Comments on: Urgent Parliament motion on Lingam Tape RCI - unacceptable chairman and unsatisfactory terms of reference http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/ for Malaysia Wed, 03 Dec 2008 08:25:30 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.6.5 By: EARNEST http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-65196 EARNEST Sun, 23 Dec 2007 20:20:47 +0000 http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-65196 Dear Shamshul Anuar, Besides the above 3 issues, viz., 1. Ethnic Cleansing, 2. ISA 3. Nepotism in DAP there is a fourth issue on illegal assemblies without police permit which had been debated extensively in this blog before, and being renewed under this thread: "PM/IGP - heed Nazrin/Musa, respect Constitution and allow peaceful demonstrations" I have said that it is wrong to deny police permits arbitrarily to prevent peaceful assemblies organized for the purpose of expressing legitimate grievances. Kindly let us have your opinion on this 4th issue. If you are agreeable with my opinion, please tell your UMNO friends that it is imperative to restore citizens’ constitutional right to peaceful assemblies, to pre-empt potentially violent eruptions of pent-up frustrations. Dear Shamshul Anuar,

Besides the above 3 issues, viz.,
1. Ethnic Cleansing,
2. ISA
3. Nepotism in DAP

there is a fourth issue on illegal assemblies without police permit which had been debated extensively in this blog before, and being renewed under this thread:

“PM/IGP - heed Nazrin/Musa, respect Constitution and allow peaceful demonstrations”

I have said that it is wrong to deny police permits arbitrarily to prevent peaceful assemblies organized for the purpose of expressing legitimate grievances.

Kindly let us have your opinion on this 4th issue. If you are agreeable with my opinion, please tell your UMNO friends that it is imperative to restore citizens’ constitutional right to peaceful assemblies, to pre-empt potentially violent eruptions of pent-up frustrations.

]]> By: ANALYSIS: Anwar checkmates Pak Lah’s election plans? « Jed Yoong http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-63099 ANALYSIS: Anwar checkmates Pak Lah’s election plans? « Jed Yoong Fri, 14 Dec 2007 15:37:15 +0000 http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-63099 [...] leaders voiced their disdain at the panel. Democratic Action Party icon Lim Kit Siang said Haidar was an “unacceptable chairman” and the terms of RC’s terms of [...] [...] leaders voiced their disdain at the panel. Democratic Action Party icon Lim Kit Siang said Haidar was an “unacceptable chairman” and the terms of RC’s terms of [...]

]]> By: budak http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-63061 budak Fri, 14 Dec 2007 09:11:16 +0000 http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-63061 please see Anwar's or PKR site for latest video clip... the credibility of current chairperson and former judges are questionable... they maybe the one "sumbat" Anwar into jail... Title: Video Penuh VK Lingam http://www.keadilanrakyat.org/index.php/content/view/456/1/ please see Anwar’s or PKR site for latest video clip… the credibility of current chairperson and former judges are questionable… they maybe the one “sumbat” Anwar into jail…

Title: Video Penuh VK Lingam
http://www.keadilanrakyat.org/index.php/content/view/456/1/

]]> By: sj http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-63041 sj Fri, 14 Dec 2007 06:52:46 +0000 http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-63041 Of all the people, they picked Haidar to lead the RCI. Good way to sabotage and undermine the RCI effort. I sure hope we all work together to shoot down Haidar before he screws things up bad. Of all the people, they picked Haidar to lead the RCI. Good way to sabotage and undermine the RCI effort. I sure hope we all work together to shoot down Haidar before he screws things up bad.

]]> By: undergrad2 http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-62906 undergrad2 Thu, 13 Dec 2007 17:13:04 +0000 http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-62906 "What does a historian know about the intricate workings and labyrinthine processes of the law? " Hornbill, We have too many crooked lawyers already. Placing another lawyer in charge is like putting a foxy lady in charge of a rich old man about to write his last will and testament and kick the bucket soon afterwards! “What does a historian know about the intricate workings and labyrinthine processes of the law? ”

Hornbill,

We have too many crooked lawyers already. Placing another lawyer in charge is like putting a foxy lady in charge of a rich old man about to write his last will and testament and kick the bucket soon afterwards!

]]> By: DarkHorse http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-62887 DarkHorse Thu, 13 Dec 2007 16:11:19 +0000 http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-62887 "A square peg in a round hole just won’t fit!" hORNBILL With a little help from my friend known by his initials KY, it should fit! “A square peg in a round hole just won’t fit!” hORNBILL

With a little help from my friend known by his initials KY, it should fit!

]]> By: ENDANGERED HORNBILL http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-62844 ENDANGERED HORNBILL Thu, 13 Dec 2007 13:23:48 +0000 http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-62844 Sorry, I just have to say this: Prof. Khoo Kay Kim should recuse himself from the RCI. Why? What does a historian know about the intricate workings and labyrinthine processes of the law? The fact that a CJ stands accused of impropriety bears upon constitutionalk and administrative law and a deep appreciation of the legal system (the role and functions of judges etc.etc.etc.). Prof. Khoo, you may be a nice man and even a competent historian but this RCI thing is definitely a subject for the legal mind; if you have to seek advice and understanding from other panel memebers and are not able to form an independent opinion without such input, then simply put, you are incompetent for the RCI. A square peg in a round hole just won't fit! Sorry, I just have to say this: Prof. Khoo Kay Kim should recuse himself from the RCI.

Why? What does a historian know about the intricate workings and labyrinthine processes of the law? The fact that a CJ stands accused of impropriety bears upon constitutionalk and administrative law and a deep appreciation of the legal system (the role and functions of judges etc.etc.etc.).

Prof. Khoo, you may be a nice man and even a competent historian but this RCI thing is definitely a subject for the legal mind; if you have to seek advice and understanding from other panel memebers and are not able to form an independent opinion without such input, then simply put, you are incompetent for the RCI. A square peg in a round hole just won’t fit!

]]> By: lakshy http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-62843 lakshy Thu, 13 Dec 2007 13:21:56 +0000 http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-62843 This pm is a real no-hoper. First he postponed the umno elections because of the General Elections supposed to be held this year. Now we are at the end of 2007, with no likelihood of an elections being held anytime soon. I guess even aab does not know when the next elections will be held. Its only Rashid who knows. Thats why rashids retirement had to be extended! This pm is a real no-hoper. First he postponed the umno elections because of the General Elections supposed to be held this year. Now we are at the end of 2007, with no likelihood of an elections being held anytime soon.

I guess even aab does not know when the next elections will be held. Its only Rashid who knows. Thats why rashids retirement had to be extended!

]]> By: sheriff singh http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-62798 sheriff singh Thu, 13 Dec 2007 11:22:41 +0000 http://blog.limkitsiang.com/2007/12/13/urgent-parliament-motion-on-lingam-tape-rci-unacceptable-chairman-and-unsatisfactory-terms-of-reference/#comment-62798 I am really surprised that some panel members actually accepted their appointments to the RCI knowing full well its narrow scope which will not stop the rotting Judiciary. 5 Chaps to consider the authenticity of the tape? Why not a "full bench" then? Its like looking at a tree while a forest fire wages all around. But Bolehlanders are typically myopic, have alot of wax in their big ears, suffer from foot in the mouth disease and pepetual sleepiness, and cannot walk the talk but only talk the cock and bull. But hey!! We are better off than Ghana!!! Look at the bright side. I am really surprised that some panel members actually accepted their appointments to the RCI knowing full well its narrow scope which will not stop the rotting Judiciary.

5 Chaps to consider the authenticity of the tape? Why not a “full bench” then? Its like looking at a tree while a forest fire wages all around.

But Bolehlanders are typically myopic, have alot of wax in their big ears, suffer from foot in the mouth disease and pepetual sleepiness, and cannot walk the talk but only talk the cock and bull.

But hey!! We are better off than Ghana!!! Look at the bright side.

]]>