If the Malays can enter local Universities by competing with other races, then it’s okay for Malays to become rich.

If the Malays ‘birth rights’ are taken away by abolishing the NEP and allow other races to compete in the economy equally, then it’s okay for Malays to become rich.

If the government contracts are open to all races by means of competition and allowing all business owners ( of all races) to bid for the tenders, then it’s okay for Malays to become rich.

When the three important aspects above are still practiced by the Government to help the Malays, why on earth should I be happy with Malays becoming rich? Shamshul, perhaps you are enjoying the privileges given to Malays in Malaysia. Put yourself in the life of an Indian or Chinese who have been discriminated by not getting a place in the local university, unable to compete fairly in business, and many other ways the other races are being discriminated. If you are the other race who was discriminated, would you then be angry when you see Malays enjoying all aspects of life when you can’t even get to educate yourself? When Malays can enter the University with their scrappy results, why is the Government bargaining with non Malay students who obtained all A’s by not giving them Medical seats? The government and all Malays who are enjoying these priveleges at the expense of other races suffering is truly a pathethic situation.

Finally, I wonder why Malays pray 5 times a day, when in reality, they don’t live up to God’s expectation. Does God allow people to take away anothers rice bowl, anothers rights to be educated? I wonder how so many Malays sleep peacefully and with conscious at night. By saying all these, I’m not saying that you belong to that category. All I can say to you is , ‘Tepuk Dada, tanyalah selera’.

God bless Malaysia.

I refer to your response to Mr Anbar. You wrote ” Perhaps he should be …..”. Exactly that is my point. Why on earth Hindraf claimed on etnic cleansing?. And why accused Govt( meaning UMNO led) of sanctioning killing of Indians?

Why Hindraf lied? Why ? Call a spade a spade they say. Exactly Hindraf accused Malaysian Govt of conducting etnic cleansing in the same league with that Serbians did to Bosnians.

Nobody is denying Uthaya’s right in promoting the interests f Indians. But why must he lie?. Are you saying it is OK to spread lies on Malays in order to promote the interests of Indians?. Why must malays, UMNO, Islam be insulted in the process.

Are you saying it is OK Hindraf to lie in order to draw attention to its flight. What is the point of holding potrait of Mahatma Gandhi but not following his teaching. So nice of you , Anba to absolve Hindraf on its “fitnah” by creating another definition of “etnic cleansing ala Malaysia”.

What about Malays. Do not they have the right not to be accused of etnic cleansing. Does a race that choose to allow Indian politicians to win in Malay majority areas practises etnic cleansing?

Who is playing with racial issue actually?. Who is so creative in ridiculing Moslem women wearing tudung with a “rap” on “Negarakuku”. Who is actually feeding fear on Chinese Community on Sekolah Wawasan as a “ploy” to eliminate vernacular schools.

Who is feeding hatred by not telling the truth that the said demolished temple actually sat on a private land? Who is actually playing with racial issue by keeping to remind Chinese community on a closure of a Chinese school in Damansara( actually relocated not closed).

Who is actually tend to close private sectors to non Chinese by insisting on Mandarin requirement. Who is actually crying out loud about “ketuanan Melayu” but keeping quiet on “Ketuanan Cina” in economy.

And Mr Anba, what is wrong on Malays becoming rich. Malays also use their brain in order to succeed in life. Perhaps you are not aware of Muslim billionaires building schools in kedah, Melaka. Is that is the way you reason, I can also crying out loud to accuse rich Indians of not helping poor Indians.

Greed is a universal plague. No race is immune to it. And do read my remarks carefully. I did not accuse Chinese and Indians of playing with racial issue. Similarly, if you do not like Hishamuddin, please do not lump all Malays as “spineless”.

It is obvious that Shamshul’s verbal skills are not anywhere near the best in this blog when he said:

“….everybody knows Hindraf lied about etnic cleansing.” Shamshul Anuar

Perhaps he should have said it a different way, more selective in the choice of words and more sensitive to those who feel passionately about the issues - like yourself.

Uthayar’s intention is obvious and something he admitted i.e. to draw world attention to a problem long suffered by his community who has been economically marginalized. There can be no dispute to that.

On your allegation that Hindraf’s claim of ethnic cleansing is a lie. First, it was Uthaya who mentioned about this, but now you are claiming that Hindraf mentioned it. If Uthaya’s words can be concluded to be Hindfar’s claim, then can a Malay father’s racist remark be considered the remarks that comes from Muslims in general. Do you understand my analogy?

There are many definitions for ethnic cleansing. Uthaya had used the narrower definition of systematically, illegally involving gross human right abuses.( see definition below)
Here is a possible definition of ethnic cleansing, according to Drazen Petrovic, as appeared in Wikipedia :
Drazen Petrovic has distinguished between broad and narrow definitions. Broader definitions focus on the fact of expulsion based on ethnic criteria, while narrower definitions include additional criteria: for example, that expulsions are systematic, illegal, involve gross human-rights abuses, or are connected with an ongoing internal or international war. According to Petrovic:

[E]thnic cleansing is a well-defined policy of a particular group of persons to systematically eliminate another group from a given territory on the basis of religious, ethnic or national origin. Such a policy involves violence and is very often connected with military operations. It is to be achieved by all possible means, from discrimination to extermination, and entails violations of human rights and international humanitarian law.”[3]
Reference [3] : “Ethnic Cleansing - An Attempt at Methodology” p.11.
Nevertheless, Uthaya mentioned that the ethnic cleansing is an ethnic cleansing ala Malaysia. That means an ethnic cleansing a unique Malaysian style.
You mentioned “poverty cuts across racial boundary”. Well you are right, and whats true is also that the Malays have all the avenue to get help when they need it. If a Malay is still poor in Malaysia today, it simply means that the richer Malays are not willing to redistribute their wealth to poorer Malays. Thanks to Dr.Mahathir and shame to the rich Malays who simply became greedy upon accumulating wealth.

You mentioned that the Malay’s preoccupation as :” The preoccupation of Malays right now is how dangerous a situation when people play with racial issue, hiding under mantra “freedom expression”. Who is playing with racial issue, and which race is hiding under the mantra “freedom expression”? If you are saying that other races ( other than Malay race) are hiding under the mantra “freedom expression”, you are spineless like Hishamuddin. Do you know that the Malay race is hiding under the ‘NEP’ umbrella and hope to be spoon fed throughout generation after generation. Well, this preference given to the Bumiputera’s must be stopped. Everyone born in a land is actually a “Bumi Purtan” a tamil phrase that means the “prince of the soil”.
Please do a little research before writing, don’t be like the other Malay politicians who are showing to the world that they are incompetent in running the country. Wake up to reality.

If you’re a competent Malay ( I’m not sure if you’re a Malay or not), then please reply to this message.
God bless Malaysia.

That’s a good one, dawsheng. Have a happy new year! Oh, we’re not there yet? It is still Christmas?

No. It is because the Bangadeshi car washer does more of the washing and the Indian car washer works more for less.