinary Sabahans. Honestly I am very much in doubt of their sincerity. Sabah has been marginalised and brutalised for more than 30 years and yet successive leaders did nothing but abetted to that marginalisation. By the way, it is led by Yong T L who is no even a MP. What about others, including cabinet ministers? Surely they are slow in coming, although they had been more than 30 years late.
Just be frank. Just say you want your power back at the time when the Federal Government is substantially weakened. Just say this time around you want to use your power for the good of ordinary Sabahans. It sounds less phoney.
#9 by seaturtle on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 4:52 pm
Aiya, no point to bring AAB down… bring BN down la. If AAB step down, then still BN idiot will become PM, what for?? Let AAB be our PM until the whole BN collapse….
#10 by digard on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 4:55 pm
“The Parliamentary Standing Orders do not have special provision for a no confidence motion.”
Interesting. This needs to change; not only for this time and under the circumstances. The Reid-commission has probably overlooked this. I understand that the speaker is and should be allowed to turn down motions deemed irrelevant (that has been abused over time, as we all know).
On the other hand, there are a list of motions out of the ordinary that the speaker must not be entitled to dismiss. Otherwise, he’d be the most powerful person in the country!
If a party represented in the high house is of the opinion that the government or the PM have lost the momentum to govern, there cannot be even a thought of dismissing the motion as ‘secondary’.
Zaid, time for action!
#11 by limkamput on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 4:58 pm
Seaturtle,
Precisely. SAPP may not even be joining PK. It may just be playing political game, supporting another BN candidate as PM and extracting more concession for themselves in the process.
#12 by k1980 on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 5:05 pm
With the billions of ringgit from the cut in petrol subsidies in its war chest, the umno-controlled judiciary may sack the two SAPP MPs, Dr. Chua Soon Bui (Tawau) and Eric Majimbun (Sepanggar) and then hold by-elections. And all MPs considered likely to defect will be sent for special courses in boot camps where the dramatic power of C4 explosives would be displayed to change their minds.
#13 by Anti_NEP on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 5:09 pm
MCA and Gerakan are cowards. They have no balls to go against their master. They are call Umno dogs, remember?
#14 by yin_bak on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 5:14 pm
Agree with Seaturtle. But bear in mind that we shall still continue to suffer with AAB’s stupid, half-cook decision makings if he continues sitting in that ‘chair’!!
#15 by Jeffrey on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 5:29 pm
We’ll have to see next 2 days for further developments/defections if any.
From what YB Kit said, it sounds like SAPP (assuming in conjunction with DSAI) embarked on an amateurish attempt without considering standing orders. If they have not consulted you, it is worse, how come such an ambitious project of voting the government out under the auspices of Pakatan Rakyat or its defacto head can be embarked upon without first consulting strategy co-ordination or standing orders with DAP & DAP’s supremo, LKS?? This really eludes me!
Want to defect – you defect, and number of defections totalling up eventually will, by logic of the situation, dictate the course whether the government will resign & King dissolve parliament for fresh election.
No need for the melo drama of making public an unprecedented call to move a motion of no confidence on PM in Parliament on Monday when one is not sure whether Parliamentary standing orders support it (or that the Speaker will defect along with you)!
You are dealing with a government of 50 years reign that has all the reason in the word to remain in power and thwart your ambitious project and you come unprepared! It is like beating the grass to alert the snake.
What the latest development has precipitated is uncertainty and unpredictability. I am not surprised if BN even imposes emergency rule!
#16 by pkrisnin on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 5:32 pm
This is just SAPP’s way of saying they want more. I suspect most of the goodies went mostly to 1 party. That combine with the MB rotation stopping at UMNO Sabah must have made them angry.
#17 by Godfather on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 5:35 pm
“It is like beating the grass to alert the snake.”
No, it is like beating the grass to flush out the snakes. What happens if some renegades within UMNO like Razaleigh also say that they will vote for the motion ? At this juncture, silence from the BN parties will signify tacit approval of the motion and Badawi should know where he stands even before Monday.
#18 by bennylohstocks on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 5:46 pm
SAPP makes it happen, to others, why wait?
SAPP LEADS OTHERS
#19 by hiro on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 5:49 pm
Well, between now and Monday, a lot of money from Petronas will be used to put out the raging political wildfire :)
#20 by citizenwatch on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 5:51 pm
So when Yong Teck Lee wants PM to step down, is he hoping for Najib to take over? It’s going to be the same old story. Best for SAPP to get out of BN. Unless he is doing a favour for TDM as Yong was under TDM’s leadership before.
#21 by bennylohstocks on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 5:53 pm
(error earlier post)
SAPP makes it happen, why wait?
SAPP LEADS
#22 by voice on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 5:57 pm
They can’t blame the whole thing on Abdullah, it’s UMNO and the cronies beside Abdullah who made the mess, now everyone seems to forget what UMNO did and the “gangs” in the party, while Abdullah has the responsibility, the UMNO party evil spirit must not be forgotten, we wouldn’t want another Mahathir either, and we don’t want UMNO, the racists’ party.
#23 by citizenwatch on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 6:01 pm
From Malaysiakini: A poll placed in Sapp’s blog indicated the general feelings on the ground at the moment. The poll asked members of the public whether the party should stay on in BN, leave the coalition but remain independent, or join Pakatan.
At press time, there were 2,052 votes tallied, with 85 percent (1,749 votes) asking Sapp to join Pakatan. Another 242 (11 percent) want the party to leave BN and remain independent. Only 2 percent (61 votes) urged it to stay on with BN.
#24 by Godfather on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 6:08 pm
If Najib has any b@lls, he should call on his boss to resign now. Then he should promise the rakyat that all grievances will be looked into, the judiciary will be reformed, the ACA will report to parliament, the AG’s Chambers will report to a prosecutions committee, the recommendations of the IPCMC will be implemented, the country’s finances will be run transparently, there will be competitive tenders for all projects with all tenders being evaluated by external consultants.
That way, BN will continue to rule the federal government, but then I guess it is just wishful thinking…..
#25 by k1980 on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 6:15 pm
Tawau MP Datuk Chua Soon Bui said that the party had lost confidence in the PM’s leadership. She then read out a statement which listed the reasons why SAPP would support motion of no confidence against Abdullah.
• No concrete action had been taken on the issue of illegal immigrants despite repeated requests by SAPP and other BN parties.
• No holistic economic solutions had been offered by the government to cushion sudden increase in petrol prices which had burdened the public.
• Not enough attention had been paid to issues raised by the people of Sabah including corruption, poor development.
• People have lost confidence in Abdullah and if he cannot perform, he should step aside and make way for another leader.
http://themalaysianinsider.com/index.php/home/42-lead-stories/643-huge-blow-to-abdullahs-leadership
#26 by vchi on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 6:16 pm
Whatever the circumstance, this is crunch time for Pakatan. Any misstep now will cause a massive public erosion of confidence.
I hope all Pakatan parties will stand united or Malaysians will lose confidence in Pakatan’s ability to govern.
Proceed carefully!
#27 by sonsofsabah on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 6:21 pm
First of all, take a deep breath and look at what is going on. I think it is a wise move by SAPP to both test the political water, and at the same time announce to sabahans that they are indeed the only party to champion Sabah’s interest!
SAPP should stay independent and contest all MP seats in the next election. PM has not been listening to what sabahans feel sacred. I think Anwar suffered worst than PM regarding this issue.
They should also consider forming another block with both Sabah and Sarawak, and rival BN and PR. After all, there is no guarantee PR will treat Sabah and Sarawak any better than BN.
#28 by hiro on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 6:21 pm
Uncle Lim, could you be so kind as to make available a copy of our Parliamentary Standing Orders on DAP website please? I’ve googled and wikied and can’t find one. Comparatively, Singapore Parliament Standing Orders are available on the Spore Parliament website. Thanks. By knowing the standing orders, Malaysians could contribute ideas as to how to get around BN placed procedural restrictions. Thanks.
#29 by yhsiew on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 6:48 pm
I hope the no-confidence motion will succeed and trigger the start of an “UMNO meltdown”.
#30 by Xiao He on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 6:53 pm
We shall see what will happen in the next few days..
#31 by ShiokGuy on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 7:02 pm
Calling the Speaker from Sabah!
Dear Speaker Sir, this is the time for redemption for Sabah and Sarawak! I will watch on TV if it is broadcast life that you are doing a job for the people. Speaker Sir, it is time for us to rise for the occasion.
You action or inaction will affect your credibility as representative of Sabah and Sarawak!
On another issue in the star today, I am happy to hear about Selangor MB’s action to take back if possible those concession on basic need of people, like water.
I have been “bashing” Syabas in my blog since i started blogging 2 months back.. can read about Syabas bashing here..
http://shiokguy.blogspot.com/2008/06/no-more-syabas.html
I will dig more….
Shiok Guy
#32 by mybangsamalaysia on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 7:05 pm
LETUP UMNO!!!!
#33 by pai on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 7:12 pm
Mr. Yong Teck Lee,
While you’re making noises about walking out of BN,
Dr Chong Eng Leong had fired the first shot! By walking out of PBS for its failure to stand up to UMNO’s tacit support for PTI with Project I.C.
Well done, Dr. Chong! Hopefully your courageous act will trigger a political domino effect in Sabah!
#34 by Mr Smith on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 7:23 pm
There is one snag though! Say the vote of confidence is allowed and Abdullah loses the vote, with some UMNO MPs voting with the Opposition. But this may not guarantee a victory for Pakatan.
The King might even call one amongst, namely Razaleigh or Najib to form a government since BN has the majority in Parliament. And they might well succeed.
Pakatan is revealing all its trump cards. How can it win?
#35 by Godfather on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 7:25 pm
How can anyone in the right mind expect UMNO to survive ?
Two weeks after increasing fuel prices by over 40 pct, they announced billions in new projects and grants to Sabah and Sarawak. Then they announce a miserable 10 pct cut in the cabinet allowances.
Quietly, they gave 1,200 APs to an UMNO putera guy (and a KJ crony) to import hybrid cars. At RM 30,000 per AP, this guy and his partners stand to make RM 36 million. Presumably, the APs will be replenished yearly.
What sort of government is this ? Getting the fat lady out is simply the means to give control of APs to someone else in UMNO. They obviously think that we are all stupid.
#36 by Godfather on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 7:31 pm
Limkamput:
PR may not be perfect, with warts and all, but they are our only hope. Unlike you, I am not going to wait around for the stealing to go on for a few more years.
#37 by Jeffrey on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 7:40 pm
Will there be a political domino effect? This is not certain. Now I am not even certain of the PR’s defacto head (DSAI)’s leadership that he could pull it through to bring others to follow SAPP’s step.
There are two reasons for this.
First, I am aghast that when SAPP made announcement for vote of no confidence on PM on Monday, Kit has said that there is no parliamentary standing order providing for it to be done, which suggests to me that this major project to dislodge the BN government has been undertaken by DSAI without proper consultation with DAP’s top leaders or else SAPP would not have opened its cards on something that this thread says is subject to procedural limitation. A notice of 14 days can change everything. During such a time anything can happen. SAPP can change its mind; PAS can join UMNO and even BN can invoke emergency rule. What kind of planning is this???
Second, when DSAI is supposedly on verge of initiating a take over of government starting with SAPP’s announcement today, PAS Youth, unrestrained by PAS top leadership could throw a spanner in the works by presenting, at this very critical juncture, a memorandum to Selangor Mentri Besar’s Office to protest and demonstrate against performance of rock queen Ella and Dangdut singer MAS Idayu on July 6th, heedless it would alienate non Malays and moderate Malay PR supporters at the time when unity is important before the take over!
What does that suggest?
It suggests that even PAS have not been properly consulted and coordinated in the big move scheduled on Monday.
The fact that PKR and Selangor did and said nothing against PAS memorandum suggests that they don’t care about the image and voice of the DAP state assembly men in the Selangor State Government or that they want to prioritize appeasing PAS and overlook its excesses.
More important for YB Kit not to be consulted in a major initiative to be launched on Monday (if he had, surely this matter of standing order would not be raised in this thread) it reflects that DAP is of no great standing in Pakatan Rakyat’s scheme of things as run by Anwar which makes DAP’s supporters wonder whether they will really be better off under the new regime led by Anwar appeasing PAS, and not consulting DAP and that tolerating the BN to carry on might not actually be the lesser of the two evils!
#38 by rainbowseahorse on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 7:44 pm
Hmmm, looks like Yong has started a fire to send his smoke signal to the PM!
Reading that Yong cunning and manipulative mind, this is most probably what’s going though his grand schemes :
Step One: Assess Federal UMNO weakness. Ask for Ministerial posts. If unsuccessful go to step Two.
Step Two: Agree to meet with Opposition parties..none committal on joining..let everybody knows of meeting. Wait for Federal BN to make “counter offers” to assumed Opposition “offers”. If no suitable Federal UMNO counter offers forthcoming or counter offers not acceptable/sufficient, go to Step Three.
Step Three: Pass on rumors that Sabah BN component parties planning to leave BN due to serious issues not being tackle by Federal BN (i.e. like illegal migrants, etc.). Make it like Sabah BN have people’s best interest at heart of issues to garner support from ignorant Malaysians. Again wait for any or more counter offers from Opposition Parties and Federal UMNO. If still no acceptable/sufficient offers from both parties go to Step Four.
Step Four:Circulate rumor of a definite date that BN Sabah is going to leave BN, but not definitely joining Opposition parties, maybe as Independent Party. This leaves door wide open for both Federal UMNO and Opposition Parties to make acceptable/sufficient offers.
Step Five:Wait and see what Federal UMNO or Opposition has to or can offers. If still no positive & lucrative offers forth coming from Federal UMNO, start fire & send smoke signal.
#39 by wesuffer on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 7:50 pm
i dont agree MCA, MIC AND GERAKAN joining PR. becauce those party were corrupted component party in BN. The leaders is thinking their next generation childrens that why eat so many rakyat money now. Anyone know sami vellu belonged two hill in hulu langat there ? he planing join venture with foreign investor to build casino there! if selangor still under BN goverment, think they started building now
#40 by AhPek on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 7:57 pm
Do you mean this,Jeffrey….”Tolerating BN to carry on might actually be the lesser of the two evils.” and not “Tolerating BN to carry on might not actually be the lesser of the two evils.” which is what is in your post.
#41 by Cookie Monster on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 8:10 pm
so many yrs already wat had sabah component parties done for ordinary sabahans? Illegal immigrants , high cost of living , unstandardize price diff of essential items we east malaysians (EM) pay more compared to counterpart in west malaysia , federal leaders take away 95% of east malaysia’s oil revenue , so tis yearly 95% of revenue where had it gone to ? building twin towers ? KLIA ? NS Highway ? MSC ? LRT ? Putra Jaya (new parliament Hse) , F1 circuit , grand stadium for tat world youth cup which malaysia organize? y all west malaysia had these good things , wherelse EM dun have ?? jia lat lor…..EM actually pay for WM’s development……..haizzzzzz
#42 by dawsheng on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 8:17 pm
I think SAPP should just cut the crap, get a divorce immediately, move out and get a new bed.
#43 by Jameswong on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 8:22 pm
we can discuss any thing on what we think, but the poll in the SAPP web shows:
Stay on with BN 143 (3%)
Leave BN & Non-aligned 481 (10%)
Leave BN & Join Pakatan 3818 (85%)
this will shock BN’s stubborn heads that how much people hate them if they still stay at what they are now.
#44 by bennylohstocks on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 8:34 pm
Oh, what a…
A FROGGY MORN’
#45 by penang308 on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 8:37 pm
Bravo SAPP!
This is just the beginning, I don’t expect those Penisular base parties like MCA, MIC, Gerakan, PPP etc to support the motion on monday in parlimet.
The ball is now in other Sabah base BN parties to decide the fate of BN. We in Penisular already shows you the way, it is up to you to follow!
Sabah and Sarawak are riches in natural resources but what did you get in return? Where is your highway? Where is your rail services?
In Penang, there are so many Sarawakian working in Advertise Hospital! Why is this happening?
It is time for you guys to say “JOM UBAH”!
#46 by ktteokt on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 8:46 pm
After what AAB did in the last 100 days, this is the expected result!
#47 by PSM on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 8:53 pm
Let’s be very careful!
If it’s to make the PR the next Federal Government, by all means go for it!
However, if it’s to get rid of Pak Lah, well…what will happen if Pak Lah goes is that Rosmah Mansor will be PM!!!!!
If that happens, God help us for Malaysia will be entering into another “Dark Period”!!!!!
#48 by caishen on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 8:59 pm
Extract from the Star.
” PM says SAPP leader acted out of ‘personal greed’
PUTRAJAYA: Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi says Sabah Progressive Party (SAPP) President Datuk Yong Teck Lee’s latest action has been due to the fact that “I have not been able to satisfy his personal greed.”
Abdullah did not elaborate. However, his aides told Bernama that the Prime Minister would elaborate at a later date.
Yong declared in Kota Kinabalu Wednesday that his party had lost confidence in Abdullah”……..
Salute to Sdr.LKS and DSAI..
their strategies of disintegrate the BN parties is working.
tearing 10% of the representatives in BN…
Whether SAPP is joining PAKATAN is irrevelant now….
BN is on the verse of collapsing….
#49 by katdog on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 9:00 pm
Is SAPP truly leading the way or merely taking opportunity of the situation?
Why would they need to make such an open declaration? Is it to encourage other BN MP’s to defect or merely to garner more favours for itself?
Only time will tell.
#50 by robert wong on Wednesday, 18 June 2008 - 9:04 pm
The SAPP moves is a wake up call to all BN govt. and PR alike . The plight of SABAHAN AND SARAWAKIAN has reached a critical point. All this while Sabah and Sarawak has been left out from the main stream of development. It’s a lesson to be learned for PR as well !!!