Najib apology on demolition of Hindu temple on Deepavali eve – six more apologies by Umno/MIC leaders awaited


The front-page headline of the night edition of China Press is “Najib apology – demolition of Hindu temple on Deepavali eve”.

This is a manifestation of Makkal Sakti (People’s Power) but it is a grave error for the Barisan Nasional and MIC leadership to think that such an apology is acceptable or satisfactory answer to the Malaysian Indian political awakening and uprising following the seminal 30,000-people Hindraf protest in Kuala Lumpur on Nov. 25 last year.

If Najib and the top Umno leadership are serious in wanting to making amends for the long-standing political, economic, educational, social, cultural religious polarization of the Malaysian Indians resulting in their becoming the new underclass in the country, Najib’s apology must be followed by at least six other apologies and ensuing actions, such as:

• Apology by Selangor Mentri Besar, Datuk Seri Khir Toyo as the No. 1 man in the Selangor state government who must bear full responsibility for the demolition of the Hindu temple in Shah Alam on Deepavali eve;

• Apology by the Prime Minister, Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi for Umno insensitivity in holding the Umno General Assembly last year on the day of Deepavali – when it would be regarded as highly insensitive and offensive if MIC, MCA or Gerakan had held their national delegates meeting on Hari Raya Aidilfitri for instance.

• Apology by the Umno Youth deputy chief, Khairy Jamaluddin, the Prime Minister’s son-in-law in publicly castigating the Indian news vendors for “anti-national” actions in having a press holiday when the Umno general assembly was being held resulting in the policy speech of the Prime Minister and Umno President at the Umno general assembly not given coverage the next day – when it was the fault of Umno in fixing its general assembly on Deepevali, long a press holiday.

• Apology by MIC President and sole Indian Cabinet Minister for over 28 years in refusing to admit the fact of the marginalization of the Malaysian Indians – a stand which he reiterated during his recent visit to India;

• Apology by Abdullah for the detention of the five Hindraf leaders under the Internal Security Act for fighting the cause to end the marginalization of the Malaysian Indians – and the five should be released immediately and unconditionally.

• Apology by Samy Vellu for the 20-year-long Maika Telekom Shares hijacking scandal in betraying the rights and interests of Malaysian Indians who had put their trust in him by placing their life-savings in Maika shares.

Are these six apologies from the UMNO and MIC leaders forthcoming to demonstrate that there is now a genuine change of heart in the top Umno leadership to meaningfully end the marginalization of the Malaysian Indians in the country?

(Speech at the DAP ceramah in Buntong, (Ipoh Barat) on Sunday, 3rd February 2008 at 10 pm)

Print Friendly

  1. #1 by jus legitimum on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 12:09 am

    As a Chinese saying goes:”Just look at the mouth and the face of that nasty fellow,your hatred has already become so uncontrollable.”Thinking back,not so long ago,peaceful demonstrators were ill treated with water cannons and tear gas.Irreparable damage has been severely done.Isn’t it too late to undo it?Use your votes to teach the hypocrites a lesson now.

  2. #2 by Colonel on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 12:16 am

    Is Najib about to create another layer of privileged Malaysians? The Indiaputras? What happens to the Chinese? I thought we are all equal before the law?

  3. #3 by kaybeegee on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 12:50 am

    Know of some muslim converts who were Hindus before marriage to Muslim women. In name Muslim. Still practise Hinduism. Despite having “bin Abdullah”to replace their biological father’s name these converts or Indian Muslims as we call them, are outraged looking at the destruction of Hindu temples. These new Indian Muslims still feel for their Hindu temples!
    UMNO going to apologise for destruction of temples? Forced conversion or dubious conversions to Islam?
    HINDRAF stood for Hindu rights. Indians could be Hindus, Muslims, Christians, atheists, Buddhists, Jains Bahais.
    Is UMNO going to apologise for arresting the 5 Hindraf leaders? UMNO going to apologise that Ghani Patail their Attorney general will not take the Atlantuya prosecution nor assist the Royal Commission in the VK Lingam episode but takes straight forward cases involving so called unlawful assembly. Is UMNO going to apologise that Tun Haniff the ex IGP said 40% of senior cops corrupt? Is UMNO going to apologise that the ACA like Admiral Cheng Ho is/are eunuch(s) UMNO should apologise that they still prefer to use English and local councils whack traders for not using Malay. UMNO should apologise to all Malayans and now all Malaysians for their (UMNO’s) existence. After creation of Malaysia UMNO is redundant, no more can they say they fought for independence of Malaysia.

  4. #4 by ihavesomethingtosay on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 12:59 am

    “Najib apology on demolition of Hindu temple on Deepavali eve – six more apologies by Umno/MIC leaders awaited”

    Why apologies? do you only learned that this is a gross improper act after 50years of nation building or you’re a dying tyrant trying to make atonement for your sins???

    tak malu ke?

    easier to jump off the KL tower.

  5. #5 by kaybeegee on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 1:19 am

    By the way anybody agree with me that for polytheistic Hindusim, the Rukunnegara is anti Hinduism. Should be kepercayaan kepada Tuhan Tuhan for Hindus. Muruga

  6. #6 by limkamput on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 1:31 am

    Colonel Says: It is harder to apologize and easier to step down.

    See, again you can not get the right sentiment. To BN and you, it is easier to apologise and much harder to step down, get it?

  7. #7 by dawsheng on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 1:38 am

    Why did Najib apologize, did Abdullah ask him to? If BN really wants to win back Indian votes, isn’t it suppose to be Abdullah who apologize first and then follow by the rest? If the apology by Najib was his own initiative isn’t that telling something is amiss in the BN camp? Will there be a change of leadership in UMNO and BN before the general election?

  8. #8 by dawsheng on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 1:44 am

    Whatever it is, Malaysians irregardless of race, language and religion should not have a Prime Minister who once declared that he will soaks the Keris with Chinese Blood. Well, you can change your mind if he apologize for that too.

  9. #9 by LadyGodiva on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 1:55 am

    What Colonel must have meant was it would be easier for Najib to step down! That should be simple for you to understand.

  10. #10 by scorpian6666 on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 2:13 am

    “Najib apology on demolition of Hindu temple on Deepavali eve”

    Was he sorry for the Demolition of Hindu temple or was he sorry they did it on Deepavali eve !!

    Najib…You can fool all of them.

    Oh Najib, Najib… prove that you are truly sorry by rebuilding a BIGGER Temple on the same spot.

  11. #11 by SIMPLYJUSTICE on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 3:28 am

    ” THE APOLOGY SHOULD FOLLOW THE REBUILDING THE TEMPLE BUT IT DID NOT! “.

    HOWEVER, THE MIC DELEGATES CLAPPED FOR THE APOLOGY BUT NO ONE ASKED WHETHER THE TEMPLE WILL BE REBUILD.

    BN HAS MORE TO LEARN AND MIC HAS MORE TO LOOSE.

  12. #12 by undergrad2 on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 3:57 am

    Limkamput, if you stop twisting what Colonel wrote, you’d understand the message. The message is loud and clear i.e. it’d be easier for Najib to step down. But he’s not. He’s instead apologizing.

  13. #13 by oct on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 6:46 am

    As Rambo said ‘Die for something or live for nothing’. We shall amend as ‘VOTE FOR THE CHANGE OR LIVE FOR NOTHING’

  14. #14 by cemerlang on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 7:32 am

    I am sorry to say that there are too many people out there saying sorry not because they are sorry but because they feel guilty and they cannot say the kind of words that they should say.

  15. #15 by jus legitimum on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 7:45 am

    Why suddenly from ‘saya pantang dicabar’;'certain community will run amok’ is changed to ‘say sorry’ and ‘all communities will be taken care of’? Isn’t it shedding air mata buaya ke?

  16. #16 by Bigjoe on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 8:57 am

    Thank you for all the list of apologies that BN owes. The list is long and I started with May 13, 1969 because this was Badawi’s greatest mistake when he took over the leadership when he said there was no need for a new vision. This coutry did and does need a new vision.

    This country has been on the same vision since 1969, Vision 2020 and Dr. M’s ideas did not begin with him, it just cluminated with him. It all begin when they lied in 1969 – that of ends-justify-the means and the hijacking of the national agenda by ultra-right in UMNO. It includes the likes of Harun Idris, Syed Jafar. Step-by-step they destroyed institutions, wasted resources, commit illegality and injustices and set this country in path unknown in the name of their self-righteousness.

    The Lingam-video affair gives a good insight of what the vision that started in 1969 looks like. You have the highest powers committing acts that breaches the very basic rules of good governance. Its not likely that there is only one V.K. Lingam. In every neigbourhood you can identify someone who does what V.K. Lingam does to one degree or other and in some neigbourhoods like Damansara, Taman Tun Ismail, Titiwangsa, Ampang etc. you see many more. The problems are systematic.

    This is why the RCI on Lingam-video had to be tempered and the Bar Council call for judicial RCI denied. It rocks the very foundation of UMNO if it was unfettered. Already it may be unavoidable. It all depends on the Bar Council and the public will react to the eventual coverup that will take place to some degree at least.

    We have a peek of the destruction of institutional governance for the last nearly 38 years and the result is evident to us all that Hindraf has just dramatised . This country can never come together to repair the damages until the day we are willing to admit the source of it all May 13, 1969.

  17. #17 by KanNinNeh on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 9:02 am

    Can U rape the girl already then say sorry !

  18. #18 by dawsheng on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 9:15 am

    Will Najib wait for Abdullah to hand over the Prime Minister position? With all the mega corridors Abdullah plans, it looks like it is going to be forever before Malaysia sees a new Prime Minister, is Najib willing to wait or it is worth the wait, don’t you think Najib at least deserves an extra position as the Finance Minister? Come to think of it, if Mahathir when he was the Prime Minister can appoint Anwar as Finance Minister, why can Abdullah do the same thing? Yep, things are about to get very nasty within UMNO.

  19. #19 by akarmalaysian on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 9:16 am

    kanninneh…this blood sucking government has been raping off billions of ringgit over the past decades fr the people of this country….do u ever see anyone of them saying sorry?

  20. #20 by BlackEye on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 9:23 am

    “Can U rape the girl already then say sorry !”

    Don’t know about that but you certainly do not need her consent.

  21. #21 by scorpian6666 on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 9:41 am

    C’mon People

    naJIh is not sorry for the demolition of Hindu temple!
    He is sorry they did it on Deepavali eve !

  22. #22 by helpless on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 11:22 am

    YB,

    Is those Indian buy your comment?

    Sometime result is more convincing.

    There are possible views from the people of the corruption during GE campaign.

    …more chinese school will be built…. BN is good for the people
    …apology to Indian….. BN has realise the mistake
    …visit to chinese community…. BN is fair to all
    …more police station…… BN is concern on crime

    My guess is 5 detained under ISA will be reliease one week before election.

    It is to good to believe this good deed will continue….

    But the fact is we can only hear about it during GE campaign.

    The opposition party need better strategy to enlighten the people.

    Where is the money came from for all BN campaign? BN has use the advantage of the position to ‘cheat ‘ the people.

    The development has to be paid by taxpayer whether it is from public servant or private individual. It is from all company pay the taxes and Petronas. Increase high way toll rate to cover the corruption.

  23. #23 by scorpian6666 on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 12:20 pm

    “The opposition party need better strategy to enlighten the people.”

    Damn Wrong..helpless
    You don’t need enlightenment when someone demolish your temple !

    You and I and everybody else know damn well, the Malay Population hold the “key”

    The Opposition party has done one hell of a good job… not forgetting the people themselves …..the Hindraf and the bersih.

    What better strategy ?
    Better economical plan ? Better NEP for the Malays ? Convert every non Malay to Muslim ?

    I can’t figure any … maybe you could .. so let’s hear it

  24. #24 by dawsheng on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 12:38 pm

    The question, was Najib’s apology represents Abdullah, and can be taken as apology from the BN government as whole, if not Najib has taken things into his own hand. He is painting Abdullah in the bad light.

  25. #25 by dawsheng on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 12:39 pm

    My comment is awaiting moderation, again???

  26. #26 by sheriff singh on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 2:00 pm

    You naughty boy, but Mr Lim and his minders are very sensitive these days.

    You said what I said at the top.

  27. #27 by iyamwhoiyam on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 2:04 pm

    mine too…..on the other page at least

  28. #28 by cheng on soo on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 3:39 pm

    One of most important apologies from this Naji. is what he says in 1987, to soak keris with Msia Ch…’s blood. somebody should put this in world wide web, to the whole world

  29. #29 by Godson on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 4:12 pm

    Heard from my indian friends in Sarawak…..they were laughing at the apology. Everybody knows this nuts will do something like that coz its election time. Maybe our 5 heros will be release soon coz its election time. Sweet talk here and there or rather bulls__t here and bulls__t there.

    Demolished our temple!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    This time BN you are going down one by one.
    Your time is up to pay the price.
    Dont be over confident that you will win this time.
    Pack up, go home and think of what you have done to us for 50 years. Maybe you BN are too lazy to think. Better go to sleep.

    ENOUGH IS ENOUGH.
    VOTE FOR OPPOSITION.
    GOD BLESS DAP.

    THANK GOD FOR THE INTERNET.

  30. #30 by rajanjohn on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 4:54 pm

    Apology is just a word to be uttered! Wats so difficult for SV&Co..SV kan top actor once upon a time..!He full of drama..one of these days he might even weep like a baby while campaigning..don’t be surprise.. I’m sure old habits die hard!
    They can do wonder as well but…all b4 election maaaa….after that u see la..they might bomb all worship places of NON-MULSLIMS..then show you the “Keris,Samurai,Parang,M16,AK47,C4 and wat not!

    Just ignore this ppl is the best…don’t take part in any of this ppl campaign or listen to their EMPTY promises..!

    we should look upon DAP.. for a real change..

  31. #31 by rajanjohn on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 4:56 pm

    Apology is just a word to be uttered! Wats so difficult for SV&Co..SV kan top actor once upon a time..!He full of drama..one of these days he might even weep like a baby while campaigning..don’t be surprise.. I’m sure old habits die hard!
    They can do wonder as well but…all b4 election maaaa….after that u see la..they might bomb all worship places of NON-MULSLIMS..then show you the “Keris,Samurai,Parang,M16,AK47,C1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9, and wat not!

    Just ignore this ppl is the best…don’t take part in any of this ppl campaign or listen to their EMPTY promises..!

    we should look upon DAP.. for a real change..

  32. #32 by prelude3372 on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 5:54 pm

    Can YB highlight is we can find out how many new voters registered after the 25th Nov`07? Would those new registered would be eligble to vote for this GE? How many % of them are Indians?

  33. #33 by prelude3372 on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 5:55 pm

    Oppss….suppose to be in the other posting

  34. #34 by alaneth on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 10:00 pm

    In my opinion Khir Toyo is extreme in his thoughts – imagine :

    During his reign – what has Selangor achieved, which is by his effort??? None. All development is due to the KL/Putrajaya effect.

    But what extreme laws & things he has done???
    - Limiting beer ads in Selangor to 1/3 of signboard area.
    - Supporting Selayang Municipal Council on cruel dog-catching method
    - No live performances by international artists (All went to KL)
    - Make dog licencing almost impossible in Shah Alam & MPSJ.
    - No new year celebrations in Shah Alam (Shah Alam city only reflects & portray Malay-Muslim architecture, all these built by taxpayers money).
    - Loudest voice in banning pig rearing in Semenyih
    - Many pro-Islamic extreme policies.

    Ever see him visiting a Chinese/Indian cultural event? or visiting a Chinese/Tamil school?

    He will never apologise. Let us all bring his BN reign to an end – support PKR & DAP in Selangor. This time I believe the Selangor Chinese & Indians will be wise & much wiser to bring down BN rule.

    Don’t give BN a 2/3 majority in Selangor! Vote DAP/PKR !

  35. #35 by alaneth on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 10:03 pm

    Najib will not even apoligise if not for this coming General Election!!!

  36. #36 by damianyeow on Tuesday, 5 February 2008 - 11:39 pm

    If u study Najip’s facial expression & body language, who can tell me if he’s truly sincere & remorseful over the temple-demolition issue? His face says it all & speaks a thousand words.That is the most insincere apology I have ever seen, he even look disgusted to even have to attend that ‘gathering’, must be forced to do so by Pak-helah, and can u see that slight grin he displayed, priceless, it must be ‘etched’ permanently on his face for trying so hard. So what mis-guided MIC crowd should have waited for the follow-up declaration by PM’s Thaipusam holiday for KL/FT, should be this time, ” Saya umumkan secara rasmi, Malaysia mulai hari ini mempunyai 5 ugama rasmi- Islam, Buddha, Hindu, Kristian, Sikhism”
    & written into the Rukun-Negara. That would be meaningful & genuine ‘gesture’ to show, Mr. Najip, that u’re truly remorseful & want to repent, & to make-up for all the discriminatory policies that your party UMNO have brought upon us. What harm can it do? No, he or anyone from Umno will do no such thing, you want to know why? Because the discriminatory policies to sideline all other race & religion will continue, u better believe it, if not prove me wrong, make this simple declaration, ‘BN sangat adil’ right?
    one of DAP slogans should be “5 official religion to chose from” if there is no freedom of choice then don’t call this country a Democracy.

  37. #37 by ktteokt on Wednesday, 6 February 2008 - 9:51 pm

    Democracy might as well be pronounced “dead and buried” in Malaysia. If you remember what happen to Namewee’s case, you will know what I mean. He just sang a song using the national anthem as “background” music and there he was penalized. They even brought in the National Anthem Act! So what democracy are they talking about when the people cannot even have the freedom of expression and speech? And with ISA still active, how can one enjoy democracy in this purportedly “democratic” country? The slightest political “breeze” would bring about an “Operasi Lalang”!

    And don’t ever talk about the Rukunegara. It is a national disgrace for the contents of this “holy document” were never realized from the day of its inception. What “masyarakat yang adil” are they talking about if they want to maintain the NEP, Ketuanan Melayu and Malay special rights? Can that be made adil? It is like slapping their own face with this “holy document” and they had the guts to send our “space tourist” to outer space to read it. To me, the Rukunegara is nothing but a tattered piece of paper fit for wiping asses!

  38. #38 by tunglang on Saturday, 9 February 2008 - 2:13 am

    “Najib apology – demolition of Hindu temple on Deepavali eve”.
    Done with a pinch of salt! Well Malaysian Indians, are you that palcable with just an apology? Not that simple matter, Najib.
    Election is around the corner, that’s why he shamefully APOLOGISE!
    Why not go to the Indian temples and apologise. That can make alot of difference! And in future, do it every time an Indian temple is demolish. More are needed to prove BN sincererity, Najib, PM, Khairy, Toyol, Samy?

  39. #39 by kalai on Friday, 22 February 2008 - 2:47 pm

    Well, this just proved that BN will do or say anything to get the public to vote for them..perhaps, they have taken the public to be either too stupid or gullible to fall for an apology..It’ just like repairing roads full of potholes or sanctioning projects that have been delayed for years to get the public’s approval especially near election…why don’t he just build a new temple or allocate a new plot for it to show how sincere he is with that apology..that is not going to happen in another 1000 years if BN is still up there as the government…..so, people, as the election song goes, berfikirlah sebelum mengundi, jangan dengar cakap orang, terutamanya yang baru meminta maaf…

You must be logged in to post a comment.